The sight of Sutton Stracke and Garcelle Beauvais together used to be the only thing that felt "real" in the hyper-edited world of Beverly Hills. They were the Lucy and Ethel of Bravo—one a Southern socialite with a penchant for couture and the other a Hollywood staple with a "tell it like it is" attitude that kept the cast on their toes. But if you’ve been keeping up with the mess lately, you know that the air in 90210 has gone cold.
Are Sutton and Garcelle still friends? Honestly, the short answer is no. They aren’t just "on a break" like Ross and Rachel. As of January 2026, the friendship is officially, and quite publicly, over.
The Moment Everything Shattered
It wasn't a slow fade. It was a car crash. The Season 14 reunion of The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills (RHOBH) was the crime scene. While the cameras caught plenty of shouting, it was what happened when Garcelle walked off that set that changed everything. She didn't just walk to her dressing room; she walked away from the show and, apparently, from Sutton.
Garcelle was visibly checked out during that reunion. She felt like she was on an island, constantly defending herself while the rest of the cast—Sutton included—didn't really have her back. The "alliance" (as Dorit Kemsley famously called it) wasn't enough to save the friendship when the heat got turned up.
By the time the cameras stopped rolling, Garcelle refused to even take the group photo. She told the producers she was "done" with the "f***ing assholes," and it turns out that blanket statement included her supposed bestie.
🔗 Read more: Jared Leto Nude: Why the Actor's Relationship With Nudity Is So Controversial
Garcelle’s Final Word
If you think this is just fan speculation, Garcelle cleared the air herself. During an appearance on Watch What Happens Live in late 2025, Andy Cohen asked the question everyone was dying to hear: "Is the friendship with Sutton completely over?"
Garcelle’s response was a simple, "Yes."
She didn't sugarcoat it. She mentioned that Sutton didn't just fail to defend her during the reunion, but that even afterward, Sutton never took accountability for her role in the fallout. Garcelle basically said she’s moved into a different space now. She’s focusing on her kids, her production deals, and a life that doesn’t involve being someone’s "emotional support human" on national television.
Why Sutton is Still "Sad"
On the other side of the fence, Sutton seems to be struggling with the reality of the situation. In the Season 15 premiere, which just hit screens in December 2025, we saw a very different Sutton. She was actually in tears talking about Garcelle.
💡 You might also like: Jada Pinkett Smith With Hair: What Most People Get Wrong About Her Journey
"I loved Garcelle," she told the cameras while wiping away tears. "We were best friends."
She’s been doing the media rounds claiming she texted Garcelle "again and again" but never got a response. Sutton’s take is that she’s giving Garcelle "space," but Garcelle’s actions—like unfollowing Sutton’s personal and business accounts—suggest she’s looking for a clean break, not a temporary distance.
The "Sutton-Centric" Problem
The most interesting perspective on this breakup actually came from a surprising source: Jennifer Tilly. As a close friend of Sutton’s who joined the cast in a bigger capacity for Season 15, Jennifer didn't hold back in recent episodes.
In a conversation with Kyle Richards that aired just this month, Jennifer admitted she thinks Sutton’s personality is part of why Garcelle left. "It's always all about Sutton," Tilly said. Coming from one of Sutton’s actual real-life friends, that carries a lot of weight. It hints at a pattern where Sutton’s "fragility" or need for attention eventually exhausts the people around her.
📖 Related: How Tall is Charlie Hurt? The Fox News Personality Explained
Where Do They Stand Right Now?
To wrap your head around where they are today, look at the receipts:
- Social Media: Garcelle has unfollowed Sutton everywhere. Sutton still follows Garcelle, occasionally "liking" a post, but the engagement is strictly one-way.
- Filming: Garcelle has officially left RHOBH. Without the "contractual" obligation to see each other, they haven't been spotted together in months.
- Public Comments: Garcelle says it's over; Sutton says she's "giving her space."
It’s a classic case of two people remembering the same relationship differently. Garcelle felt like she was a shield for Sutton for years, and the moment she needed a shield herself, Sutton was too busy trying to stay in Kyle Richards' good graces to help out.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans
If you’re holding out hope for a reconciliation, don’t hold your breath for Season 15. The "Lucy and Ethel" era is firmly in the rearview mirror.
If you want to keep tabs on the fallout, watch Jennifer Tilly’s role this season. She seems to be filling the "best friend" vacuum left by Garcelle, but she’s already showing signs of frustration with the "Sutton Show." Also, keep an eye on Garcelle’s upcoming Lifetime projects—she’s clearly making moves that have nothing to do with reality TV drama.
The biggest lesson here? Sometimes the most "real" friendships on TV are the ones that can’t survive the reality of the show itself. Garcelle chose her peace, and Sutton is left trying to figure out who she is without her most loyal ally.