If you’ve spent any time at Comerica Park lately, you know the vibe. It’s that collective breath-holding every time a ball is scorched toward the 6-hole. For years, the shortstop for Detroit Tigers conversation has been, well, let's call it "complicated." It’s basically been the Javier Báez show—a high-wire act of highlight-reel tags and head-scratching swings at sliders in the opposite batter's box.
But things are shifting. Fast.
Honestly, we’re at a point where the name on the back of the jersey matters less than the production on the field. The Tigers are officially out of the "rebuilding" phase and into the "we actually expect to win games" phase. That changes how Scott Harris and the front office look at the most important defensive position on the diamond. You can't just "let Javy be Javy" when you're chasing a Wild Card spot or a division crown.
The Javier Báez Conundrum
Look, Javy is Javy. You’ve seen the stats. He’s coming off a 2025 where he actually managed to snag an All-Star nod—which, let's be real, felt like a fever dream for a minute—but the consistency is still the white whale. He’s signed through 2027 on that massive $140 million deal. He’s not going anywhere unless someone wants to eat a mountain of cash.
But here’s the thing: his "El Mago" magic is flickering. In 2025, we saw him regress late in the season. He still flashes that elite glove, but the bat-to-ball skills are... fickle. The Tigers need a shortstop for Detroit Tigers who doesn't just provide "veteran presence" but actually anchors a lineup that finally has teeth with guys like Riley Greene and Kerry Carpenter.
📖 Related: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
The Trey Sweeney Factor
Then there’s Trey Sweeney. Remember the deadline deal with the Dodgers that brought him over? He’s been the primary "other guy" at short.
Sweeney is basically the anti-Báez. He’s 6’3”, left-handed, and brings a more disciplined, if less explosive, approach. In 2025, he logged over 100 games at short, but the batting average hovered in that painful sub-.200 range for a long stretch. It’s hard to stay in a Major League lineup when you’re hitting .196, no matter how many walks you draw.
Is he the long-term answer? Probably not. He’s looking more like a bridge. Or maybe a utility piece. The internal buzz suggests his window might be closing because of the guy currently wrecking Double-A pitching.
Kevin McGonigle: The Name You Need to Know
If you haven't heard of Kevin McGonigle yet, you're missing out. He’s basically the reason why Tigers fans are actually optimistic about the infield.
👉 See also: Mizzou 2024 Football Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
McGonigle is currently the #2 prospect in all of baseball according to some rankings. That’s not a typo. The kid is 21 years old and has "video game" numbers. We’re talking about a .305/.408/.583 slash line between High-A and Double-A in 2025.
- Hit Tool: Elite. He walks more than he strikes out.
- Power: Surprising. He’s not huge (5'10"), but he’s hitting 113 mph exit velocities.
- Defense: He’s been playing short, but the Tigers are moving him around.
The front office has him taking reps at third and second base too. Why? Because they want his bat in the lineup as soon as possible. Whether he's the shortstop for Detroit Tigers on Opening Day or by June, he’s the future. Scott Harris has already hinted that he’s getting a serious look in Spring Training.
The "Bridge" Strategy for 2026
So, what does the depth chart actually look like right now? It's a bit of a mess, but a calculated one.
- Javier Báez: The incumbent. He’ll get the lion's share of starts early because of the contract and the glove.
- Zach McKinstry: The Swiss Army knife. He’s the guy who fills in when Javy needs a "mental health" day or a breather.
- Trey Sweeney: The lefty option. If he can find his swing in Toledo, he might see time, but he’s on a short leash.
- Kevin McGonigle: The wildcard. He’ll likely start in Triple-A Toledo just to get those final "reps," but don't be shocked if he forces his way up by May.
What Most People Get Wrong About Detroit’s Infield
Everyone thinks the Tigers are "stuck" with Báez. And yeah, financially, they kind of are. But Scott Harris has shown he doesn’t care about "sunk costs." If McGonigle or even Bryce Rainer (the 2024 first-rounder who is also a shortstop) shows they are ready, the Tigers will move Javy to a bench role or find a creative way to pivot.
✨ Don't miss: Current Score of the Steelers Game: Why the 30-6 Texans Blowout Changed Everything
They aren't just looking for a body at shortstop. They are looking for a catalyst.
The Tigers are also being aggressive in the international market. Just this January, they signed Oscar Tineo, a 16-year-old shortstop with a $1.45 million bonus. They are stockpiling talent at the position because they know that's how you build a sustainable winner.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Bettors
If you’re following this team, keep your eyes on the box scores in Toledo. That’s where the real story is.
- Watch McGonigle’s Strikeout Rate: If it stays below 15% in Triple-A, he’s coming up. Period.
- The Javy "Leash": Watch how Hinch manages Javy’s playing time against right-handed pitching. If we see more Sweeney or McKinstry early, it means the front office is losing patience.
- Draft Strategy (Fantasy): Don't touch Javy. Seriously. But keep McGonigle on your radar for a mid-season waiver wire pickup. He’s going to provide immediate value in OBP and runs.
The era of having a "hole" at shortstop for Detroit Tigers is ending. Whether it's through a veteran resurgence or a youth explosion, the 2026 season is going to be the turning point for the Detroit infield. Get ready, because the "Motor City Kitties" are finally growing some claws.
Next Steps for Tigers Fans:
Monitor the 40-man roster moves following Spring Training. If McGonigle remains in camp through the final week of March, expect a service-time-influenced call-up by early May to maximize his impact while securing a potential compensatory draft pick through the MLB Prospect Promotion Incentive.