Let’s be real. You’re standing in the office supply aisle, looking at a plastic box that costs more than your last grocery run, and you’re wondering how on earth a few milliliters of liquid could be this pricey. It’s the classic printer trap. You buy the hardware for $60, then realize the HP printing ink cartridges cost $40 a pop. It feels like a scam. Honestly, it kind of is, but there’s a massive technical reason why HP (and Epson and Canon) keeps it this way.
The industry calls it the "Razor and Blade" model. They sell the printer at a loss—sometimes losing $20 to $40 per unit—just to get it into your home. Once it’s on your desk, they’ve got you. You’re locked into their ecosystem. But if you understand how the tech actually works, you can stop overpaying.
The Chemistry Behind Your HP Printing Ink Cartridges
Most people think ink is just colored water. It isn't. HP spends millions every year on R&D for their proprietary thermal inkjet technology. When you hit "print," a tiny resistor in the cartridge heats up to roughly 300 degrees Celsius in a fraction of a second. This creates a vapor bubble that forces a droplet of ink through a nozzle thinner than a human hair.
If the ink isn't perfectly formulated, it clogs. If it's too thin, it bleeds. HP’s pigment-based inks, like those found in the 962 or 910 series, are designed to be water-resistant and fade-proof for decades. That’s why your family photos don't turn into a yellow blur after six months. Cheap third-party inks often use dyes instead of pigments. Dyes are basically food coloring. They look okay on day one, but they smear if your hand is slightly damp and they vanish under sunlight.
Why the "Low Ink" Warning is Often a Lie
Have you ever noticed your printer screaming that it’s empty, yet you still manage to print fifty more pages? It's annoying. HP uses smart chips on the bottom of the cartridge to track "ink consumption." The problem is these chips don't actually measure the liquid level; they estimate it based on page coverage and the number of cleaning cycles.
Sometimes the chip "times out" the cartridge before it's actually dry. This is a huge point of contention for consumer advocates. In 2022, HP faced a class-action lawsuit (handled by the Northern District of California) regarding their "Dynamic Security" firmware updates. These updates essentially "bricked" printers if they detected a non-HP chip. While HP claims this is to protect the printhead from damage caused by poor-quality ink, critics argue it’s just a way to kill the competition.
🔗 Read more: Smart TV TCL 55: What Most People Get Wrong
Instant Ink: The Subscription You Probably Don't Need
You’ve probably seen the pop-ups for HP Instant Ink. It’s a monthly subscription service where the printer "calls home" and tells HP to mail you new cartridges before you run out.
It sounds convenient. For some people, it is. But here is the catch: you aren't paying for ink. You are paying for pages.
If you print a single dot on a piece of paper, that’s one page. If you print a high-resolution, full-color 8x10 photo, that’s also one page. If you print a lot of photos, Instant Ink is a steal. If you just print black-and-white text documents for school or work, you’re almost certainly losing money. Plus, the second you cancel the subscription, those cartridges—even if they are full—stop working. HP remotely disables them. It’s a digital leash that keeps you tethered to their billing system.
The Third-Party Gamble
Can you use "remanufactured" or "compatible" HP printing ink cartridges?
Yes. Usually.
💡 You might also like: Savannah Weather Radar: What Most People Get Wrong
But you need to know what you’re getting into. A remanufactured cartridge is just an old HP shell that’s been cleaned, refilled, and fitted with a new (or reset) chip. Companies like LD Products or 123Inkjets do a decent job. However, because HP constantly pushes firmware updates to your printer via Wi-Fi, there’s always a chance that your "off-brand" ink will suddenly stop working.
If you decide to go this route, turn off "Auto-Updates" in your printer settings immediately. This prevents HP from sending a "killer" update that rejects your third-party cartridges. Also, keep in mind that if a generic cartridge leaks and ruins your printhead, HP’s warranty won't cover the repair. It’s a risk-reward calculation. For an old $50 printer? Go for it. For a $400 OfficeJet Pro? Maybe stick to the real stuff.
XL Cartridges vs. Standard
Always buy the XL. It’s basic math. A standard HP 63 cartridge might hold 3.5ml of ink, while the 63XL holds 8.5ml. The XL usually costs about 40% more but gives you over double the prints. The "cost per page" drops significantly. If you’re buying standard capacity cartridges, you’re essentially paying a "convenience tax" for the plastic housing every single time.
How to Make Your Ink Last Twice as Long
Most people waste 20% of their ink on "maintenance." Every time you turn your printer on and off, it runs a cleaning cycle. This spits ink into a waste pad inside the machine to keep the nozzles clear.
If you only print once a week, leave the printer on. Modern HP printers have a low-power "sleep" mode that uses almost zero electricity. By leaving it on, the printer won't feel the need to do a "deep clean" every time you wake it up.
📖 Related: Project Liberty Explained: Why Frank McCourt Wants to Buy TikTok and Fix the Internet
Also, change your default font.
Seriously.
Fonts like Arial and Times New Roman are ink hogs. "Ecofont" or even "Century Gothic" use significantly less ink because the lines are thinner or have tiny holes in them that aren't visible to the naked eye. Switch your printer settings to "Draft Mode" for everything except final documents. You’ll barely notice the difference in quality, but your HP printing ink cartridges will survive a lot longer.
What About Those "Tank" Printers?
If you are tired of the cartridge game, HP’s Smart Tank series is the alternative. Instead of buying plastic cartridges with chips, you buy bottles of ink and pour them into reservoirs.
The upfront cost is higher. You might pay $300 for the printer. But a single set of ink bottles can last for two years or 6,000 pages. If you print more than 20 pages a week, stop buying cartridges. Throw your old inkjet away and get a tank printer. The math doesn't lie. Over three years, you'll save hundreds of dollars.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Print Job
Stop blindly clicking "buy" on the first ink replacement you see. Follow these steps to actually control your printing costs:
- Check your firmware: If you want to use third-party ink, go into your printer settings on the tiny screen or the web interface and disable "Cartridge Policy" and "Auto-Updates."
- Calculate your CPP: Divide the price of the cartridge by the estimated page yield. If your cost per page is over $0.05 for black and white, you're getting ripped off.
- Print a Test Page Weekly: Inkjet ink dries out. If you don't print for a month, the ink in the nozzles will turn into a crusty plug. You’ll end up using half a cartridge just trying to "clean" the clog. Print one small color image every Sunday to keep the "plumbing" clear.
- Recycle for Credit: Don't throw old cartridges in the trash. Staples and Office Depot often give you $2 in store credit for every empty HP cartridge you bring in. It's an easy way to subsidize your next purchase.
The world of printing is designed to be confusing. It thrives on your frustration and your need for a quick document. By switching to XL sizes, avoiding unnecessary subscriptions, and keeping your nozzles moist, you take the power back from the manufacturer. You bought the printer; you should decide how much it costs to run it.