Aside from actual critique, I'm still wondering more so why you refuse to say this can't be done in 1 hour.
I don't know myself, but if another member says they can, and if they really can, then who are you to say they can't? Maybe you can not do it because you haven't yet practiced enough, don't know/have the rights tools and shortcuts to make things that much quicker, and thus are slower than more experienced users, but that doesn't mean it's impossible, or anything.
I don't think there's really much of an argument to be had here.
Different people work at different speeds, you undoubtedly work slower than some of the people saying they can't make it faster.
If I'm misunderstanding something, let me know. Sorry for beating a dead horse.
Now, I'll go ahead, and once again, agree with everyone else, and say you shouldn't be so quick to dismiss their edits, I really like miscdudes version, probably due largely to personal taste, but it seems to appease me more than any other piece yet done.
You seem to be refuting practically everything everyone said or shared in this thread, from my observations.