Some celebrity pairings just stick in your brain. You know the ones—they didn't have a messy, public fallout or a multi-season reality show, but they felt significant. That’s exactly how it feels when you look back at Zachary Quinto and Jonathan Groff.
It’s been over a decade since they were a "thing," yet search trends still spike whenever one of them wins a Tony or lands a major Sci-Fi role. Why? Honestly, it’s probably because they represented a very specific moment in Hollywood history. They were two of the first high-profile, "out" leading men who weren't afraid to be seen together before it was considered "safe" for an actor's career.
The Relationship Timeline: How It Actually Happened
Let's get the facts straight. They didn't meet on a movie set, and there wasn't some big cinematic "meet-cute." They were just two actors working in the same circles.
✨ Don't miss: Is Malcolm-Jamal Warner Dead? What Really Happened With the Rumors
Rumors started swirling around 2010. At the time, Zachary Quinto was massive because of Heroes and his role as Spock in the Star Trek reboot. Jonathan Groff was the Broadway darling who had just broken into the mainstream via Glee.
They kept things incredibly low-key. For two years, it was all speculation. It wasn't until September 2012 that Quinto finally confirmed the relationship during an interview with Out magazine. He didn't make a huge spectacle of it; he basically just mentioned he was in a relationship and "very happy."
Then, almost as soon as the public got used to them as a couple, it ended. By July 2013, news broke that they had split. Sources at the time cited "busy schedules" and "long distance," which sounds like the standard PR line, but given their career trajectories—Groff heading to film Looking in San Francisco and Quinto's filming schedule—it actually made sense.
Why people are still obsessed
People love a "what if."
👉 See also: Rita Marley Grandchildren: What You Didn't Know About the Third Generation
Since their split, both have gone on to reach the absolute top of their fields. Groff is a literal Disney prince (voice of Kristoff in Frozen) and a Tony winner for Merrily We Roll Along. Quinto has remained a steady force in both prestige TV like American Horror Story and big-budget films.
There is a weirdly wholesome quality to their post-breakup lives. Unlike most Hollywood exes, there is zero bad blood. In 2024, Groff even mentioned in an interview that his first boyfriend—widely believed by fans to be either Gavin Creel or Quinto—attended one of his performances, calling it a "full-circle moment." It’s that kind of maturity that keeps fans rooting for them individually.
Zachary Quinto and Jonathan Groff: The Impact on Hollywood
You have to remember what the industry looked like in 2010.
Back then, "coming out" was still seen as a potential career-killer for an action star or a romantic lead. By being open about their relationship, Zachary Quinto and Jonathan Groff shifted the needle. They proved you could be a gay man and still play the most logical commander in the galaxy or a heartthrob on Broadway.
They weren't "activists" in the traditional sense, but their existence as a couple was a form of activism.
- Visibility: They showed up at events together without making it a "statement."
- Professionalism: Neither let their personal lives overshadow their work.
- Normalcy: They were just two guys dating who happened to be famous.
Life after the split
What happened next?
Quinto went on to have a long-term relationship with model Miles McMillan. They were together for nearly six years, even buying a gorgeous apartment in Manhattan together before splitting amicably in 2019. Since then, Quinto has been relatively private, focusing heavily on stage work and producing.
Groff, on the other hand, had a high-profile relationship with choreographer Corey Baker from 2018 to 2020. As of early 2026, Groff has been pretty vocal about being single but "open to anything." He’s famously avoided social media, which probably helps him keep his private life, well, private.
What Most People Get Wrong
The biggest misconception is that they were together for a long time. In reality, their public "confirmed" relationship lasted less than a year. The idea of them has lasted much longer than the actual partnership.
Another myth? That they don't speak. While they aren't exactly posting selfies together, the Broadway community is tight-knit. They move in the same circles, support the same charities (like the Point Foundation), and have shared many of the same co-stars.
👉 See also: Most Famous Person of All Time: Why the Data Points to One Surprising Figure
Actionable Insights for Fans and Observers
If you’re looking to follow their journeys today, here’s how to stay updated without falling for tabloid clickbait:
- Check Playbill, not TMZ: Both Groff and Quinto prioritize theater. Their most authentic interviews usually happen around their stage openings.
- Watch the Tonys: This is where you’ll see the most "crossover" in their professional worlds.
- Respect the Privacy: Both actors have made it clear that while they are out and proud, they don't owe the public a play-by-play of their dating lives.
The legacy of Zachary Quinto and Jonathan Groff isn't just about a breakup from 2013. It’s about the fact that they paved a path. Today, an actor coming out is barely a headline. In 2012, it was a revolution. We have them—and their quiet, dignified romance—to thank for at least a small part of that progress.
To stay truly informed, follow their production companies rather than gossip columns. Quinto’s Before the Door Pictures and Groff’s various collaborative projects in the theater world are where the real story of their careers is being written now.