In 1897, an eight-year-old girl named Virginia O'Hanlon lived in Manhattan. She had a problem. Her friends were starting to say that Santa Claus wasn't real. You know that feeling, right? That sinking realization that the magic might be a lie. Her father, Philip O'Hanlon, didn't want to be the one to break it to her, so he suggested she write to The Sun, a prominent New York City newspaper. He basically told her that if it was in The Sun, it was true.
That tiny letter sparked a response that became the most reprinted newspaper editorial in history. It gave us the phrase Yes Virginia, there is a Santa Claus. But if you actually read the text today, it’s not just a cute holiday story. It’s a philosophical defense of things we can’t see. It’s about the reality of the intangible.
The Man Who Wrote the Myth
Francis Pharcellus Church was the guy who had to answer Virginia. Honestly, he wasn't the obvious choice for a whimsical Christmas piece. Church was a veteran war correspondent. He had covered the American Civil War. He was used to grit, blood, and hard facts. He was a skeptic by trade.
When the letter landed on his desk, he reportedly didn't want to do it. He was a bit of a grump about it initially. But he sat down and wrote it in one afternoon. What came out wasn't a lie about a guy in a red suit coming down a chimney. Church took a different route. He argued that the most "real" things in the world are the ones that neither children nor men can see.
He wasn't trying to trick Virginia. He was trying to explain that a world without poetry, romance, and faith would be unendurable. It was a bold move for a 19th-century journalist.
Why the Letter Still Matters in 2026
We live in a world of data. We have sensors, satellites, and AI that can track almost anything. In a way, we’re more skeptical than Virginia’s friends ever were. Yet, the editorial "Is There a Santa Claus?"—which is the actual formal title—continues to trend every single December.
Why?
👉 See also: Images of Thanksgiving Holiday: What Most People Get Wrong
Because it addresses a universal human fear: the fear that the world is just a cold, mechanical place. Church wrote that "the eternal light with which childhood fills the world would be extinguished" without that sense of wonder. That’s a heavy concept for an 1897 newspaper. It’s about the idea that love and devotion exist even if you can’t put them in a test tube.
Fact-Checking the Legend of Virginia O'Hanlon
There are a lot of myths about Virginia. Some people think she was a made-up character used by the paper to boost sales. She wasn’t. Virginia O'Hanlon was very real. She grew up to be a teacher and a school principal. She spent a large chunk of her life answering letters from children about Santa.
- She earned a Doctorate in Education from Fordham University.
- She worked with children who were in hospitals or had chronic illnesses.
- She never got tired of the "Yes Virginia" legacy.
Actually, the original editorial didn't even have a byline. Francis Church wasn't credited for it until after he died in 1906. It was just an unsigned opinion piece. The Sun realized they had a hit on their hands when they started getting requests for reprints every year. It became a tradition because the public demanded it, not because the editors planned it.
The Philosophy of the Intangible
When Church wrote Yes there is a Santa Claus, he was using a rhetorical device called "the reality of the unseen." He compares Santa to fairies on the lawn. He says that just because you don't see them dancing, it doesn't mean they aren't there.
You've probably heard people argue that telling kids about Santa is "lying." It's a common debate in parenting circles. Church’s editorial provides the counter-argument. He suggests that the "realest" things are the things we can't see, like love and beauty. He frames Santa not as a person, but as a spirit of generosity.
He wrote: "He exists as certainly as love and generosity and devotion exist." That’s a nuanced take. It shifts the conversation from a biological man at the North Pole to a persistent human emotion.
✨ Don't miss: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessing Over Maybelline SuperStay Skin Tint
Breaking Down the Editorial's Impact
The piece is surprisingly short. Only about 400 words. It’s punchy. Church uses short, sharp sentences to drive his points home. He uses words like "skepticism," "abnormal," and "dreary."
He wasn't talking down to Virginia. He treated her question with the seriousness of a political debate or a theological inquiry. That’s probably why it stuck. Most people talk to kids like they’re simple. Church talked to Virginia like she was a person trying to understand the fabric of the universe.
- The Social Context: In 1897, New York was a city of extreme contrast. Immense wealth and crushing poverty lived side-by-side. The editorial offered a sense of shared humanity that didn't cost anything.
- The Timing: It was published on September 21. Not December. People often forget that. It wasn't a Christmas Eve rush job; it was a response to a kid's nagging question in the late summer heat.
Common Misconceptions About the Story
Let’s clear some stuff up. First off, Virginia wasn't some poor orphan. Her father was a doctor. She was a middle-class kid.
Second, The Sun didn't think it was a big deal at first. It was buried in the third column of the editorial page, way below a piece about the election laws of Connecticut. It took years for it to become the "most famous editorial."
Third, the phrase wasn't a marketing slogan. It was a genuine answer to a genuine question. The paper actually resisted making it a huge deal initially because they were a "serious" news outlet. They didn't want to be known for "fairy tales."
A Lesson for the Digital Age
Honestly, we could learn a lot from Church's approach. We’re so obsessed with "debunking" things now. We want to "well, actually" everything into oblivion. Church argues that debunking the magic of life makes the world "as dreary as if there were no Virginias."
🔗 Read more: Coach Bag Animal Print: Why These Wild Patterns Actually Work as Neutrals
He uses a metaphor about a telescope. Even if you could see through the stars, you wouldn't see the spirit of the world. It’s about the limits of perception. It's a reminder that not everything worth knowing can be measured with a ruler or a clock.
The Practical Legacy of Virginia’s Question
If you want to experience this history yourself, there are a few things you can actually do. The original letter and the editorial are preserved in various archives, but the sentiment is everywhere.
- Visit the New York Public Library: They often have displays related to 19th-century journalism and Virginia’s story during the holidays.
- Read the Full Text: Don't just read the "Yes Virginia" part. Read the whole thing. The language is old-fashioned, but the logic is incredibly tight.
- The Radio Play: There are several recordings of the editorial being read by famous voices, including Boris Karloff and Lou Costello. Hearing it read aloud changes the cadence significantly.
Virginia herself died in 1971. She lived long enough to see her letter turned into an animated special and a play. She always maintained that her father was right—the truth is what we choose to believe in.
Actionable Insights for Cultivating Wonder
If you’re a parent, or just a human trying to navigate a cynical world, the story of Yes there is a Santa Claus offers a roadmap.
Stop trying to prove everything. Some things are true because they produce true results. Generosity is real. Kindness is real. If the idea of Santa makes a child more generous or more hopeful, then in a very practical, measurable way, that "spirit" is performing work in the physical world.
Instead of focusing on the "lie," focus on the tradition of giving. The best way to keep the spirit of Virginia’s letter alive isn't just by reading the editorial. It’s by becoming the "Santa" Church described—the one that represents love and devotion.
- Look for the Unseen: Make a habit of acknowledging the "invisible" things that make your life better, like someone's patience or a stranger's smile.
- Practice Narrative Honesty: When kids ask hard questions, don't just give a "yes" or "no." Give them a reason to think, just like Francis Church did for Virginia.
- Preserve the Mystery: Leave some things unexplained. Not everything needs a Google search. Sometimes, "I don't know, what do you think?" is the best answer you can give.
The editorial ends with a famous promise. Church says that Santa will continue to make glad the heart of childhood a thousand years from now. "Nay, ten times ten thousand years from now." We’re about 129 years into that prediction. So far, he’s been right.
The value of the story isn't in the bearded man. It's in the fact that an eight-year-old girl challenged a major newspaper to prove that the world wasn't a cynical place—and the newspaper, for once, rose to the occasion.