Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - passededge
Pages: [1]

1
Pixel Art / Re: Critique on portrait
« on: October 22, 2010, 06:22:43 pm »


My initial response is that even for anime facial structure, the cheekbone on the left is far far too low, and at the very least does not seem to match up with the cheekbone on the opposite side of the face (as indicated by the light/shadow). Also, based on my (extremely slapdash) edit, the eyes may be off-center. Lastly, I would reckon that you could lose some colors, although I myself am not particularly obsessed with low color counts.

From a content point-of-view, the facial expression is very creepy/generic anime. Yes I understand that he is a fun-loving and golden-hearted youthful ne'er-do-well, or something, but I think the style carries that baggage and not the facial expression, if you follow. A portrait is an opportunity for the character to interact with the viewer as a person, (not necessarily by staring directly at them, mind.) Here he seems to be the victim of those unfortunate photographs taken of people mid-word.

Finally, this person has 3 'sides' of the whites of his eyes showing. Look at the link below for a highly unscientific explanation to why this may be a concern.

http://www.octogenariansblog.com/san-paku-three-sides-of-white-showing-in-the-eyes/

All that said, there is much to like in this picture, and I hope my nitpicking is helpful.



That's all very helpful, thanks a lot! I never noticed before, but I see what you mean by the cheekbone being too low.  Also, good call with the eyes -.-  His expression is supposed to be happy, and it's a talking portrait, so I don't know if his expression needs to be changed at all?

Thanks again!

2
Pixel Art / Critique on portrait
« on: October 22, 2010, 03:14:53 pm »
Hey everyone! I've been commissioning artists for a while now, and this is the first time I've tried something like this (even though I've wanted to for a while).

Basically I've received permission from the extremely talented tyvon http://www.wayofthepixel.net/pixelation/index.php?topic=10360.0 to post one of his pieces for critique.  It's for a game I'm working on, and while it looks great, everything without exception can be improved if you get good feedback from fellow artists.  So that's what I'm hoping for; some constructive criticism to improve the art that will be used in my game.

So here's the artwork  and here's the reference http://fc08.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2010/213/2/b/The_Alchemist_by_Jin_api.jpg The artist of the reference is Jin-api http://jin-api.deviantart.com/

I'm hoping a lot for feedback on the eyes, hair, mouth and marking on his cheek.

Thanks!

Pages: [1]