Honestly, in 2012, Andy Samberg was basically the king of the "cool" internet. He’d just finished a legendary seven-year run on Saturday Night Live, where he and his Lonely Island buddies basically invented the SNL Digital Short. He was exhausted. He wanted to do movies. The last thing anyone expected was for him to jump straight back into the grueling schedule of a network sitcom.
But then Andy Samberg and Brooklyn Nine-Nine happened.
It wasn't a sure thing. Far from it. When Mike Schur and Dan Goor pitched the show, people were skeptical. Could the "Dick in a Box" guy really lead a broadcast comedy? Could he play a cop without it feeling like a parody of a parody?
Why Andy Samberg Almost Said No to the Nine-Nine
Samberg has been pretty open about how burnt out he was after SNL. The schedule at 30 Rock is notoriously soul-crushing. You’re writing at 4 a.m., surviving on caffeine and sheer adrenaline. When Schur and Goor approached him, he wasn't looking for another TV gig.
He told TheWrap back in 2013 that he was a massive fan of Parks and Recreation. That was the hook. He saw what that team did for Amy Poehler and realized he’d be an idiot to pass up that kind of writing. He took a couple of days to think about it, but he already knew. He was in.
The character of Jake Peralta was a tightrope walk. He had to be "ridiculously efficient" but also a "man-child." If he was too annoying, the show would fail. If he was too serious, it wouldn't be a Samberg project.
📖 Related: Colin Macrae Below Deck: Why the Fan-Favorite Engineer Finally Walked Away
The $125,000 Per Episode Magic
By the time the show hit its stride, Samberg was reportedly pulling in $125,000 per episode. That’s a lot of yogurt money. But he wasn't just a face on a poster. As an executive producer, he had a massive hand in the show's DNA.
One of the coolest things about the Andy Samberg and Brooklyn Nine-Nine era was how generous he was as a lead. Usually, the "star" wants all the punchlines. Samberg? He was happy to play the straight man to Andre Braugher’s Captain Holt or let Joe Lo Truglio’s Charles Boyle take the physical comedy wins.
He once told the LA Times that Joe Lo Truglio had been a legend in the comedy community for two decades, and it felt "insane" that it took this long for him to get a spotlight. That’s the vibe Samberg brought to the set. It wasn't the "Andy Samberg Show." It was a true ensemble.
That Time the Show Died (For 30 Hours)
We have to talk about May 10, 2018. It was a dark day. Fox officially canceled the series after five seasons. The internet basically exploded.
It wasn't just fans tweeting hashtags. Legends like Lin-Manuel Miranda, Mark Hamill, and Guillermo del Toro were publicly mourning the show. It was a cultural moment. Samberg later joked to Seth Meyers that it must have been a "slow news day," but the reality was that people genuinely cared about these characters.
👉 See also: Cómo salvar a tu favorito: La verdad sobre la votación de La Casa de los Famosos Colombia
NBC swooped in less than two days later. For Samberg, it was a homecoming. He’d spent his formative years at NBC with SNL. He even said that when he walked back into 30 Rock for the upfronts, the security guards were giving him hugs.
What People Get Wrong About Jake Peralta
A lot of people think Jake is just a 1:1 copy of Samberg’s real personality. It’s not. Jake is a "Die Hard" obsessed, emotionally stunted detective who uses humor as a defense mechanism because his dad left.
Samberg actually brought a lot of nuance to the role as the years went on. Think about the growth:
- Season 1 Jake: Competes with Amy Santiago to see who can get more arrests. Total chaos agent.
- Middle Seasons: Actually falls in love. Learns that being a "tough guy" isn't as cool as being a good partner.
- The Finale: He literally quits his dream job to be a stay-at-home dad.
That last part is huge. It subverted the entire "hero cop" trope. He realized his son, Mac, needed the upbringing he never had.
The Andre Braugher Factor
You can't talk about Samberg on this show without talking about the late, great Andre Braugher. Their chemistry was "kinda kismet," as Samberg put it on Reddit.
✨ Don't miss: Cliff Richard and The Young Ones: The Weirdest Bromance in TV History Explained
Braugher came from a world of Juilliard and Shakespeare. He didn't trust himself with comedy at first. Samberg was the one who helped bridge that gap. The dynamic of the hyperactive Peralta and the stoic Holt became the backbone of the entire series. When Braugher passed away, Samberg noted how difficult a reunion would be because Holt was the "base DNA" of why the show worked.
Life After the Precinct
Since the show wrapped in 2021, Samberg hasn't exactly been lounging around.
- Palm Springs (2020): He proved he could do "indie darling" movies while the show was still airing.
- Digman!: His animated series that dives into a world where archaeologists are celebrities.
- Voice Acting: He’s stayed busy with Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse and Hotel Transylvania.
He’s also returned to SNL recently to play Doug Emhoff. It’s like he can’t stay away from the 30 Rock halls for too long.
Your Nine-Nine Binge Strategy
If you're revisiting the show or watching it for the first time because of Samberg, don't just look for the big "Cool, cool, cool" moments.
Watch the "The Box" (Season 5, Episode 14). It’s basically just Andy Samberg, Andre Braugher, and Sterling K. Brown in an interrogation room. No B-plots. No fluff. It’s a masterclass in acting and shows exactly why this show was more than just a silly sitcom.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans
- Check out the "The Lonely Island" Podcast: If you want to hear the real Andy Samberg talk about the early days of his career, this is the place.
- Watch 'Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping': If you love Jake Peralta’s brand of idiocy, this movie is the peak version of it.
- Follow the Cast: Most of them, like Melissa Fumero and Terry Crews, are still super active and often post BTS memories that never made it to the DVDs.
The legacy of Andy Samberg and Brooklyn Nine-Nine is pretty simple: it was a show about good people trying to be better. In a world of cynical TV, that’s probably why it still ranks so high on everyone’s comfort-watch list.