It started with a literal buzz. That distorted, gravelly bassline that feels like a swarm of bees trapped in a subwoofer. Then, the voice. "The truth will set you free," Pharrell Williams whispers, "but first, it'll piss you off." If you were alive and near a radio in late 2017, you couldn't escape it. N.E.R.D. and Rihanna’s "Lemon" didn't just mark a comeback; it was a cultural reset for a band that had been dormant for seven years.
Honestly, nobody expected Rihanna to rap like that. We knew she could handle a melody, and we knew she had "swag," but "Lemon" saw her tapping into a cadence that felt less like a pop star and more like a seasoned battle rapper from the Bronx. It was jarring. It was brilliant. It was exactly what music needed at a time when everything was starting to sound a bit too polished.
The Secret History of the Lemon Beat
Pharrell Williams is a hoarder of ideas. He doesn’t just "write" a song; he archives sounds until the world is ready for them. The skeleton of the "Lemon" beat had been floating around his studio for a while. In fact, many fans don't realize that the track was originally intended for a different project. It has that signature Neptunes minimalism—claps, a trunk-rattling bass, and a lot of empty space.
But why Rihanna?
Pharrell has gone on record saying that once the beat was finalized, he knew he needed someone with a specific "don't give a damn" energy. N.E.R.D. (composed of Pharrell, Chad Hugo, and Shae Haley) has always been about the "No-one Ever Really Dies" philosophy, which is basically about eternal youth and creative rebellion. Rihanna is the living embodiment of that. When she stepped into the booth, she didn't just provide a hook. She took over.
That Verse: Breaking Down the "Rih-rap"
"Bacc it up, bacc it up."
💡 You might also like: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
That three-word refrain became a mantra. But let’s look at the complexity of her verse. She’s playing with internal rhymes and a staccato flow that most rappers would struggle to maintain over that tempo. She references "the bath with the bubbles," "the whip," and "the vision." It’s a flex, sure, but it’s delivered with a cold, calculated precision.
The most fascinating part? Pharrell actually wrote the verse. Usually, when a pop star raps a verse written by someone else, it sounds forced. You can hear the gears turning. But Rihanna internalized Pharrell’s quirky, off-beat writing style and made it her own. It’s a masterclass in collaboration.
Why the Music Video Mattered More Than You Think
If the song was a punch to the gut, the music video was a roundhouse kick to the head. Directed by Todd Tourso and Scott Cudmore, the visual starts with Rihanna shaving a woman's head. That woman is Mette Towley, a dancer who, after this video, became an overnight sensation.
The video is essentially one long, continuous-feeling take of Mette dancing in an indoor flea market. It’s raw. There are no fancy light shows or CGI dragons. It’s just human movement. This was a strategic move. By centering the video on Mette’s incredible athleticism and raw talent rather than just showing Rihanna’s face for four minutes, the group emphasized the "nerd" aesthetic—celebrating the unconventional and the highly skilled.
It was a viral moment before TikTok made viral moments mandatory. Every dancer on Instagram spent the next six months trying to recreate Mette’s "Lemon" choreography. It reminded people that music videos could still be art pieces, not just advertisements for a brand.
📖 Related: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
The Political Undercurrents of No One Ever Really Dies
"Lemon" was the lead single for the album No One Ever Really Dies. While "Lemon" feels like a club banger on the surface, the album itself was deeply political. 2017 was a heavy year. The US was grappling with intense social division, and N.E.R.D. didn't shy away from it.
If you listen closely to the lyrics of the track, there’s a sense of urgency. The "lemon" metaphor itself—turning something sour into something profitable or usable—is a classic American trope, but Pharrell twists it. It’s about the struggle. It’s about being "pissed off" before you find freedom.
- The "Truth" Sample: The song opens with a sample of a woman shouting "The truth will set you free!" This isn't just a catchy intro. It’s a nod to the era of "fake news" and the search for authenticity.
- The Minimalism: By stripping away the lush production common in 2017 trap music, N.E.R.D. forced the listener to pay attention to the words and the rhythm.
- The Collaboration: Bringing together a black skate-rock-nerd band with a Caribbean superstar was a statement of unity in a fractured landscape.
Technical Brilliance: Why it Sounds "Right"
From a production standpoint, Chad Hugo’s influence is all over this. While Pharrell is the face, Chad is the secret weapon. He’s the one who ensures the synthesizers have that specific, analog warmth. In "Lemon," the synth melody is almost non-existent. It’s a percussion-driven track.
The "squeeze" sound you hear throughout the song—that high-pitched, chirping noise—is a classic Neptunes trope. It keeps your brain engaged. It’s a psychological trick; by using repetitive, sharp sounds, the producers trigger an "alert" response in the listener's brain, which makes the song feel more energetic than it actually is. It’s a mid-tempo track that feels like a high-speed chase.
The Lemon Effect on Rihanna's Career
People often forget that before "Lemon," there was a debate about whether Rihanna was "over" her experimental phase after the ANTI album. "Lemon" proved she could jump on a weird, avant-garde track and still dominate the charts. It gave her the "cool factor" back in the eyes of the indie crowd while keeping her firmly planted in the pop world.
👉 See also: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
It also set the stage for her later features. She stopped doing generic EDM features and started picking weird, interesting projects. Without the success of "Lemon," we might not have seen her take the creative risks she took in the following years with her fashion and beauty empires. She learned that being a "nerd"—being obsessive, being niche, being technical—was actually her greatest strength.
Misconceptions About the Song
Some people think "Lemon" was a flop because it didn't hit Number 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 immediately. That’s a mistake. It was a "sleeper hit." It stayed in the cultural consciousness for years. You still hear it at NBA games. You still hear it in fashion shows.
Another misconception is that the song is about wealth. While there are references to "the whip" and "the vision," the core of the song is about resilience. It’s about the "lemon" of life—the hardships—and the "lemon" of the industry. It’s a song about staying sour enough to keep your edge but sweet enough to stay in the game.
Actionable Insights for Music Fans and Creators
If you’re a creator, "Lemon" is a case study in how to collaborate.
- Don’t play to strengths; play to surprises. Don’t ask a singer to sing. Ask them to rap. Don’t ask a dancer to be a background prop. Make them the star.
- Embrace the "Empty Space." You don't need 100 tracks in your DAW. Sometimes a kick, a snare, and a weird synth chirp are enough if the "vibe" is right.
- Visuals are not secondary. The "Lemon" video is 50% of the reason the song was successful. If you’re releasing music, think about the "one-shot" idea. How can you capture attention without a million-dollar budget? Focus on raw talent.
- Wait for the right moment. Pharrell held onto that beat. He didn't rush it. If you have a great idea that doesn't fit the current trend, put it in the "vault." The world might catch up to you in a few years.
The legacy of the N.E.R.D. and Rihanna collaboration isn't just a catchy song. It’s a reminder that the most successful "pop" music is often the stuff that sounds the least like pop. It’s the "lemon" in the sugar bowl. It’s the sharp, acidic, refreshing break from the status quo that keeps the industry moving forward.
Next time you hear that "Bacc it up" refrain, listen for the claps. Listen for the silence between the beats. That’s where the magic is. It’s a masterclass in restraint, and in a world that’s constantly screaming for attention, sometimes a whisper and a heavy bassline are the loudest things in the room.
The real lesson here? Never count out the nerds. They usually have the best records.