You’re standing on a street corner in Manhattan, looking at a map that makes everything look like a simple grid, and you think getting from New York to Brooklyn is just a matter of crossing a bridge. Technically, sure. But honestly, if you just wing it, you’re probably going to end up stuck on a stalled L train or paying $60 for an Uber that moves slower than a jogger. New York City geography is tricky because "New York" usually means Manhattan to locals, but Brooklyn is actually the most populous borough. It's massive.
It’s about 70 square miles of land.
Choosing how to cross the East River depends entirely on whether you’re heading to the hipster cafes of Williamsburg, the brownstones of Brooklyn Heights, or the salt-aired boardwalk of Coney Island. People mess this up by assuming every train goes everywhere. They don't. You need a strategy, or you'll waste half your afternoon underground.
The Subway Reality Check
The subway is the lifeblood of the city, but it’s also a chaotic mess sometimes. Most people trying to get from New York to Brooklyn instinctively head for the L train. It’s the "cool" train. It takes you straight from 14th Street in Manhattan to the heart of North Brooklyn. However, the L is notorious for weekend construction. If you see a sign that says "Planned Service Changes," believe it.
I’ve seen tourists wait 30 minutes for a train that was never coming because they didn't read the crumpled paper taped to the station pillar.
The A and C lines are your workhorses for Downtown Brooklyn. The A is express; the C is local. If you’re at Port Authority or Penn Station, these are your best bets. They feel grittier than the shiny new R211 cars, but they get the job done. Then you have the 2, 3, 4, and 5 lines. These are the "IRT" lines—the numbered ones—and they generally run under Lexington Avenue or Seventh Avenue in Manhattan before diving under the river to Atlantic Avenue-Barclays Center.
Atlantic Avenue is the "Grand Central" of Brooklyn. If you can get there, you can get anywhere.
Don't forget the Q train. Honestly, the Q is the best ride in the city. Why? Because it crosses the Manhattan Bridge instead of going through a tunnel. For about sixty seconds, you get this stunning, cinematic view of the Brooklyn Bridge and the skyline. It’s better than any paid tour. If you’re heading to Prospect Park or Ditmas Park, stay on the Q. It’s fast, it’s reliable (mostly), and the views are free.
The "Secret" G Train
You won't use the G train to get from Manhattan to Brooklyn because the G is the only major line that doesn't enter Manhattan. It stays in Brooklyn and Queens. But you need to know about it. If you’re in Brooklyn and want to move between neighborhoods—like going from Greenpoint to Park Slope—the G is your only hope unless you want to trek all the way into Manhattan and back out again. It’s a short train, so stand in the middle of the platform or you’ll be sprinting when it pulls in.
Walking the Bridge (And Avoiding the Bikes)
Walking from New York to Brooklyn via the Brooklyn Bridge is a rite of passage. It's beautiful. It's iconic. It’s also a nightmare if you go at 2:00 PM on a Saturday.
The bridge underwent a massive change a couple of years ago. The city finally moved the bike lane to the main roadway, which means pedestrians now have the entire upper wooden boardwalk to themselves. No more angry cyclists screaming "get out of the bike lane!" while you’re trying to take a selfie. It takes about 30 to 45 minutes to walk across at a casual pace.
Start on the Manhattan side near City Hall.
Pro tip: Walk toward Brooklyn. Most people do the opposite, but the view of the Brooklyn skyline and the Manhattan Bridge to your left is underrated. Once you hit the Brooklyn side, you’re dumped right into DUMBO (Down Under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass). You’ll see the famous spot on Washington Street where the Manhattan Bridge is framed by brick buildings. It’s the most photographed street in the borough.
If the Brooklyn Bridge is too crowded, try the Manhattan Bridge. It’s louder because the subway trains rumble right next to you, but the views of the Brooklyn Bridge itself are actually better from there. Plus, there are way fewer tourists.
The NYC Ferry: The Best $4.50 You’ll Spend
If you have some extra time, stop thinking about the subway. The NYC Ferry is the most civilized way to travel from New York to Brooklyn. It’s not the Staten Island Ferry; it’s a separate system of smaller, sleek boats.
The East River route starts at 34th Street or Wall Street/Pier 11. It stops at:
- Hunters Point South (Queens)
- Greenpoint
- North Williamsburg
- South Williamsburg
- DUMBO
It costs $4.50 for a single ride (as of late 2024/2025 pricing). You can sit on the top deck with the wind in your hair and watch the city go by. It’s glorious. Most locals use the NYC Ferry app to buy tickets because the machines at the docks always have a line. Just remember that the ferry doesn't run as frequently as the subway. Check the schedule. If you miss a boat, you might be waiting 20 or 30 minutes for the next one.
💡 You might also like: Thrifty Car Rental Indianapolis International Airport: Is It Actually the Best Deal in Indy?
Car Services and the BQE Trap
Uber, Lyft, and Revel (the blue Teslas) are everywhere. Taking a car from New York to Brooklyn is tempting when you have luggage or it's raining. But you have to account for the bridges and the tunnels.
The Brooklyn-Battery Tunnel (officially the Hugh L. Carey Tunnel) is the fastest way from Lower Manhattan to Red Hook or South Brooklyn, but it has a toll. If your driver takes it, that toll is added to your fare. Then there’s the BQE—the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway. This road is a structural marvel and a traffic disaster. It’s almost always jammed.
If you’re traveling during rush hour (8-10 AM or 4-7 PM), the subway will almost always beat a car. By a lot.
Hidden Gems Along the Way
Most people just want to get to their destination, but the transition between the boroughs is where the character of the city lives. If you’re taking the L train, get off at the first stop in Brooklyn: Bedford Avenue. It’s the epicenter of "New" Brooklyn.
If you’re taking the F train, get off at York Street. You’ll be in a deep underground station that feels like a bunker, but when you walk out, you’re in the heart of DUMBO’s cobblestone streets.
There's a specific magic to the transition. You leave the vertical intensity of Manhattan and suddenly the sky opens up. The buildings get shorter. The air feels slightly different.
Practical Logistics and Fares
To get from New York to Brooklyn, you no longer need a physical MetroCard. The OMNY system is everywhere. You just tap your credit card, phone, or watch at the turnstile. It works for the subway and buses.
- Subway/Bus Fare: $2.90.
- OMNY Cap: If you tap 12 times in a week (Monday-Sunday), every ride after that is free.
- Ferry Fare: $4.50 (not part of the OMNY system).
- LIRR: If you’re going from Penn Station or Grand Central to Atlantic Terminal, you can take the Long Island Rail Road. It’s faster and cleaner but costs more (check "CityTicket" off-peak rates for a discount).
Misconceptions About the Trip
One big mistake is thinking you can walk between all the Brooklyn neighborhoods easily. You can't. Walking from Williamsburg to Coney Island would take you about four hours. Brooklyn is a collection of villages.
Another misconception: "The subway is dangerous at night."
Look, it’s a big city. Be aware of your surroundings. But thousands of people use the subway to get from New York to Brooklyn at 2:00 AM every single day. Stick to the cars where there are other people. If a car is completely empty, there’s usually a reason (like a broken AC or a bad smell). Move to the next one.
👉 See also: Gothic Bridge Central Park New York: What Most People Get Wrong
Actionable Steps for Your Trip
- Download Citymapper: Forget Google Maps for a second. Citymapper is much better at handling NYC subway delays and telling you exactly which subway exit to use. It saves you from walking three blocks in the wrong direction.
- Check MTA.info: Before you head out, check the "Service Status." If the line you need is yellow or red, look for an alternative.
- Avoid the "Empty Car": I’ll repeat it because it’s vital. An empty subway car on a crowded train is a trap.
- Walk the bridge early: If you want those "empty bridge" photos, you need to be there at sunrise. By 9:00 AM, the crowds arrive.
- Buy Ferry tickets in advance: Use the app. Don't be the person fumbling with a credit card at the pier while the boat pulls away.
- Atlantic Terminal is your North Star: If you get lost in Brooklyn, find your way back to Atlantic Avenue-Barclays Center. Almost every major train line meets there, and it’s the easiest place to catch a ride back into Manhattan.
Brooklyn isn't just a suburb of Manhattan; it's the heart of the city's creative and residential life. Crossing over is more than a commute—it's how you actually see New York.