Let’s be real. Nobody actually wants to spend their vacation budget on a hunk of metal sitting in a parking garage. You’re landing at IND—which, by the way, is consistently voted one of the best airports in North America—and you just want to get to Speedway, Broad Ripple, or downtown without getting fleeced. That’s usually where thrifty car rental indianapolis international airport enters the chat. It’s the brand people pick when they see that insanely low daily rate on Expedia or Kayak and think, "Yeah, I can live with a slightly older Nissan Sentra if it saves me fifty bucks."
But Indianapolis is a weird rental market.
Unlike Chicago or Atlanta, Indy’s airport is compact, efficient, and surprisingly easy to navigate. However, the Ground Transportation Center (GTC) can still feel like a maze if you're lugging three suitcases and a car seat. Thrifty operates out of this central hub, which is basically a massive garage connected to the terminal by a climate-controlled pedestrian bridge. No shuttles. No waiting in the freezing Indiana wind. Just a long walk.
The Reality of Picking Up a Car at IND
Most people assume every rental counter is the same. They aren't. At the Indianapolis International Airport, the rental counters are lined up like soldiers in the GTC. Thrifty shares a lot of its DNA (and sometimes its fleet) with Dollar and Hertz because they’re all part of the Hertz Corporation.
If you’ve booked a "Manager’s Special," don't expect a luxury SUV. You’re likely getting whatever is clean and available, which could range from a Chevy Spark to a high-mileage Ford Focus. The convenience here is the lack of a shuttle bus. You walk across the bridge from the terminal, hit the escalator, and you're at the counter.
One thing local travelers know that outsiders don't: the "Indy 500 Factor." If you are booking thrifty car rental indianapolis international airport during the month of May, specifically Memorial Day weekend, the rules of physics and economics basically break. Rates that were $40 a day in April will skyrocket to $200. Supply vanishes. If you show up without a confirmed reservation during race week, you’re basically walking or calling a very expensive Uber.
Why the "Thrifty" Price Tag Sometimes Lies
Budget brands get a bad rap for "hidden fees," but in Indianapolis, most of those fees are actually local taxes and airport recovery charges that every company has to pay. You’re going to see an Indiana Auto Rental Excise Tax and a Marion County Supplemental Auto Rental Excise Tax.
Honestly, it adds up.
👉 See also: 3000 Yen to USD: What Your Money Actually Buys in Japan Today
If your base rate is $30, don't be shocked when the total is $48. That’s just the cost of doing business in Marion County. Thrifty tends to keep their base rates lower to compensate for these "pass-through" costs.
The Blue Chip Program: A Legitimate Life Hack
If you hate standing in lines—and the line at the Thrifty counter can get gnarly on a Monday morning when business travelers are descending on the city—you need the Blue Chip Rewards program. It’s free. It basically lets you skip the main counter in many cases or at least move into a shorter line.
Is the Thrifty fleet at IND brand new? Not usually.
You might find a car with 30,000 miles on it and a couple of mystery stains on the floor mats. If you want the "new car smell," you go to the National Emerald Aisle across the way and pay double. If you want a car that gets you from point A to point B for the price of a decent steak dinner, you stay in the Thrifty lane.
Navigating the Indianapolis Airport Rental Return
Returning a car at IND is actually one of the smoothest experiences in the Midwest. You follow the signs for "Cell Phone Lot" and then "Rental Car Return" as you approach the airport via Col. H. Weir Cook Memorial Dr.
Here is the kicker: the gas stations immediately surrounding the airport (like the ones off the Sam Jones Expressway) have historically higher prices.
Pro Tip: If you’re coming from the north, hit a Speedway or a GetGo in Plainfield or Avon before you get within three miles of the terminal. You’ll save about 40 cents a gallon. Thrifty, like most agencies, will charge you a king's ransom—often upwards of $9 per gallon—if you bring the car back half-empty.
✨ Don't miss: The Eloise Room at The Plaza: What Most People Get Wrong
The Under-the-Radar Challenges
Indiana weather is erratic. In January, a "Dusting" can turn into a sheet of ice in twenty minutes. Thrifty’s fleet at IND consists largely of Front-Wheel Drive (FWD) sedans. If you’re heading out to rural parts of the state or the hilly regions of Southern Indiana during a snowstorm, a base-model compact might struggle.
Also, check your tires. Seriously.
Before you leave the GTC garage, walk around the car. Check the tread depth. If they look bald and there’s a blizzard forecasted for your trip to Bloomington, go back to the desk and politely ask for a swap. They usually have a few All-Wheel Drive (AWD) crossovers tucked away, though they might try to upsell you.
What About Insurance and Tolls?
Indiana isn't a "toll heavy" state compared to Illinois or New York, but if you’re planning on driving up to Chicago via I-65, you’re going to hit the Indiana Toll Road or the Illinois skyway.
Thrifty offers "PlatePass," which is their electronic tolling solution.
Avoid it if you can. The daily convenience fee for PlatePass can be as much as $5.99 per day, even on days you don't use a toll. If you’re just staying in Indy, you don't need it. There are no tolls on I-465 (the loop) or any of the spokes leading into downtown. If you are going to Chicago, just use your own I-Pass or E-ZPass from home; it works perfectly in the rental.
As for insurance, Thrifty agents are trained to sell. They’ll ask about Loss Damage Waivers (LDW). If you have a decent credit card (like a Chase Sapphire or an Amex Gold), you likely already have primary or secondary rental coverage. Check your app before you reach the counter. Saying "no" saves you $20–$30 a day, which often doubles the price of a "thrifty" rental.
🔗 Read more: TSA PreCheck Look Up Number: What Most People Get Wrong
Comparing Thrifty to the "Big Guys" at IND
Indianapolis isn't a massive hub, so the competition is tight.
- Enterprise/National: They own the premium market here. Their cars are cleaner, but you pay for the privilege.
- Hertz: Often shares cars with Thrifty. If Thrifty is sold out, Hertz might have "Gold" deals that get close in price.
- Budget/Avis: Usually the direct price competitors.
The main difference with Thrifty at Indianapolis is the "vibe." It’s utilitarian. It’s for the person who is spending their money on tickets to the Colts game or dinner at St. Elmo Steak House rather than the leather seats in their rental car.
Final Check: Before You Drive Away
When you finally get your keys and find your spot in the garage, do a 30-second video walkthrough of the car with your phone.
Look for:
- Windshield chips (Indiana gravel is brutal).
- Curb rash on the rims.
- Fuel level (it should be 8/8 full).
The agents at the exit gate at IND are usually pretty chill, but having that video is your "get out of jail free" card if they try to charge you for a dent when you return.
Actionable Steps for Your Indy Trip
If you're ready to book, don't just click the first link you see. Follow this sequence to actually get the deal the brand name promises:
- Join Blue Chip First: Go to the Thrifty website and sign up for the loyalty program before you even look at dates. It’s the only way to avoid the potential 30-minute line at the IND counter during peak arrival windows (usually Sunday nights and Monday mornings).
- Book the "Mid-Size" over the "Compact": In the Indy fleet, the price difference is often less than $2 a day, but the jump in comfort for the 20-minute drive downtown is massive.
- Check the "Off-Airport" Rates: If you're staying in Indy for a week, look at Thrifty locations in the suburbs (like Carmel or Greenwood). Sometimes—not always, but sometimes—the "Airport Facility Fee" is so high that taking a $30 Uber to a suburban location to pick up the car saves you $150 over a week.
- Verify Your Own Coverage: Call your insurance agent or check your credit card benefits guide. Knowing you can decline the LDW is the difference between a $200 trip and a $450 trip.
- Download the "GasBuddy" App: Use it to find the cheapest fuel in Plainfield before you return the car to the GTC. Avoid the stations on the immediate airport perimeter unless you enjoy burning money.
Indianapolis is a city built for cars. You can't really do it right without one. Choosing Thrifty at IND is a solid choice if you prioritize the destination over the journey and want to keep your "Circle City" budget under control. Just remember to check those tires and skip the toll pass if you're staying local.