Let’s be real. Most of what people "know" about their first time in anal comes from one of two places: terrifying urban legends or professional adult films that have about as much to do with reality as a superhero movie has to do with physics. It’s a polarizing topic. Some people are curious but scared; others are eager but have no idea where to start. Honestly, the biggest hurdle isn't even physical. It’s the massive amount of misinformation floating around that makes the whole idea feel way more intimidating than it actually needs to be.
The truth is that the anatomy involved is complex but predictable. If you understand how the muscles work—specifically the internal and external sphincters—you’re already halfway there. But most people just dive in without a plan. That’s usually when things go wrong.
Why preparation for your first time in anal isn't just a suggestion
You can't just wing this. Seriously. Unlike other types of physical intimacy, the "back door" isn't self-lubricating. That’s a biological fact. The lining of the rectum is delicate, and it's designed to move things out, not in. Because of this, the preparation phase is arguably more important than the act itself.
💡 You might also like: How to Quit Smoking Pot: What People Get Wrong About Marijuana Withdrawal
Dr. Evan Goldstein, a well-known anal surgeon and founder of Bespoke Surgical, often talks about the "brain-gut connection." If you’re nervous, your muscles tighten. It’s an involuntary reflex. When you're stressed, your external sphincter—the one you have control over—clamps down. But it's the internal sphincter, which reacts to your nervous system, that really determines how the experience goes. If you’re clinching because you’re scared of pain, you’re basically guaranteeing that it’s going to hurt.
Communication is the only way around this. You’ve gotta be with someone you trust. Someone who won't push if you say "stop" or even "hold on a second." If you can't talk about it comfortably, you probably shouldn't be doing it yet.
The science of lubrication and why your choice matters
Forget what you think you know about lube. For your first time in anal, the cheap stuff from the drugstore probably won't cut it. You need something with staying power.
There are basically three types of lube:
- Water-based: These are easy to clean but they dry out fast. If you use these, you’ll be reapplying every five minutes.
- Silicone-based: These are the gold standard for anal play. They don't absorb into the skin, they're super slick, and they stay slippery even underwater. Just don't use them with silicone toys, or they'll degrade the material.
- Oil-based: Just don't. They can break down latex condoms and are generally a nightmare for hygiene in that specific area.
Hygiene is another big one. Look, it's the anus. People get weirdly shy about the fact that it’s a waste-disposal system. Most experts, like those at the International Society for Sexual Medicine (ISSM), suggest a simple rinse or using a saline enema about an hour beforehand if it makes you feel more confident. But don't overdo it. Over-douching can irritate the lining and actually make things more uncomfortable. Keep it simple.
The "Go Slow" rule is a rule for a reason
Speed is the enemy of a good first experience. You’ve probably heard that before, but it bears repeating because everyone ignores it. Start with fingers. Start with small toys. Start with literally anything other than the "final goal."
The goal of the first time in anal isn't necessarily to reach some cinematic climax. It’s to get the body used to a new sensation. The nerves in that area are incredibly dense. When stimulated correctly, it can lead to intense pleasure because of the proximity to the prostate in men or the back of the vaginal wall and the "A-spot" in women. But those nerves also transmit pain signals very effectively if things are forced.
Try the "stop-start" method. Apply pressure, wait for the muscle to relax, then move a tiny bit further. If there’s sharp pain? Stop. Totally. Pressure is normal; a "full" feeling is normal; sharp or stinging pain is a sign that a micro-tear is happening or the muscle is spasming.
Position matters more than you think
Don't just stick to the classic "doggy style" because you saw it in a movie. For a first timer, that position can actually be one of the most difficult because it doesn't allow for much control.
- Spoons: Lying on your side is great because it’s relaxing and allows for a shallow angle of entry.
- On Top: This gives the receiving partner total control over depth and speed. If it feels like too much, you just lift up. Easy.
- Lying Flat: Sometimes just laying on your stomach with a pillow under your hips helps align the rectum more naturally.
What happens afterward?
The "aftercare" part of the first time in anal is something people rarely discuss. You might feel a bit of "fullness" for an hour or two. That’s normal. Some very light spotting can happen, but if there's significant bleeding, that’s a sign to see a doctor.
Drink plenty of water. Stay relaxed. Maybe take a warm bath. The warm water helps the sphincter muscles relax completely after the workout they just got. Most importantly, talk to your partner about how it felt. What worked? What was weird? What do we never want to do again?
👉 See also: The Proper Way to Wipe Your Butt: What Most People Get Wrong
Nuance is everything here. Some people love it immediately. For others, it’s an "acquired taste" that takes a few tries to really enjoy. Both are totally valid. There’s no "right" way to feel about it, as long as everything was consensual and safe.
Actionable Next Steps for a Successful Experience
To make sure things go as smoothly as possible, follow these concrete steps:
- Buy a high-quality silicone lubricant (like Eros or Swiss Navy) specifically designed for anal use.
- Invest in a set of graduated anal plugs. Starting with something the size of a pinky finger and working up over several days or weeks is the most effective way to train the muscles.
- Practice deep breathing. Diaphragmatic breathing (inhaling so your belly expands) naturally relaxes the pelvic floor. Practice this while using a small toy alone so you know the sensation.
- Trim your nails. If you’re using fingers, even a tiny jagged edge can cause a painful scratch.
- Set a "safe word" or signal. Even if you're with a long-term partner, having a clear "stop everything" signal reduces anxiety, which in turn reduces physical tension.
- Use a condom. Not just for STI protection, but because the texture of many condoms is actually smoother than skin, which can reduce friction-related discomfort during the initial entry.
Focus on the relaxation rather than the "event." If you spend twenty minutes just on external touch and slow acclimation, the actual act becomes a natural progression rather than a sudden shock to the system. Keep the lights low, keep the communication high, and don't be afraid to call it off if the vibe isn't right.