If you’ve watched even one season of Chicago Fire, you know the drill. The bells go off, Truck 81 and Squad 3 roll out, and your heart starts doing that weird thumping thing because you know Derek Haas and the writers aren't afraid to pull the rug out from under you. It’s brutal. Honestly, the question of Chicago Fire who dies is one of the most searched things every single time a season finale—or even a random mid-season episode—rolls around. This show treats its characters like real people in one of the most dangerous jobs on earth, which means not everyone gets a happy retirement party and a gold watch.
Some exits hurt more than others.
Firehouse 51 has seen a lot of turnover since 2012, but the deaths are what define the show's DNA. It’s not just about the shock value. It’s about how the loss of a person like Shay or Otis ripples through the house for years. You still see Otis’s memorial. You still see the look on Severide’s face when someone mentions the old days. If you’re trying to keep track of the body count or just want to relive the trauma of your favorite character getting written off, let's break down the definitive list of who we’ve lost.
The Loss That Changed Everything: Leslie Shay
Season 3 started with a literal bang, and it’s arguably the moment Chicago Fire proved it wasn't a "safe" procedural. Leslie Shay, played by Lauren German, was the heartbeat of the show. She was sarcastic, fiercely loyal, and her friendship with Kelly Severide was the emotional anchor of the series. Then came the apartment fire in the Season 2 finale.
The cliffhanger left everyone’s lives in the balance, but when Season 3, Episode 1, "Always," aired, we found out Shay didn't make it. A pipe fell. It was a freak accident during a rescue. The show didn't just move on, either. They spent a massive chunk of the season tracking down the arsonist who started that fire, making it a serialized revenge plot that felt earned. Losing Shay changed Severide forever; it made him darker, more reckless for a while, and it forced Gabby Dawson to step up in a way she wasn't ready for. To this day, fans still argue that the show lost a bit of its spark when Shay’s ambulance door closed for the last time.
Why the Otis Death Still Stings
If Shay was the heart, Brian "Otis" Zvonecek was the soul. He was the comic relief. He was the guy who loved Catan and geeky podcasts. Yuri Sardarov played him with such a relatable, "everyman" energy that when he died in the Season 8 premiere, "Sacred Ground," it felt like losing a literal friend.
The death happened because of a backdraft in a mattress factory fire. Otis managed to close a door to save his teammates, but he couldn't get himself out in time. The scene at the hospital where Joe Cruz says goodbye to him in Russian? Gut-wrenching. Seriously. I’ve seen a lot of TV deaths, but Cruz sobbing "Brother, I will be with you always" is top-tier emotional damage.
The writers made a conscious choice here. They knew the audience was getting comfortable. They needed to remind us that the job is lethal. By killing Otis, they took away the "safe" character. It’s why his memorial—the "Morituri Nolumus Mori" (We who are about to die are reluctant to die) statue—stands outside the firehouse now. It serves as a constant reminder to the characters and the viewers that the stakes are real.
The Tragic Departure of Hallie Thomas
Most people forget about Hallie because she was only in the first season, but her death was the catalyst for Matthew Casey’s entire character arc. Hallie was Casey’s fiancée, a doctor who got caught in a clinic fire that was actually a cover-up for a drug ring.
It was dark. It was gritty.
Losing Hallie turned Casey from a somewhat generic leading man into a guy who carried an immense amount of grief and responsibility. It cleared the way for the "Dawsey" romance, sure, but it also established that being adjacent to Firehouse 51 is just as dangerous as being in it.
Other Notable Deaths in the 51 Family
It isn’t always the main billing stars who leave a mark. The show has a way of making you care about the recurring cast just enough to crush you when they’re gone.
- Rebecca Jones: This one was different. It wasn't a fire. Jones was a candidate who struggled with the intense pressure of the job and her father’s disapproval. Her death by suicide in Season 2 was a sobering look at mental health within the first responder community. It was a heavy, necessary storyline that didn't have a "heroic" ending.
- Danny Borrelli: Jimmy Borrelli’s brother. His death during a structural collapse led to a massive feud between Jimmy and Chief Boden. It eventually led to Jimmy’s exit from the show after he was severely burned, proving that grief can destroy a career just as fast as a fire can.
- Anna Turner: Severide’s girlfriend who died of leukemia. While not a firefighter, her death was a massive turning point for Kelly. It showed his capacity for vulnerability. It was one of the few times we saw the "cool" lieutenant completely break down.
- Benny Severide: Kelly’s dad. Treat Williams was incredible in this role. Benny died of a stroke, but his "death" happened off-screen in terms of the actual event, with the fallout being the focus. He went out after using his remaining political capital to save Boden’s job, which was the most Benny Severide thing ever.
Evan Hawkins: The Death Nobody Saw Coming
Recently, the biggest shock to the system was Jimmy Nicholas’s character, Evan Hawkins. He was the Paramedic Field Chief and Violet Mikami’s love interest. Just as they were finally becoming a "thing" and winning over the fans, a building collapsed on him while he was trying to help a victim.
It happened in Season 11, Episode 3. People were livid.
The chemistry between Violet and Hawkins was some of the best the show had seen in years. His death felt cruel because it happened right as he was becoming a staple of the 51 family. But that’s the Chicago Fire brand. They give you something beautiful and then remind you that life is fragile. Watching Violet try to perform CPR on him while knowing it was useless was a brutal piece of television.
Why do they keep killing off favorites?
You might wonder why a show would risk alienating its fan base by killing off people like Otis or Shay. Honestly, it's about longevity. Shows like Grey’s Anatomy or Chicago Fire stay on the air for over a decade because they keep the "danger" feeling authentic. If everyone always survives a 5-alarm blaze, the tension disappears. You stop worrying when the roof starts sagging.
When you search for Chicago Fire who dies, you aren't just looking for a list. You’re looking for a reason. You’re looking to see if the show is still worth the emotional investment. The answer is usually yes, because the writers use these deaths to fuel the next three seasons of character growth.
✨ Don't miss: Why CM Punk With Long Hair Still Defines His Legacy Today
How to handle the "Chicago Fire" emotional rollercoaster
If you're binging the show for the first time or catching up on the 2025-2026 seasons, here is some unsolicited advice.
First, don't get too attached to the candidates. They are statistically the most likely to end up in the line of fire (literally). Second, pay attention to the contracts. Sometimes, a "shocking death" is actually just an actor wanting to move on to movies or other projects. It makes the pill a little easier to swallow when you realize it was a career move for the performer.
Lastly, watch the "One Chicago" crossover events with a box of tissues. Dick Wolf loves to kill people when the P.D. and Med crews are around to witness it. It maximizes the drama.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Check the current cast list: If you’ve been away for a season, look up the active roster for Season 13 and 14 to see who is still standing.
- Rewatch the "Always" and "Sacred Ground" episodes: These are the gold standard for how to write a character exit that respects the fans while moving the plot forward.
- Follow the actors on social media: Seeing Yuri Sardarov and Lauren German hanging out in real life is the best cure for the "Chicago Fire" blues.
The show isn't slowing down. As long as the sirens are blaring in the Windy City, someone is going to be at risk. That's just the nature of the job.