How to finger yourself as a guy: What most people get wrong about prostate play

How to finger yourself as a guy: What most people get wrong about prostate play

Let's be real for a second. Most guys grew up with a pretty limited map of their own bodies. We’re taught about the "main event" up front, but the rest of the terrain is often left completely off the charts. It’s kinda strange when you think about it. If you’re looking into how to finger yourself as a guy, you aren't just exploring a new sensation; you're tapping into what many doctors and sex therapists, like Dr. Evan Goldstein or the late sexologist Betty Dodson, have long called the "male G-spot."

It’s the prostate.

Honestly, the learning curve here is more about relaxation than it is about some secret technique. If you’re tense, it’s not going to feel good. Period. You have to approach this with the same patience you'd use for any other hobby—except this one has much better payoffs.

The anatomy of it all

Before you dive in, you need to know what you’re actually looking for. The prostate is a small, walnut-sized gland. It sits about two to three inches inside the rectum, toward the front of the body (the belly button side). When it’s stimulated correctly, it doesn't just feel "okay"—it can trigger intense, full-body orgasms that feel fundamentally different from a standard penile climax.

But here is the thing. The internal anal sphincter is a literal gatekeeper. It is a ring of muscle that reacts to pressure by tightening up. That is its job. To get past it, you have to trick it into relaxing. If you just shove a finger in there? Ouch. That’s how you end up with fissures or just a really bad Saturday night. You’ve got to be methodical.

Prep work and the "must-haves"

Do not skip the lube. Seriously. The tissue inside the rectum is delicate and doesn't produce its own moisture like other parts of the body might. You want a high-quality, water-based lubricant. Why water-based? Because if you decide to use silicone toys later, water-based lube won't degrade the material. Plus, it’s easier to clean off your sheets. Brands like Sliquid or Uberlube are often cited by pelvic health experts because they lack harsh chemicals like glycerin or parabens that can irritate sensitive membranes.

Trim your nails. This sounds obvious, but a single jagged edge can turn a session into a medical incident. Scrub your hands. Use soap.

Setting the stage

Relaxation isn't just a mental state; it’s physiological. Take a hot shower. Maybe put on some music that doesn't make you feel like you're in a waiting room. The goal is to lower your heart rate. When your nervous system is in "rest and digest" mode (parasympathetic), those internal muscles loosen up naturally.

How to finger yourself as a guy: The step-by-step reality

Start externally. Don't even think about going inside yet. Use a generous amount of lube and massage the perineum—that’s the space between the scrotum and the anus. This area is packed with nerve endings. Spend five minutes here. Just breathe.

When you feel ready, place a lubricated finger against the opening. Don't push. Just let it rest there.

Wait for the "wink."

That’s the technical term for when the sphincter relaxes and slightly opens. Once that happens, slowly slide your finger in up to the first knuckle. Stop. Breathe again. If it feels tight, back off a little. You are in charge here.

Finding the prize

Once you are in past the second knuckle, curl your finger toward your belly button in a "come hither" motion. You're looking for a firm, slightly rounded bump. It might feel a bit like the tip of a nose or a small chestnut. That’s the prostate.

For some guys, the first time they touch it, it feels like they suddenly need to pee. That’s normal. It’s just the gland being compressed near the bladder. If you keep the pressure light and rhythmic, that "I need to pee" feeling usually transforms into a deep, heavy heat.

Why it feels different for everyone

Some men prefer a tapping motion. Others like steady, firm pressure. There is no "correct" way to do this, only the way that works for your specific nervous system. It's also worth noting that the prostate can be sensitive. If it feels "boggy" or painful, stop. Persistent pain in this area can sometimes indicate prostatitis—an inflammation of the gland—and that’s something you’d want to mention to a urologist.

The "come hither" motion is the gold standard, but don't be afraid to experiment with side-to-side movements. You're basically mapping out your own internal geography. Every body is shaped slightly differently.

Hygiene and the "ick" factor

Let's address the elephant in the room. It’s the butt. There might be a bit of a mess.

It’s fine.

Most people find that a simple bowel movement and a quick shower beforehand is plenty of prep. You don't need a full-on medical enema. Lay down a towel you don't care about. Keep some wet wipes nearby. If you’re really worried about it, you can wear nitrile gloves, which also helps if you’re worried about your fingernails.

Moving beyond the basics

Once you’ve mastered how to finger yourself as a guy, you might find that your hand gets tired. This is usually when people start looking at toys. Specifically, "P-spot" vibrators or A-line stimulators. These are curved to hit that exact spot without the awkward wrist angles.

But honestly? Fingers are the best way to start because they provide immediate sensory feedback. You can feel exactly how your muscles are reacting. You can't get that from a piece of silicone.

💡 You might also like: Is Protein in Fruit Actually a Real Thing? What Most People Get Wrong

Actionable steps for your first session

  • Buy the right lube: Avoid anything with "tingling" or "cooling" sensations for internal use. Stick to simple, high-viscosity water-based options.
  • The 10-minute rule: Spend at least ten minutes on external stimulation and general relaxation before attempting any internal entry.
  • Short nails, long patience: Check your hands for any cuts or hangnails.
  • Positioning: Most guys find it easiest to lie on their side with knees tucked toward the chest (the fetal position) or lying on their back with feet flat on the bed.
  • Breathe through the resistance: If you feel a "push back" from your muscles, exhale deeply. Your pelvic floor drops when you exhale, making entry significantly easier.
  • Post-session care: Wash up with mild, unscented soap. If you feel any lingering discomfort, a warm bath can help soothe the muscles.

Exploring this part of your body isn't just about the climax. It's about body literacy. Understanding how your prostate reacts to touch can lead to better sexual health, improved pelvic floor awareness, and, yeah, some of the best sensations you've ever had. Just take it slow, use way more lube than you think you need, and listen to what your body is telling you.