You've probably seen the thumbnails. There’s a grainy screenshot of Susie holding a glowing, purple-etched weapon, or maybe a Discord leak claiming that the Magic Axe in Deltarune Chapter 4 is the new "Broken Sword" equivalent. It’s everywhere. But if you’ve been following Toby Fox’s development updates—specifically the newsletters and the 2024-2025 progress reports—you know the reality is a bit more complicated than a simple "go here, find this" guide.
The Deltarune community is basically a pressure cooker of theories right now. With Chapters 3 and 4 being developed simultaneously, the line between what’s confirmed and what’s just high-effort fan art has become incredibly blurry. Let's be real: we're all desperate for new Susie gear.
The Mystery of the Magic Axe in Deltarune Chapter 4
Honestly, the term "Magic Axe" has become a bit of a catch-all for a few different things. In the existing code for Chapters 1 and 2, we have the Brave Ax and the Devilsknife. So, where does the idea of a specific "Magic Axe" come from for the next installment?
Most of this stems from the "Green Room" teaser and the various "Shadowmen" enemy designs Toby shared. In one of the developer logs, there was a brief mention of how Susie’s "Rude Buster" ability might scale with new equipment that specifically boosts her Magic stat rather than just raw Attack. Fans immediately latched onto this. They started calling this hypothetical weapon the Magic Axe.
It makes sense. Susie is a tank, but her magic potential is actually decent if you kit her out right.
But here is the catch: Toby Fox hasn't officially named a weapon "Magic Axe" in any of the Chapter 4 previews. What we did see in the 2024 anniversary stream were glimpses of a weather-themed Dark World. If Chapter 4 takes place in a setting related to the church or the town's festival, the equipment will likely reflect that. Some theorists suggest a "Censer Axe" or a "Parade Axe."
Why the "Magic" Stat Matters for Susie
In Chapter 2, giving Susie the Jevilstail boosts her magic. This isn't just for show. It makes Red Buster hit like a freight train. If Chapter 4 introduces a dedicated Magic Axe, it would fundamentally change how you play her. You’d stop just "Acting" or "Attacking" and start using her as a primary spellcaster.
Imagine a weapon that reduces the TP cost of Rude Buster. That would be broken. In a good way.
Separating Fact from Fan Speculation
Look, I've spent way too much time on the Undertale/Deltarune Tumblr tags. People are convinced that the Magic Axe is a reward for a "No-Hit" challenge in the rumored Chapter 4 "Donut Shop" area. There is zero evidence for that.
Here is what we actually know about Chapter 4's development:
- The chapter is "content complete" as of late 2024, meaning the items and weapons are finalized.
- Toby Fox mentioned that Chapter 4 is more "traditional" in structure compared to the experimental nature of Chapter 3.
- The team has been focusing on "gimmick" items that affect how the soul moves.
If there is a Magic Axe in Deltarune Chapter 4, it’s likely going to be a hidden item found in the "Strap-on" or "Clutter" sections of the Dark World. Remember how the Spinning Blade was just... in a chest? It'll probably be like that. No grand ceremony. Just exploration.
People often forget that Toby likes to subvert expectations. Everyone expected a "Fire Shield" in Chapter 2 because of the Berdly fight, and instead, we got a Dealmaker from a dumpster-dwelling salesman. The Magic Axe might not even be an axe. It could be a "Magical Guitar" that Susie just uses like an axe because she’s Susie.
The Impact of the "Shadow Mantle"
We can't talk about Chapter 4 equipment without mentioning the Shadow Mantle. Seam explicitly mentions it at the end of Chapter 2. You need it to face the next "Pure Shadow." While the Mantle is a defensive item, there’s a prevailing theory that it can be "forged" with a weapon. If you combine a basic axe with the essence of a Shadow Crystal, you'd effectively get a magic-infused weapon.
Is that the Magic Axe? Maybe. It would explain why people are searching for it so specifically. It’s the "Ultimate Weapon" trope that we’ve seen with the Meowmere or the Ultima Weapon in other RPGs.
How to Prepare for the Chapter 4 Release
Whenever the Chapters 3-4-5 bundle finally drops on Steam and Console, you aren't going to find the best gear by rushing. That’s not how these games work.
📖 Related: Final Fantasy X Blitzball: Why Most Players Still Get It Wrong
You've got to talk to everyone. Twice.
If you want the best version of Susie—whether she’s wielding a Magic Axe or a rusty piece of metal—you need to maximize your Chapter 2 save file now.
- Get the Shadow Crystals: Beat Jevil and Spamton NEO. If you don't have those crystals, Seam won't help you in Chapter 3 or 4.
- Stock up on CD Bagels: Or any high-efficiency healing items.
- Check the Hole: Make sure you've interacted with the hole in the wall in the light world.
There's a weirdly persistent rumor that your "interactions" with Noelle in Chapter 2 will change the equipment available in Chapter 4. While the "Snowgrave" route (or Weird Route) definitely changes things, it's unlikely to lock you out of a specific weapon like a Magic Axe unless that weapon is tied to a specific character being "gone."
The Reality of "Leaked" Stats
I've seen "leaked" stats for the Magic Axe claiming it gives +10 Magic and +5 Attack. Don't believe them. These are usually just people editing the data.win file of Chapter 2 to create custom items. It’s easy to do, and it makes for great clickbait.
Actual Deltarune balance is much tighter. A +10 Magic boost would be insane for a Chapter 4 item. Usually, the jumps are much smaller, like +2 or +3, because Toby cares about the math behind the TP system.
The most realistic scenario? The Magic Axe in Deltarune Chapter 4—if it’s called that—will be a mid-game upgrade found after a mini-boss. It'll probably have a funny description like "Smells like glitter and violence."
What to Do Next
Stop scrolling through unverified leaks on X (formerly Twitter). Most of them are just people trying to farm engagement before the actual release. Instead, focus on your save files.
If you haven't done a "Pacifist" and a "Noelle" run of Chapter 2, do them now. Keep them on separate slots. We know for a fact that the world state changes based on your choices, and the equipment Susie can use might be tied to which characters are still "available" to help you in the hub world.
Check the official Deltarune.com site for the seasonal newsletters. That is the only place where Toby actually shares real screenshots. Everything else is just noise.
When Chapter 4 finally hits, head straight for the shops in the new Dark World. Look for the "Overpriced" tab. Toby loves putting the best gear behind a ridiculous paywall of Dark Dollars that requires you to grind or find a secret shortcut. That’s where the real magic happens.
Actionable Insights for Players:
- Complete your Chapter 2 "Perfect" Save: Ensure you have both Shadow Crystals from Jevil and Spamton NEO, as these are confirmed flags for future rewards.
- Monitor the Fangamer Newsletter: Toby Fox uses this as his primary communication tool; any official reveal of new weapons like a "Magic Axe" will appear there first.
- Ignore YouTube "Mod" Showcases: Many videos titled "Chapter 4 Gameplay" are actually high-quality mods (like the Ribbit mod or fan-made encounters) and do not reflect the final game's items.
- Save your Dark Dollars: Historically, top-tier equipment in Deltarune costs a significant amount of currency or requires specific quest items (like the Iron Shackle).