Numbers don't lie, but they sure do hide things. If you’ve spent any time scrolling through news feeds lately, you’ve likely seen the headlines screaming about "murder capitals" and "war zones" in American streets. It's scary stuff. Honestly, most of us just want to know if our own neighborhoods are safe or if that weekend trip to a new city is a bad idea.
But here is the thing: the highest murders in us by city isn't just a list of names like St. Louis or Baltimore. It’s a moving target.
By the start of 2026, the landscape of urban violence in the United States has shifted in ways that experts didn't entirely see coming a few years ago. We’re seeing a strange "decoupling" of crime. In some places, total crime is plummeting while the most extreme violence—homicide—stays stubbornly high. In others, the numbers are finally dropping to levels we haven't seen since the 1960s.
👉 See also: Quién es el presidente de Israel y por qué su oficina es distinta a la de Netanyahu
The Per-Capita Trap: Why Total Numbers Miss the Point
If you just look at a raw count of bodies, Chicago usually looks like the "deadliest" city. It's a massive place. More people means more everything—more coffee shops, more traffic jams, and unfortunately, more crime.
But that's a lazy way to look at safety.
Real insight comes from the homicide rate. This is the number of murders for every 100,000 people. It levels the playing field. When you look at it this way, the "dangerous" label shifts away from the mega-hubs like New York City or Los Angeles (which are actually incredibly safe on a per-capita basis) and moves toward medium-sized cities in the Midwest and South.
The Heavy Hitters of 2025 and 2026
According to data consolidated from the Council on Criminal Justice (CCJ) and preliminary 2025 year-end reports, a few cities remain consistently at the top of this grim leaderboard:
- St. Louis, Missouri: It’s been at or near #1 for years. With a homicide rate often hovering around 60 to 70 per 100,000 residents, it remains a focal point for researchers. The violence is often hyper-localized in specific northside neighborhoods, creating a "tale of two cities" dynamic.
- New Orleans, Louisiana: The "Big Easy" hasn't been so easy lately. In late 2024 and throughout 2025, New Orleans saw significant spikes, sometimes overtaking St. Louis for the top spot.
- Birmingham, Alabama: This is a city that often flies under the radar in national conversations but has a murder rate that rivals much larger metros.
- Baltimore, Maryland: There’s a bit of a silver lining here. While Baltimore is still high on the list, 2025 saw a massive 56% decrease in homicides in certain quarters—the largest drop in the country. It's a sign that local interventions might actually be working.
The "Great Decelerations" of 2025
You’ve probably heard people say crime is "out of control."
Well, that's not exactly true everywhere. 2025 was actually a year of massive improvement for several major hubs. Detroit, for instance, recorded just 165 homicides in 2025. That might sound like a lot, but for Detroit, it’s the lowest number since 1964.
Basically, the "urban apocalypse" narrative is hitting a wall.
Even Memphis, which topped the "Total Crime" charts in 2024 with a staggering 2,501 violent crimes per 100,000 people, started seeing a downward trend in early 2025. Why? Most experts, like those at the Rochester Institute of Technology, point to a return to "normalcy" after the chaos of the pandemic years. The social friction caused by lockdowns and the disruption of local drug markets is finally starting to smooth out.
What Drives These Stats? (It’s Not Just "Bad People")
Talking about the highest murders in us by city without talking about why is useless. It’s like diagnosing a fever without looking for the infection.
👉 See also: Moore OK tornado path: Why the same neighborhoods keep getting hit
Research from the Evolutionary Human Sciences journal suggests that violence spikes most where resources are both scarce and unequally distributed. It’s the "scarcity plus inequality" cocktail. When people feel like the "system" is rigged and they have no legitimate way to secure a future, high-risk activities—including lethal violence—become a desperate form of social and material competition.
There's also the "Lethality" factor.
The Council on Criminal Justice noted a terrifying trend: while the number of violent incidents (like robberies) went down in 2024 and 2025, the lethality of those incidents went up. Essentially, when people do fight, they are more likely to use a gun, and those guns are more likely to be used with deadly intent. In Washington, D.C., for example, the lethality rate rose 38% recently, even as other crime metrics stabilized.
Misconceptions That Mess With Your Head
People love to blame "progressive prosecutors" or "tough-on-crime" policies for these numbers.
The data doesn't really support either side clearly.
Cities with extremely aggressive "law and order" budgets saw the same 2020-2021 spikes as cities that experimented with bail reform. The truth is much more boring: homicide is mostly driven by local gang dynamics, the availability of illegal firearms, and something called "legal cynicism"—which is just a fancy way of saying people don't trust the police to help them, so they take matters into their own hands.
Surprising Safety: The Cities You Think are Dangerous
- New York City: It’s the media's favorite punching bag. Yet, in 2025, NYC’s murder rate was roughly 4.7 per 100,000. That’s lower than some sleepy suburban areas.
- Los Angeles: Despite the "no-go zone" rumors, LA’s rate has dropped to around 7.1.
- Boston: Often overlooked, Boston is consistently one of the safest large cities in America, with a rate that plummeted 27% recently.
How to Actually Use This Information
If you're looking at these stats because you're moving or traveling, don't just look at the city name. Look at the neighborhood. In almost every city with the highest murders in us, the violence is concentrated in less than 5% of the city's street blocks.
If you want to stay safe or help your community, here are the real-world takeaways:
- Check the "Clearance Rate": A city’s ability to solve murders (the clearance rate) is a better indicator of future safety than the number of murders themselves. If the police can’t catch shooters, more shootings happen.
- Support Micro-Interventions: Programs like "Violence Interrupters," which use former gang members to mediate disputes before they turn lethal, have shown more success in Baltimore and Richmond than traditional "sweeps."
- Don't Panic Over Percentages: If a small town has 1 murder one year and 2 the next, the news will say "Murders Jump 100%!" It’s a trick. Always look at the raw numbers and the per-capita rate.
The reality of American violence is complex. It's not a straight line up or down. While 2026 shows a country that is generally getting safer, the "capitals" of violence remain stuck in a cycle of poverty and lack of trust that no single police budget or law can fix overnight.
To get the most accurate picture for your specific area, you should check the FBI's Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) dashboard or the latest quarterly updates from the Council on Criminal Justice, as these are updated far more frequently than the viral "top 10" lists you see on social media.
Actionable Insight: If you are researching a city for relocation, prioritize looking at "Part I" violent crime trends over a three-year period rather than a single year's homicide spike. This provides a more stable picture of the area's actual safety trajectory.