Honestly, nobody had "Jennifer Coolidge dates a blocky video game character" on their 2025 bingo card. But here we are. In the wild, blocky world of A Minecraft Movie, the standout performance isn't a high-octane sword fight or a complex redstone machine. It’s Jennifer Coolidge—playing a high school vice principal named Marlene—having a full-blown romantic dinner with a Minecraft villager.
It sounds fake. It sounds like a fever dream. Yet, it’s the most talked-about part of the film.
The Romance No One Saw Coming
Marlene isn't even in the Overworld for most of the movie. While Jason Momoa and Jack Black are running around fighting Piglins, Marlene is back in the real world (specifically Chuglass, Idaho) dealing with a messy divorce from her "personality-less" husband. Her life changes when she accidentally hits a Nitwit villager with her Jeep Grand Cherokee.
For those who don't play the game, a Nitwit is a specific type of villager. They wear green robes. They don't have jobs. They just sort of... wander.
Instead of a lawsuit, we get a date. Marlene takes the Nitwit to dinner, and the chemistry is, as Coolidge herself put it in an interview with BBC Radio 1, "just like fire." She basically spends the whole scene convinced he’s just a very "unusual" or "Swedish" man with a massive head.
The absurdity is the point. Coolidge plays it with that signature breathless, wide-eyed sincerity that made her a legend in The White Lotus. She isn't in on the joke; she is the romantic lead in a movie where her partner is a CGI character with a nose the size of a baguette.
💡 You might also like: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
The Secret Ingredient: Bret McKenzie and Matt Berry
You might wonder how a romance with a mute, blocky NPC actually feels human. It comes down to the talent behind the blocks. While the villager’s head is CGI, the physical performance on set was done by Bret McKenzie (half of the comedy duo Flight of the Conchords).
Coolidge has been vocal about how hard it was to keep a straight face while McKenzie acted from inside a literal cardboard box to maintain the "blocky" proportions.
"Bret McKenzie’s a genius," Coolidge told Digital Spy. "It’s hard to do a performance through a cardboard box and still have you laughing, but he was able to do it."
But the real kicker? The voice. Throughout the film, the Nitwit only makes the classic Minecraft "hrmm" noises. However, the mid-credits scene reveals he’s learned English. The voice coming out of that blocky face? Matt Berry.
Hearing the booming, theatrical baritone of Laszlo from What We Do in the Shadows come out of a jobless Minecraft villager is peak cinema. It turns a throwaway gag into a legitimate "did that actually just happen?" moment that has dominated social media since the film's April 4, 2025 release.
📖 Related: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying
Why the "R-Rated" Cut is a Total Myth (Mostly)
There’s been a lot of internet chatter about a "Coolidge Cut" of the movie. Director Jared Hess teased that the outtakes from the dinner scene were so raunchy they would have pushed the film’s PG rating straight into R-rated territory.
Coolidge is a master of improv. When you let her loose on a "date" with a silent villager, she’s going to go places. While we likely won't ever see a version of A Minecraft Movie that isn't family-friendly, the legend of the "raunchy villager date" has only helped the movie’s box office. As of early 2026, the film has grossed nearly $960 million.
People didn't just go for the crafting. They went to see Stifler's Mom fall for a Nitwit.
What Most People Get Wrong About Marlene
A common criticism is that Marlene’s storyline is "useless" because she never enters the Overworld. Critics at sites like Screen Rant argued her scenes could be cut without changing the plot.
They’re missing the point.
👉 See also: Jack Blocker American Idol Journey: What Most People Get Wrong
The movie is a comedy. Marlene and the Nitwit provide the "B-plot" levity that keeps the film from feeling like a generic hero’s journey. By showing a villager in the real world, the movie bridges the gap between the game’s logic and our reality. It also gives us the funniest line of the year: Marlene asking the villager not to sue her because "people just love to sue me when I hit them with my Jeep."
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you're looking to dive deeper into this specific corner of the Minecraft cinematic universe, here is what you need to do:
- Watch for the "Nitwit" in-game: If you play Minecraft, look for the villagers in green robes. They can’t take professions, which is exactly why the movie version was "unemployed" and looking for love.
- Check the Digital Extras: The digital release (which dropped May 13, 2025) includes behind-the-scenes footage of Bret McKenzie in his "block suit" acting opposite Coolidge. It’s arguably funnier than the movie itself.
- Don't skip the credits: The Matt Berry reveal is essential. It changes the context of the entire romance and sets up a potential (though debated) return for Coolidge in the 2027 sequel.
The pairing of Jennifer Coolidge and a villager shouldn't work. It’s objectively ridiculous. But in an era of "perfect" CGI and predictable blockbusters, this weird, improvised, slightly uncomfortable romance is exactly what the audience needed. It’s a reminder that even in a world made of blocks, Jennifer Coolidge is still the most unpredictable element on screen.
To truly appreciate the performance, pay close attention to the mid-credits scene where the Nitwit's new "human" voice is revealed—it recontextualizes every "hrmm" they shared during dinner.