benny blanco dating history: What Most People Get Wrong

Benny Blanco is basically the guy who won the lottery without even buying a ticket—except he actually worked for it for about fifteen years. For the longest time, he was just that dude in the background of your favorite pop songs. The guy behind the scenes. Now? He’s the man who married Selena Gomez.

The internet is obsessed. People want to know every single detail. Who did he date before the "B" ring? Was he always this much of a romantic, or did Selena just bring it out of him? Honestly, his track record is surprisingly short for a guy who has been at the top of the music industry since he was a teenager.

He's private. Like, really private.

The Mystery of benny blanco dating history Before the Limelight

Most music producers have a "type," and usually, that type is "anyone with a blue checkmark." Benny? Not so much. For the first decade of his career, he was a ghost. He was busy racking up 29 number-one hits with people like Ed Sheeran and Justin Bieber. He wasn't exactly walking red carpets with a new model every week.

If you look back at the early 2010s, there’s almost nothing. No leaked paparazzi photos. No messy Twitter feuds. No "sources" talking to TMZ about his latest fling. It’s kind of refreshing, actually.

The Elsie Hewitt Era (2019-2020)

Before Selena, there was Elsie Hewitt. She’s a London-born model and actress who has a pretty significant following of her own. You might recognize her from the indie film Upon Waking or her brief stint as Playboy’s Miss June 2017.

They met on the set of his music video for "Graduation" in 2019. If you haven't seen it, it’s a trip—Juice WRLD is in it, and it's basically a parody of every high school movie ever made. Elsie was one of the stars.

Their relationship was low-key but official. Elsie actually posted on X (which was still Twitter back then) for National Boyfriend’s Day in 2019, basically telling the world she wished Benny was with her instead of being on a boat. Benny, in his typical humor, replied that he wished she was single. Classic.

They did the whole "official" thing:

• Walked the red carpet at the Spotify Best New Artist Party in January 2020.
• Shared mushy, blurry photos on Instagram.
• Benny even posted a photo of her calling her his girlfriend when people doubted he had one.

Then, by late 2020, it was just... over. No drama. No shade. No million-dollar lawsuits (unlike Elsie’s previous relationship with Ryan Phillippe). They just drifted. Interestingly, Elsie eventually moved on to date Pete Davidson in 2025, and they’re actually expecting a baby now. Small world, right?

Why the Selena Gomez Romance Changed Everything

Everything shifted in 2023. Benny and Selena had been friends forever. Like, since 2008. He met her when she was 16 years old and just starting out. They worked together on "Same Old Love" and "Kill Em With Kindness" in 2015. They were just work buddies.

Then came "Single Soon."

It’s ironic. They were working on a song about being single while they were actually falling for each other. Benny admits he was "the last one to know" they were on a date. Selena asked him to dinner, and he thought they were just hanging out as friends. He didn't realize the vibe had changed until it really changed.

The Timeline of the Century

1. Mid-2023: They start "secretly" dating.
2. December 2023: Selena breaks the internet by confirming the rumors. She calls him her "absolute everything."
3. January 2024: Courtside at the Lakers game. They weren't hiding the PDA.
4. December 2024: The Proposal. Benny did it over Taco Bell on a soundstage. Honestly, if that isn't the most Benny Blanco thing ever, I don't know what is.
5. March 2025: They drop a joint album, I Said I Love You First.
6. September 27, 2025: They get married in California.

The "Betrayal" Narrative

You've probably seen the TikToks. People love to bring up the fact that Benny is close friends with Justin Bieber. Since Selena and Justin have that legendary, messy history, the internet tried to make Benny out to be a villain.

They pointed to a 2020 interview where Benny talked about "cookie-cutter pop artists" who launch makeup lines. Everyone thought he was shading Selena's Rare Beauty.

But here’s the thing: Selena didn't care. She defended him against her own fans. She told everyone he was "better than anyone" she’d ever been with. Facts only.

What We Can Learn From Benny’s Approach

Benny Blanco isn't your typical Hollywood playboy. He doesn't collect "it girls" for clout. He seems to value longevity. He went from a one-year relationship with Elsie to marrying his long-term collaborator and friend.

It’s a "friends-to-lovers" trope that actually worked in real life.

If you're looking for a deep list of exes, you're not going to find it here. Benny kept his circle small and his private life under lock and key until he found the person he wanted to tell the whole world about.

📖 Related: Who is Rashida Jones' Mom? Peggy Lipton’s Iconic Life and Legacy

If you're curious about how he balances his career with this high-profile marriage, you should definitely check out his cookbook Open Wide. It’s less about recipes and more about the art of hosting and being a good partner. He talks a lot about how he manifested this life by making a list of what he wanted in a woman—and it turns out, Selena checked every box.

You can start by looking at his production discography to see just how long these two have been in each other's orbits. It’s a masterclass in playing the long game.