Ever get that weird, localized itch to text an ex-boyfriend right around December 15th? It’s not just the peppermint mochas talking. You’re likely haunted by the boyfriends of Christmas past. These aren't literal ghosts, obviously, but the emotional echoes of people who once shared your tinsel-covered memories.
Memory is a funny thing. It’s a liar, mostly. When the temperature drops and the Mariah Carey starts blasting in every Walgreens, our brains do this weird survival-mechanic pivot where we filter out the fights and keep the cozy lighting.
Why do we do this to ourselves? Honestly, it’s a biological cocktail of loneliness, holiday pressure, and "cuffing season" hormone spikes. We aren't actually missing "Todd from 2017." We're missing the version of ourselves that felt secure enough to watch The Holiday for the fourteenth time with a warm body next to us.
The Psychological Trap of Holiday Nostalgia
Nostalgia isn't just a sweet feeling; it's a coping mechanism. Dr. Krystine Batcho, a psychology professor at Le Moyne College, has spent decades researching this. She notes that nostalgia helps us maintain a sense of continuity in our lives. When the year is ending—which naturally causes a bit of existential dread—we reach back. We look for the boyfriends of Christmas past because they represent a time when we knew who we were.
Even if that person was a disaster.
Think about the "reminiscence bump." This is a psychological phenomenon where people tend to recall memories from their late teens and early twenties more vividly than any other period. If you dated someone during that window, those holiday memories are burned into your neural pathways with a higher intensity. So, when you smell pine needles or burnt cookies, your brain 404s and tries to reconnect you to a person who is probably currently living in a different state with a new dog and zero interest in your 2 a.m. "Merry Christmas" text.
The Dopamine of the "Almost"
Sometimes we obsess over the ones that didn't work out because of the Zeigarnik Effect. This is a fancy way of saying our brains hate unfinished tasks. If a relationship ended abruptly right before the holidays, your mind keeps the file "open."
✨ Don't miss: Charcoal Gas Smoker Combo: Why Most Backyard Cooks Struggle to Choose
You’re stuck in a loop.
You think about the gift you never got to give. Or the New Year's Eve kiss that was supposed to happen at that one party in Brooklyn but ended in a driveway argument. These boyfriends of Christmas past become idealized versions of what could have been. You aren't mourning a real person; you're mourning a lost script.
Decoding the Different "Ghosts"
Every woman has a specific roster of holiday ghosts. They usually fall into a few predictable buckets.
The High School Hero. You see him at the hometown bar on December 23rd. He looks... fine. He's wearing a fleece vest. You remember him as the guy who drove you around looking at lights, but now he just talks about crypto or his kid's soccer league.
The One That Got Away (Because You Left). This is the dangerous one. The guilt hits hard when the "peace on earth" vibes start. You wonder if you were too harsh. You think maybe, just maybe, if you'd stayed, you'd be married in a farmhouse by now.
The Holiday Fling. This person only existed for three weeks. They are inextricably linked to the smell of mulled wine. You have no idea what they’re like in July. Do they even own shorts? Probably not. In your head, they are permanently wearing a chunky knit sweater.
🔗 Read more: Celtic Knot Engagement Ring Explained: What Most People Get Wrong
Social Media: The Digital Séance
Instagram is a graveyard of boyfriends of Christmas past. We "soft block" or "mute," but then the curiosity gets the best of us. We see a story of them at a tree farm. They're holding a saw. Suddenly, we’re spiraling.
A 2022 study published in the journal Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking found that "creeping" on an ex-partner’s social media leads to lower personal growth and increased distress. It's basically digital self-harm. You're looking at a curated, filtered highlight reel of someone's life and comparing it to your messy, real-time Sunday afternoon.
It’s easy to romanticize a photo of a tree. It’s harder to remember that they didn't help pay for it, or that they complained the whole time it was being decorated.
Breaking the Cycle of Ghost-Hunting
If you're feeling the pull to reach out, stop.
Drink some water. Go for a walk. Realize that the "crave" is actually just a need for connection, not a need for him. Our brains are remarkably bad at distinguishing between "I am lonely" and "I need my ex-boyfriend."
Instead of looking backward, look at the traditions you can build solo or with friends. The "Galentine’s" concept shouldn't just be for February. December is actually the prime time for it. Surround yourself with people who actually know the current version of you, not the 2019 version who thought a scarf was a substitute for emotional availability.
💡 You might also like: Campbell Hall Virginia Tech Explained (Simply)
How to Handle an "Old Ghost" Reaching Out
Sometimes, you aren't the one doing the haunting. Sometimes, one of those boyfriends of Christmas past slides into your DMs with a "Thinking of you" or a "Happy Holidays."
It’s a trap.
Usually, they’re just bored or feeling the same holiday-induced loneliness you are. It’s rarely a sign of genuine growth or a desire to rekindle something healthy. If they wanted to be in your life, they would have been there in October when things were boring.
If you do decide to respond, keep it short. Keep it "business casual." You don't owe anyone a deep dive into your emotional state just because they saw a snowflake and remembered you existed.
Moving Forward Without the Haunting
The goal isn't to erase the past. Those memories are part of your story. But you have to stop letting them take up the prime real estate of your current holiday season.
Acknowledge the memory. "Oh, that was a fun night in 2021." Then put it back on the shelf.
The boyfriends of Christmas past serve one real purpose: they are benchmarks. They show you what you used to accept, how you used to love, and how much you’ve changed since then. Usually, that change is for the better.
Immediate Action Steps for a Ghost-Free Holiday
- Audit your feed. If seeing an ex's holiday photos makes your stomach drop, mute them. Right now. Don't wait for the New Year's Eve post.
- Reclaim a "Ruined" Tradition. Did an ex love a specific Christmas market? Go there with your best friend. Order the most expensive thing on the menu. Overwrite the memory.
- Write a "Reality Check" List. When you start romanticizing a past relationship, write down three specific, annoying, or hurtful things that actually happened. Keep it in your Notes app. Read it when you feel the urge to text.
- Invest in Newness. Buy a new ornament. Try a recipe you’ve never made. Start a tradition that has zero ties to anyone you used to date.
The holidays are short. Don't spend them living in a version of the past that never actually existed. Focus on the present—even if the present is just you, a weighted blanket, and a really good bottle of wine. That’s much better than a ghost.