You're standing at the stove in Chez Remy, staring at a pile of fish and jars, wondering why on earth your recipe just turned into a pile of "Hard-Boiled Eggs" or some other culinary disaster. We've all been there. Disney Dreamlight Valley is a cozy game, sure, but the cooking system can be a real pain if you don't know the specific logic behind it. Pickled Herring is one of those recipes that sounds simple—I mean, it’s just fish and vinegar, right?—but the game has a very specific "Order of Operations" that trips up even veteran players.
It's not just a random snack. You need this stuff. Whether you're trying to power through Elsa’s friendship quests or just trying to fill out that massive collection log, mastering the art of the pickled fish is a rite of passage in the Valley.
The Recipe Most People Mess Up
Let's get the basic chemistry out of the way. To make Pickled Herring, you need exactly four ingredients. No more, no less. If you add a fifth, you’re probably making a different 5-star meal, and if you miss one, you’re stuck with a generic grilled fish dish.
Here is the lineup:
- Herring (Obviously)
- Lemon
- Onion
- Any Spice (Oregano or Basil are the easiest to find)
Now, here is where the confusion usually starts. There is a different recipe called Arendellian Pickled Herring. People get these two mixed up constantly because the names are almost identical. If you are doing Elsa’s quest "What Home Feels Like," she specifically wants the Arendellian version, which requires Garlic and a Glittering Herring. If you just want the standard Pickled Herring for a gift or a meal, stick to the four items above.
Where to Find the Goods
You can't just wish these items into your inventory. Well, you can if you have a ton of Dreamlight to spend on Woodys' stall or something, but usually, you've gotta grind.
The Herring is a white-ripple fish. Don't go chasing the gold or blue ripples if this is all you need. Head to Dazzle Beach or the Glade of Trust. I personally prefer the Glade because the layout is tighter and you can lap the ponds faster.
Lemons are a bit of a trek if you’re early in the game. They grow on trees in the Glade of Trust and the Forest of Valor. Pro tip: move your trees into a single "orchard" area using the furniture mode. It saves you from running across the entire map just to grab two fruits.
Onions are the bottleneck. You have to unlock Goofy’s Stall in the Forest of Valor. If he’s only selling seeds, you’re gonna have to wait about 75 minutes for them to grow. It’s annoying. I usually buy a stack of 50 seeds and just keep a chest full of onions because so many high-level recipes require them.
Spices are the easiest part. Just grab the purple plants growing out of the ground in the Plaza (Oregano) or the Peaceful Meadow (Basil). Either one works perfectly fine for Pickled Herring.
Why Pickled Herring is a Strategic Powerhouse
You might think, "Why bother?"
Energy. That's why.
Pickled Herring is a 4-star meal. In the current 2026 meta of Dreamlight Valley, maximizing your "Well Fed" bonus (that yellow bar that makes you run faster) is essential for efficient resource gathering. While berry salads are the old-school favorite, a 4-star meal provides a massive chunk of stamina that keeps that golden glow active way longer.
Honestly, it’s also about the Star Path. Gameloft loves throwing "Cook 10 4-star meals" or "Cook a meal using Lemon" into the duties list. Pickled Herring checks multiple boxes at once. It’s a versatile tool in your progression kit.
The Arendellian Variant: A Warning
I touched on this earlier, but it's worth its own section because it breaks people's brains. Arendellian Pickled Herring is a 5-star dish.
It requires:
- Herring
- Lemon
- Onion
- Garlic
- Oregano/Basil
If you add Garlic to the standard recipe, you automatically upgrade it to the Arendellian version. If you're trying to finish a specific "Cook 4-star meals" task, adding that extra clove of garlic will actually fail the task because you made a 5-star meal instead. The game is literal like that. Use exactly what is required.
Common Mistakes and How to Fix Them
I've seen players try to use the Glittering Herring for standard Pickled Herring. Don't do that. The Glittering Herring is a unique quest item caught during rainy weather specifically for Elsa. If you use it in a generic recipe, you might find yourself waiting for the next rainstorm just to progress your questline. It’s a headache you don't need.
Another slip-up? Using the wrong fish.
✨ Don't miss: The Brutal Context Behind My Death Brings Flames
The game has "Any Fish" recipes and "Specific Fish" recipes. Pickled Herring must have the silver-scaled Herring. Substituting a Bass or a Cod will result in a "Savory Fish" dish. It won't look the same, it won't sell for the same price, and it definitely won't satisfy a villager's "Favorite Thing of the Day" requirement.
Energy and Value Breakdown
| Stat | Value |
|---|---|
| Star Rating | 4 Stars |
| Energy Restored | ~1,746 (Varies slightly based on spice) |
| Sell Price | ~431 Star Coins |
Compare this to a simple Grilled Fish which barely gives you 500 energy. You're getting triple the utility for just a little more legwork in the Glade of Trust.
The Expert Workflow for Mass Production
If you’re looking to stock up, don't just cook one by one. Use the "Autofill" feature if you've unlocked the Ancient Vacuum or the specific cooking stations from the A Rift in Time expansion (if you have the DLC). Even without those, the standard stove now allows for multiple-meal crafting as of recent updates.
- Clear your inventory except for the four key ingredients.
- Sort by "Fish" at the stove to find Herring quickly.
- Use the History Tab. Once you make it once, you can just click the recipe in your history and it will pull the ingredients automatically. This saves you from hunting through the vegetable and fruit tabs every single time.
A Note on Villager Gifts
Pickled Herring is a frequent "Favorite Gift" for characters like Elsa, Kristoff, and even Donald Duck. Keeping a stack of five in your storage is a smart move. It's much faster to pull one from a chest than it is to stop what you're doing, gather lemons, and find a stove every time a favorite gift resets.
Actionable Steps to Master the Recipe
To ensure you never fail this recipe again and maximize its benefits in your game, follow this exact sequence:
- Stockpile Onions Early: Since they take over an hour to grow, plant a plot of 20-30 onions in the Forest of Valor. The "Growth Boost" from being planted in their native biome means they’ll be ready faster than if you planted them in the Plaza.
- Check the Weather: If it’s raining, go for the Herring. The spawn rates for white ripples seem more consistent during weather shifts, and you might accidentally snag a Fugu or a Glittering Herring while you're at it.
- Double-Check the Stars: Before hitting "Start Cooking," look at the top left of the pot. If you see 4 stars, you're making Pickled Herring. If you see 5 stars, you've accidentally added an extra ingredient (like Garlic) and are making the Arendellian version.
- Save Your Lemons: Lemons are used in several high-energy recipes like Blueberry Pie and various fish dishes. Never sell them raw; always cook them into a 4-star or 5-star meal to quadruple their value in Star Coins.
Making Pickled Herring is one of the first "intermediate" steps in becoming a Dreamlight Valley pro. It moves you away from simple 1-ingredient snacks and into the realm of high-efficiency gameplay. Keep your onions growing, your lemons picked, and your spice rack full. Your energy bar—and Elsa—will thank you.
Once you have the ingredients gathered, head to any cooking station, select your Herring, Lemon, Onion, and Herb, and you'll have a stack of Pickled Herring ready for whatever the Valley throws at you next.
---