If you were tuned into sports media around 2014, it was impossible to escape the "Johnny Football" phenomenon. He was the polarizing kid from Texas A&M who scrambled like a video game character and celebrated with a signature "money" hand gesture. But for those who didn't follow every roster move during that chaotic era in Cleveland, the question remains: Did Johnny Manziel play in the NFL?
The short answer is yes. He definitely played. But it wasn't the decade-long, Hall-of-Fame-bound career many predicted. Instead, it was a 14-game lightning strike that burned out almost as fast as it started.
The Cleveland Browns Era: A Brief Timeline
Manziel entered the league with more hype than almost any quarterback in recent memory. The Cleveland Browns grabbed him with the 22nd overall pick in the 2014 NFL Draft. Interestingly, the Dallas Cowboys—Jerry Jones specifically—nearly took him at pick 16 before his son, Stephen Jones, reportedly talked him out of it.
Imagine that alternate reality.
Anyway, Manziel’s time in Cleveland was defined by two seasons: 2014 and 2015. He didn't walk onto the field as a Week 1 starter. He actually sat behind Brian Hoyer for a good chunk of his rookie year. When he finally got his shot, it wasn't the fairy tale people expected. His first start was a disaster—a 30-0 loss to the Cincinnati Bengals where he looked completely overwhelmed by the speed of the professional game.
💡 You might also like: Anthony Davis USC Running Back: Why the Notre Dame Killer Still Matters
Season-by-Season Breakdown
In 2014, he appeared in 5 games. He only started two of them. He threw zero touchdowns and two interceptions. Honestly, it was a wake-up call for everyone who thought college dominance would automatically translate to Sunday afternoons.
Then came 2015. This was supposed to be the "redemption" year. He played in 9 games and started 6. There were flashes of the old Johnny—7 touchdowns, some big-time throws, and 1,500 passing yards. But the off-field distractions were mounting. Reports of him partying in Las Vegas while in concussion protocol became the final straw for the Browns organization.
By March 2016, the Browns waived him. He was 23 years old.
The Stats: A Look at the Numbers
When you look at the raw data, Manziel’s NFL career feels more like a "cup of coffee" than a full meal. He finished his time in the league with:
📖 Related: AC Milan vs Bologna: Why This Matchup Always Ruins the Script
- Games Played: 14
- Passing Yards: 1,675
- Touchdowns: 7
- Interceptions: 7
- Rushing Yards: 259 (plus 1 rushing touchdown)
- Career Record: 2-6 as a starter
He had a career passer rating of 74.4. For context, that's well below the league average for a starting-caliber quarterback. He struggled with the "boring" parts of being a QB—reading defenses from the pocket, going through progressions, and staying disciplined within the system.
Why Did Johnny Manziel Leave the NFL?
It wasn't just about the bad stats. Plenty of young QBs struggle early and find a second or third home. Manziel’s exit was a "perfect storm" of performance issues and personal struggles.
The Browns released him because they simply couldn't trust him to be the face of the franchise. Between missed meetings and the constant tabloid headlines, the "Johnny Football" brand became a liability. He didn't get signed by another NFL team after that 2016 release. He had a few workouts, but the baggage was too heavy for most GMs to carry.
Since then, he’s been remarkably open about his journey. In the Netflix documentary Untold: Johnny Football, he talked about his battle with bipolar disorder and his lack of preparation during those years. He admitted he didn't even watch film. In the NFL, that’s basically career suicide.
👉 See also: 49ers vs Chargers Super Bowl: What Most People Get Wrong
Life After the League
Just because he left the NFL doesn't mean he stopped playing football. He went on a bit of a "world tour" of professional leagues:
- Hamilton Tiger-Cats & Montreal Alouettes (CFL): He tried his hand in Canada in 2018. It was a mixed bag, and he was eventually banned from the league for violating his contract terms.
- Memphis Express (AAF): He had a very short stint in the Alliance of American Football before the league folded.
- Fan Controlled Football (FCF): He played for the Zappers in this indoor, fan-driven league, which seemed to suit his "playground" style of play much better.
What Most People Get Wrong
People often think Manziel was a total "bust" who never won a game. That’s not true. He won two games as a starter. He showed he could play at that level if he was focused. The tragedy of his career isn't that he wasn't talented enough; it’s that the mental and emotional infrastructure wasn't there to support the talent.
If you’re looking to dive deeper into the history of the 2014 Draft, check out the careers of guys like Derek Carr or Jimmy Garoppolo, who were taken after Manziel but had much longer stays in the league. It's a fascinating study in "what if."
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you're following a young, "electric" quarterback today, look for these three things to see if they'll avoid the Manziel trap:
- Pocket Discipline: Can they win without scrambling?
- Off-Field Stability: Are they making headlines for the right reasons?
- Professionalism: Do their coaches and teammates praise their "first-in, last-out" work ethic?
Johnny Manziel remains a cautionary tale, but also a reminder of how difficult it is to stay in the NFL, even if you’re the most famous player in the country.