Ever seen a grown man in a long-nosed mask lose his cool because of a 90s hip-hop reference? If you've spent any time in the deeper corners of the Slipknot fandom, you’ve probably stumbled upon the "Chris Fehn Naughty by Nature" mystery. It’s one of those weird, internet-era urban legends that feels like it should be a joke, but when you look at the footage, it’s actually kind of uncomfortable.
Chris Fehn, better known to most as #3, spent twenty years banging beer kegs and wearing that iconic Pinocchio-style mask. But for a split second in 2011, the mask slipped. Not literally—he stayed in character—but the composure was gone.
What Actually Happened with Chris Fehn and Naughty by Nature?
It all goes back to Nardwuar the Human Serviette. If you don't know Nardwuar, he's the Canadian interviewer who finds out things about celebrities that even their mothers have forgotten. In 2011, he interviewed Slipknot.
💡 You might also like: Harry Styles and Olivia Dean Explained: What Really Happened Between the Two Singers
Nardwuar, in his typical high-energy fashion, leaned in and asked Chris Fehn about a specific connection to the legendary hip-hop group Naughty by Nature.
The reaction was instant.
Chris Fehn didn't laugh. He didn't explain. He looked at the camera, did a quick gesture—some say a "don't talk about that" finger wag—and then he just walked out. Left the shot. Gone. His bandmate Sid Wilson was left standing there looking a bit puzzled, and the interview just... continued without him.
The Rumors vs. The Reality
Since that day, the internet has been trying to figure out why a mention of "O.P.P." or "Hip Hop Hooray" would make a metal percussionist bail on an interview. Honestly, the theories range from the plausible to the completely unhinged.
- The Session Musician Theory: Some fans swear Chris Fehn was a secret session drummer for Naughty by Nature back in the 90s. They claim he did uncredited percussion tracks on their early records before Slipknot blew up.
- The Tribute Band Myth: There is a persistent rumor that Chris was in a Naughty by Nature tribute band called "Naughty Klown." There is almost zero evidence of this online, which either means it’s a fake story or Chris's legal team is very, very good at their jobs.
- The Personal Grievance: Others think it was a legal thing. Since Chris eventually sued Slipknot over financial disputes (a case that was settled "with prejudice" in 2022), people love to project "money secrets" onto every old interaction.
Kinda weird, right? You'd think a guy who spends his life on stage screaming and hitting things would have thicker skin.
Why the Nardwuar Interview Still Matters
The reason people still search for Chris Fehn Naughty by Nature in 2026 isn't just because of the music. It's because of the E-E-A-T (Expertise, Experience, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) of Nardwuar himself.
Nardwuar doesn't miss. When he brings something up, it’s usually because he has a record, a photo, or a witness. The fact that Fehn walked out basically confirmed that there was something to the story. If it was a total lie, he probably would have just called Nardwuar crazy.
Instead, he bolted.
Basically, it's the classic "streisand effect." By trying to hide the connection, he made it the one thing everyone wanted to talk about. It turned a potentially cool piece of trivia into a "secret" that fans have been dissecting for over a decade.
Life After the Mask
Since his departure from Slipknot in 2019, Fehn has stayed relatively quiet. We know he’s a massive golf fan. We know he settled his lawsuit with Corey Taylor and Shawn "Clown" Crahan. But he hasn't exactly been doing press tours to explain his taste in 90s rap.
The reality is probably less dramatic than the fan theories. It’s likely that Nardwuar hit a nerve regarding a project Chris did before he was famous—something he might have signed a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) for, or maybe just something he felt didn't fit the "tough metal guy" brand Slipknot worked so hard to maintain.
What You Can Learn From the Fehn Mystery
Honestly, the biggest takeaway here is about personal branding.
- Your past always follows you. Even if you're wearing a mask and going by a number, people will find out about your early gigs.
- Silence speaks louder than words. If Fehn had just said, "Yeah, I love those guys," the mystery would have died in 2011.
- Nardwuar is the GOAT. Seriously, never try to hide anything from that man.
If you’re looking for a definitive "yes, he was their drummer" answer, you won't find it in the official credits. But in the world of music, the absence of a denial is often as good as a confirmation.
Check out the old Nardwuar footage if you can find a mirror of it. Watch Chris's eyes. You've never seen a man move that fast to avoid talking about "Feel Me Flow."
If you're curious about where Chris Fehn is now, he's mostly living a private life away from the heavy metal spotlight, though he still pops up at occasional signings and events. As for Naughty by Nature, they remain icons of the East Orange hip-hop scene, seemingly oblivious to the fact that they once caused a metal titan to flee a room in terror.
To get the full context of this weird crossover, your next step should be watching the 2011 Slipknot Nardwuar interview on YouTube. Pay close attention at the 5-minute mark; the body language tells a much bigger story than the words ever could. After that, look up the liner notes for Naughty by Nature's 1991 self-titled album—you won't find his name, but you'll hear some percussion hits that sound suspiciously familiar to a Slipknot fan.