You've probably been there. You order a "name-brand" charger or a fancy serum that usually costs sixty bucks, but on Amazon, it's twenty-five. It arrives. The box looks... off. The logo is slightly blurry. Maybe the plastic feels cheap. You start wondering: does Amazon sell fake goods, or did you just get a weird batch?
The short answer is complicated. Amazon doesn't want to sell you fakes. It's bad for business. But because of how their massive marketplace is structured, counterfeits absolutely slip through the cracks every single day.
It’s a massive game of cat and mouse. On one side, you have Amazon’s "Project Zero" and their Counterfeit Crime Unit (CCU) throwing millions of dollars at the problem. On the other, you have incredibly sophisticated counterfeit rings, often based overseas, that are experts at gaming the system. They know exactly how to mimic listings and exploit the "Commingled Inventory" system to get their fake stuff into your hands.
The "Ships from Amazon" Trap
Most people think that if a product says "Shipped from Amazon," it's safe. That’s a mistake. Honestly, it’s one of the biggest misconceptions about how the site works.
Amazon uses a system called Commingling. Here’s how it works: say you’re selling a specific pair of Sony headphones. You send ten pairs to an Amazon warehouse. Another seller—let’s call them "Discount Electronics"—sends in fifty pairs of the same model. To save time and space, Amazon might put all sixty pairs in the same bin because they have the same barcode (UPC).
✨ Don't miss: How do I check if a money order was cashed? What you need to know now
If a customer buys from you, Amazon grabs a pair from that bin. But what if "Discount Electronics" sent in high-quality fakes? You, the honest seller, just "sold" a counterfeit without ever touching it. The customer is mad, you get a bad review, and the fake-goods seller walks away with the cash.
Amazon has pulled back on commingling for some high-risk brands, but it still happens. It's why "Fulfilled by Amazon" isn't a 100% guarantee of authenticity. It just means the item was sitting in an Amazon building, not that an expert verified it was real before it was shelved.
Why Some Categories are Counterfeit Magnets
Not everything is equally likely to be fake. You aren't going to find many counterfeit paper towels. It’s not worth the effort for the scammers. They go where the margins are high and the items are small.
Beauty and Skincare are absolute minefields. Brands like Olaplex, The Ordinary, and La Mer are frequently faked. Why? Because you can fill a bottle with cheap lotion and most people won't know until their skin starts breaking out. The FBI has even warned that counterfeit cosmetics can contain things like arsenic, beryllium, and cadmium. It's not just a rip-off; it's a health hazard.
Apple Accessories are another nightmare. Apple once filed a lawsuit claiming that nearly 90% of "official" Apple power cords and chargers sold on Amazon (and fulfilled by Amazon) over a certain period were actually counterfeits. Think about that. Nine out of ten. These fakes often lack the safety features that prevent them from overheating or catching fire.
Then you have Professional Tools. If you see a Fluke multimeter or a high-end Bosch power tool for half price, be skeptical. These are items where precision matters. A fake multimeter can literally be a death sentence if it fails to correctly read a high-voltage line.
How to Spot the Fakes Before You Buy
You have to be a bit of a detective. Don't just look at the star rating. Ratings are easily manipulated by "brushing" schemes where sellers send cheap items to random people just to create "Verified Purchase" reviews.
- Check the "Sold By" field. This is crucial. If it says "Sold by Amazon.com," you’re usually in the safest possible position. If it says "Sold by [Random String of Letters]," be careful.
- Look at the review photos. Don't just read the text. Look at the pictures customers uploaded. Does the packaging match what you see on the official brand's website? Are there typos on the box? I once saw a "Nike" box that said "Just Done It." Seriously.
- Price is the biggest red flag. If a GoPro is $400 everywhere else and it’s $180 on Amazon from a third-party seller, it’s fake. Period. Brands have MAP (Minimum Advertised Price) policies. Legitimate sellers can't just drop the price by 60% without getting in trouble with the manufacturer.
- The "Visit the Store" link. Most major brands have a "Brand Store" on Amazon. If you click the brand name at the top of the listing and it takes you to a polished, well-designed storefront, that’s a good sign. If it just takes you to a generic search result page, proceed with caution.
Amazon’s War on Fakes: Is it Working?
To be fair, Amazon is trying. They launched the Amazon Brand Registry, which gives brands more control over their listings and allows them to report infringements more easily. They also have Transparency, a service where brands put unique, 2D codes on every single unit. When that item hits an Amazon warehouse, it's scanned. If the code doesn't match, it doesn't get shipped.
🔗 Read more: Why Don't Put All Your Eggs in One Basket is Actually Terrible Advice (Sometimes)
But the sheer volume is staggering. We are talking about billions of items. Even a 99% success rate leaves millions of fakes in the system.
Dharmesh Mehta, Amazon’s Vice President of Worldwide Customer Trust, has stated that the company blocked billions of suspected bad listings before they even went live. They’ve also started suing influencers who promote "dupes"—which is often just a polite word for counterfeits—on TikTok and Instagram.
Despite this, the "whack-a-mole" reality persists. A seller gets banned on Tuesday and opens a new storefront with a different name on Wednesday. It’s incredibly cheap for them to set up, and the profit from one successful "drop" of fake AirPods can fund ten more failed attempts.
What to Do if You Get a Counterfeit
If you realize you bought a fake, don't just throw it away and take the loss. That’s what the scammers want.
First, contact Amazon immediately. They have the "A-to-z Guarantee." Tell them specifically that the item is "counterfeit" or "not authentic." These are trigger words for their customer service bots and humans. Usually, they’ll refund you instantly. Sometimes they don't even want the item back because they don't want to risk it going back into the inventory loop.
Second, report the seller. Don't just leave a 1-star review. There is an actual "Report Abuse" or "Report a Problem" link on most orders. This helps Amazon's Counterfeit Crime Unit build a case.
Third, tell the brand. Most big brands have a "brand protection" or "legal" email address. They actually want to know about this stuff because it helps them pressure Amazon to clean up the marketplace.
💡 You might also like: Malaysia RM to BDT Explained: Why the Rate is Changing and How to Get the Best Deal
The Future of Shopping on the Platform
The reality is that does Amazon sell fake goods is a question that won't go away anytime soon. As long as there is money to be made, people will try to sell knock-offs.
In the next few years, expect to see more "gated" brands where you simply cannot sell the item unless you prove you are an authorized distributor. You'll also see more AI-driven image recognition that flags listings where the logo looks slightly "off" compared to the official brand assets.
But for now, the burden of proof is mostly on you, the shopper. You have to be cynical. You have to look at the seller's history. If a seller has 20 reviews and they're all from the last three days and they all sound like they were written by the same person, run away.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Purchase
Stop treating Amazon like a single store. It's a mall. You wouldn't buy a Rolex from a guy in a trench coat in the mall parking lot, so don't buy a $300 skin cream from "Xing-Store-99" on Amazon.
- Prioritize "Sold by Amazon.com" over third-party sellers whenever possible.
- Use browser extensions like FakeSpot or ReviewMeta. They aren't perfect, but they can give you a "grade" on how trustworthy the reviews actually are.
- Cross-reference prices. Check the manufacturer's own website. If the Amazon price is too good to be true, it’s a scam.
- Inspect the packaging. Real brands spend a lot of money on high-quality printing. Fakes often have "bleeding" ink, thin cardboard, or labels that aren't centered.
- Check the "Global Ratings." If an item has 10,000 five-star reviews but they are all for a completely different product (like reviews for a spatula on a listing for a power drill), the seller hijacked an old listing to steal its rating. This is a huge red flag for a scammy seller.
Ultimately, you can shop safely on Amazon, but you can't shop blindly. Stay skeptical, check the "Sold By" info, and if you get burned, make enough noise that Amazon has to take notice.