I'm definitely not talking about expanding "us" as a forum :p I'd die if the forum lost its tight, pixel-driven focus. Okay, die is a little dramatic, I'd probably suffer a mild headache for a few hours, maybe some vomiting
I meant "us" as individuals. I'd imagine the reason it's hard to find good index painting critique here is that many of us (myself wholly included) aren't very well equipped to give it. Even if it's not totally within the topic of the forum, it'd still be nice to be able to help people that post such pieces here, rare as they are.