If you’re looking for a blowout, you came to the wrong place. College basketball in the Big 12 is basically a nightly car crash where everyone walks away with a limp. The recent collision between Cincinnati Bearcats men's basketball vs UCF Knights men's basketball was exactly that—a 73-72 nail-biter that left fans in Orlando screaming and fans in Cincy wondering where the free-throw shooting went.
Honestly, it’s kinda wild how these two programs have mirrored each other lately. Both jumped from the AAC to the big leagues of the Big 12, and both are finding out that there are no "off nights" anymore. One minute you’re up seven, the next you’re watching a 7-footer from South Sudan swat your layup into the third row.
The One-Point Heartbreak in Orlando
Let’s get into the weeds of the most recent matchup. On January 11, 2026, the Bearcats rolled into Addition Financial Arena to face a UCF team that had just cracked the Top 25. Cincinnati was desperate. They were 0-3 in conference play and looking for a spark.
The game was a seesaw. Neither team ever led by double digits. You've got Riley Kugel—the Florida transfer who has become the engine for Johnny Dawkins—dropping 19 points and looking like an NBA prospect. On the other side, Cincinnati’s defense, which Wes Miller has turned into a top-10 unit nationally in terms of efficiency, was making life miserable for everyone else.
The finish was pure chaos.
📖 Related: U of Washington Football News: Why Jedd Fisch’s Roster Overhaul Is Working
With 13 seconds left, Themus Fulks hit a jumper to put UCF up by one. Cincinnati had a chance, a final look to steal a win on the road and flip the script on their season. They didn't get it. The ball didn't drop. Game over.
Why Cincinnati Bearcats Men's Basketball vs UCF Knights Men's Basketball is a Schematic Nightmare
When you watch these two teams play, you’re seeing two very different philosophies clashing in a small space.
Wes Miller wants to choke you. The Bearcats' defensive rating is legitimate—sitting at 8th in the country for a good chunk of this season. They play a physical, "in your jersey" style of man-to-man defense that forces teams into long, contested jumpers.
UCF? They want to run. Or at least, they want to use their length. Johnny Dawkins has built a roster of giants. Jeremy Foumena is 6'11", John Bol is 7'2", and they’ve got wings like Jordan Burks who can jump out of the gym.
👉 See also: Top 5 Wide Receivers in NFL: What Most People Get Wrong
- The Transition Game: UCF averages over 15 fast-break points when they’re clicking.
- The Glass: Cincinnati usually wins the rebounding battle, but against UCF’s length, they struggled, getting out-rebounded 30-27 in their last meeting.
- The Charity Stripe: This is where Cincy fans lose their minds. The Bearcats shot 62% from the line in the 73-72 loss. You make one more free throw, you go to overtime. You make two, you win.
The Riley Kugel Factor
If there is one name that defines the current state of this rivalry, it’s Riley Kugel. The kid is electric. He struggled at Florida at times, but in Orlando, he’s found his soul.
In the latest installment of Cincinnati Bearcats men's basketball vs UCF Knights men's basketball, Kugel was the difference-maker. He’s not just a scorer; he’s a momentum shifter. When Cincinnati threatened to pull away in the first half, Kugel buried a three. When they needed a bucket late, he was the guy drawing the attention.
Bearcats fans have Jizzle James, who is a stud in his own right, but the consistency isn't quite there yet for the whole roster. Cincinnati is shooting about 42% from the field as a team this year. That’s... not great. In fact, it’s one of the lower marks in the Big 12. You can’t survive on defense alone when the other team has a shot-maker like Kugel.
Breaking Down the Standings
Right now, the Big 12 is a mess. Arizona and Houston are hovering at the top like Final Four locks, while UCF is surprisingly sitting in that upper-middle tier.
✨ Don't miss: Tonya Johnson: The Real Story Behind Saquon Barkley's Mom and His NFL Journey
- UCF Knights: Currently 14-2 overall (3-1 in Big 12). They’re the real deal.
- Cincinnati Bearcats: 9-8 overall (1-3 in Big 12). They finally got a win after the UCF loss, but they are fighting for their lives just to stay out of the conference cellar.
The gap between these two isn't as big as the record suggests, though. Every Cincinnati loss in conference play has been by a handful of points. They are right there. Sorta like a guy who’s 90% finished with a marathon but keeps tripping on his shoelaces in the last mile.
What to Expect Next
If you're a betting person, or just someone who likes to stress out on a Tuesday night, here is the reality of this matchup.
Cincinnati is going to keep playing elite defense. They are going to keep holding teams under 70 points. But until they find a way to shoot better than 30% from three-point range—which they failed to do against UCF (shooting a dismal 15%)—they are going to keep losing these heartbreakers.
UCF is the opposite. They are riding high on confidence. They’ve got a home win streak that’s reaching double digits. They have the length to bother even the best teams in the country.
Practical Steps for Fans
- Watch the Point Guard Battle: Themus Fulks (UCF) vs Day Day Thomas (Cincinnati). Whoever controls the tempo wins.
- Monitor the Injury Report: Both teams have been naggingly banged up. In a one-point game, having your 6th man available is the whole ballgame.
- Check the Venue: Cincinnati is a much different beast at Fifth Third Arena. If the rematch is in Cincy, flip your expectations.
The rivalry between the Bearcats and the Knights isn't the oldest in college hoops, but it's becoming one of the most reliable for drama. It’s gritty. It’s ugly. It’s exactly what Big 12 basketball is supposed to be.
Keep an eye on the shooting percentages for Cincinnati in their upcoming games. If that number starts to tick up toward 45%, they are going to become the team nobody wants to see in the conference tournament. Until then, UCF holds the bragging rights in a series that is quickly becoming a "must-watch" on the calendar.