You walk into Kayne Prime and the first thing you notice isn't the smell of searing beef. It's the chandeliers. Big, amber, glowing things that make the place feel more like a high-end lounge in Tribeca than a traditional steakhouse in the Gulch. People talk about the kayne steakhouse nashville menu like it’s just another place to get a ribeye, but they're missing the point. This isn't a "baked potato and shrimp cocktail" kind of joint.
Honestly, if you go there and just order a New York Strip, you’ve basically wasted your reservation.
The Starters That Actually Matter
Most folks look at a steakhouse menu and skip straight to the "1200 Degree" section. Don't do that. The appetizers here are where Executive Chef Steven Chandler and the team really mess with your head in the best way possible.
📖 Related: Why Assembly Hall Bar + Market is More Than Just a Food Hall
Take the Housemade Bacon. It’s basically a thick slab of black peppercorn-crusted pork belly, but they serve it with a puff of maple cotton candy. It sounds like something a kid would invent in a fever dream. You take a bite of the salty, fatty pork, and the sugar just melts into the crust. It’s $22, and yeah, it’s worth the hype.
Then there’s the Popcorn Buttered Lobster. It’s exactly what it sounds like—lobster meat tossed with actual popcorn and beurre monte. It’s whimsical. It’s weird. It works.
Navigating the Beef: From Niman Ranch to Japanese Wagyu
When you finally get to the steaks, the menu is split into tiers. You’ve got your "Boutique" cuts and then you’ve got the heavy hitters.
- The Classics: These are your Niman Ranch cuts. The 8oz Filet Mignon usually sits around $68. It's solid. It's what you expect.
- The Wagyu Selection: This is where the bill starts to climb. They’ve got Australian Wagyu and American Wagyu from Mishima Reserve. If you're feeling flush, the 32oz Wagyu Tomahawk is a $285 statement piece.
- The Japanese A5: They source from places like Hokkaido and Shiga. They sell it by the ounce, usually with a 2-ounce minimum. We’re talking $35 to $55 per ounce.
If you can't decide, look for the Shigoku Progression. For about $495, you get a 3-ounce tasting of Omi, Olive Fed, and Kobe striploins. It’s a lot of money for nine ounces of meat, but if you're a steak nerd, it’s the varsity level.
The "Sides" That Aren't Really Sides
Most steakhouses treat sides as an afterthought. Here, the Cream Corn Brûlée is a mandatory order. It has this torched, sugary crust on top with roasted jalapeños inside. It’s sweet, spicy, and creamy all at once.
The Potato Aligot is another sleeper hit. It’s so full of Gruyère and mozzarella that it has the consistency of fondue. You could probably stretch it from the table to the ceiling.
Why the "Green Plate" Exists
Interestingly, Kayne Prime is one of the few high-end steakhouses in Nashville that doesn't ignore vegetarians. Their Green Plate Special is a $40-$50 multi-course vegetarian experience that changes with the market. It’s not just a plate of steamed broccoli; it’s actually thoughtful cooking.
The Vibe and the "Hidden" Costs
There is a dress code. It’s business casual. Don’t show up in a baseball cap or a tank top; they’ll politely ask you to fix that.
🔗 Read more: Finding the Best Haircuts for Different Head Shapes: What Your Stylist Isn't Telling You
The wine list is massive. Seriously, it's a book. If you aren't careful, you’ll spend more on a bottle of Cab than you did on the Tomahawk. But the cocktails are where the value is. Their Old Fashioned variations are consistently some of the best in the city, especially the ones using local Tennessee whiskey.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
- The Popover Rule: They serve complimentary popovers with bone marrow butter. They are airy and incredible. Do not fill up on them. I repeat: do not eat three of them before your steak arrives.
- Split the Sides: The sides are huge. Two people can easily share one order of the risotto tater tots or the Brussels sprouts.
- The Bar Hack: If you can’t get a reservation—and on weekends, you won't—the bar area often has full menu service. Get there at 4:30 PM when they open.
- The Signature Toppings: Instead of a sauce, try a "Chapeau." The bone marrow butter or the blue cheese crust ($4-$7) adds more depth than a standard béarnaise.
If you’re looking for a traditional, quiet, mahogany-walled steakhouse, this isn’t it. Kayne Prime is loud, it’s dark, and the food is experimental. But if you want a meal that you’ll actually remember three weeks later, this is the spot in Nashville.