You’re standing in the produce aisle. You see a bin of bright, waxy cylinders. You grab three, toss them in a plastic bag, and go home. Most people just call it "yellow squash." But honestly, that’s like calling every dog a "canine" and moving on with your day. There is a massive world of pictures of yellow squash varieties that most people never actually see because big-box grocery chains prioritize shelf life over flavor.
It’s kind of a tragedy.
If you’ve only ever eaten the standard straightneck from a supermarket, you’ve missed out on the nutty, buttery, and sometimes surprisingly sweet profiles of heirloom cultivars. I’m talking about the stuff that looks like a UFO or a bumpy, curved bird. These aren’t just "summer squash." They are distinct genetic lines with wildly different textures. Some hold up in a sauté, while others turn to mush the second they hit a hot pan. Knowing which is which changes everything about your cooking.
The classic straightneck vs. crooked neck debate
Most pictures of yellow squash varieties you find online start with the Prolific Straightneck. It’s the industry standard. It’s uniform. It’s easy to pack in a crate. Farmers love it because it grows fast and looks "clean" on a shelf. But if you talk to any old-school gardener, they’ll tell you the Early Golden Crookneck is where the real flavor lives.
The Crookneck is weird-looking. It has a bulbous bottom and a skinny, curved neck. It’s usually covered in little bumps or "warts." To a modern shopper, those bumps look like a disease or a defect. They aren't. In the world of heirloom squash, those bumps often signal a denser flesh and a lower water content.
Why does that matter?
Water is the enemy of a good sear. When you throw a sliced straightneck into a skillet, it releases a flood of liquid. You end up boiling your squash instead of browning it. The Crookneck—specifically the heirloom varieties dating back to the 1800s—tends to stay firmer. It has a richer, almost savory "squash" taste that the watery hybrids just can't match.
💡 You might also like: How to grow a garden sprout egg without making a giant mess
Zephyr: The two-tone outlier
Then there’s the Zephyr. You’ve probably seen photos of this one and thought it was a fluke or a photoshop job. It’s yellow for the top two-thirds and then abruptly turns pale green at the bottom. It looks like it was dipped in paint. This isn't a natural accident; it’s a deliberate cross between a yellow crookneck and a delicata/acorn hybrid.
It’s delicious.
Actually, it’s better than delicious. It’s nutty. Most summer squash is fairly bland, acting as a vehicle for butter and garlic. Zephyr actually tastes like something. It has a distinct sweetness that makes it one of the few yellow squashes you can eat raw in a carpaccio or a shaved salad without it feeling like you're chewing on a wet sponge.
Beyond the cylinder: Scallops and Sunbursts
We need to talk about Pattypan squash. If you’re looking at pictures of yellow squash varieties and see something that looks like a flying saucer with scalloped edges, that’s a Pattypan. Specifically, the "Sunburst" variety is the one that wins all the awards. It’s bright yellow with a tiny green circle at the blossom end.
These are crunchy.
Not "carrot" crunchy, but they have a snap to them that a zucchini lacks. The mistake people make is buying them when they’re the size of a dinner plate. At that size, the skin is tough enough to stop a bullet and the seeds are like pumpkin seeds. You want them small. Roughly the size of a golf ball or a yo-yo. At that stage, you don't even need to slice them. You just toss them whole into a roasting pan with some olive oil and thyme.
The "Benning’s Green Tint" is another scallop variety, but it’s more of a pale, buttery yellow-green. It’s an heirloom from the early 20th century. It’s legendary for its productivity. If you plant one of these in your garden, be prepared to give squash away to your neighbors, your mailman, and people you haven't spoken to since high school. It’s relentless.
The Pattypan's unique texture
The internal structure of a yellow scallop squash is much denser than a straightneck. It’s almost creamy. Because of the shape, you get a higher ratio of skin to flesh, which provides more structural integrity during high-heat cooking. If you're grilling, skip the slices. Use Pattypans. They won't fall through the grates and they won't turn into a limp mess over the charcoal.
Don't ignore the Cousa and Middle Eastern varieties
While technically often categorized as "light green," many Cousa varieties lean heavily into the yellow spectrum, especially as they ripen. Magda is a prime example. It’s a hybrid Middle Eastern type that is blocky and pale. It’s the "butter" of the squash world.
If you find these at a farmer's market, buy all of them.
The flavor is remarkably sweet compared to a standard yellow squash. In many cultures, these are used specifically for stuffing (Kousa Mahshi). Because they are shorter and wider, they hold up to being hollowed out and filled with rice and lamb. Try doing that with a skinny yellow straightneck and you’ll just end up with a broken vegetable and a mess on your counter.
The "Yellow Zucchini" confusion
Wait. Isn't yellow squash just yellow zucchini?
No. Sorta.
It’s a "all squares are rectangles but not all rectangles are squares" situation. A yellow zucchini is a specific cultivar of Cucurbita pepo that has been bred to be perfectly cylindrical, just like a green zucchini, but with a yellow skin. Golden Glory is a popular commercial version.
The difference is in the "neck." A true yellow squash (straightneck or crookneck) tapers at the top. A yellow zucchini stays the same thickness from the stem to the blossom.
Texture-wise, yellow zucchinis are almost identical to green ones. They are mild, high-moisture, and have very thin skin. If you’re looking for a visual pop in a ratatouille, use a yellow zucchini. But if you want that specific "summer squash" flavor—which is slightly more earthy—you want the tapered yellow varieties.
Why color matters (and when it doesn't)
When looking at pictures of yellow squash varieties, you'll notice a range from pale cream to deep, sunset orange. Generally, the deeper the yellow, the higher the beta-carotene content. But color can also be a warning sign.
If a squash is turning a dull, brownish-yellow, it’s old. It’s going to be bitter.
Look for skin that is glossy. You want it to look like it’s under tension. If the skin is matte or feels soft to the touch, the sugars have started to turn into starches. It’s going to taste like cardboard.
Also, pay attention to the stem. A fresh squash should have a green, moist-looking stem. If the stem is shriveled and black, that squash has been sitting in a cold storage warehouse for weeks. It’s lost its soul.
Growing these at home: The Squash Vine Borer reality
If you decide to grow these varieties yourself because you’re tired of the grocery store's limited selection, you need to be prepared for war. Specifically, the war against the Squash Vine Borer.
It’s a moth. It looks like a wasp. It lays eggs at the base of your squash plants, and the larvae eat the plant from the inside out. One day your "Early Prolific" is beautiful; the next day it’s a wilted pile of sadness.
✨ Don't miss: How to write common app activities so they actually get you noticed
Expert tip: Look for "Tromboncino" squash. It’s technically a Cucurbita moschata (the same species as butternut squash), but it’s eaten as a summer squash when it’s young and green/yellow. Because it has a solid stem, the vine borers can’t get inside. It grows in a long, serpent-like coil and can reach three feet in length. It’s the ultimate cheat code for anyone who wants yellow summer squash without the heartbreak of pests.
The "Slicker" and "Smoothy" hybrids
If you're looking for the most photogenic pictures of yellow squash varieties, search for "Slicker" or "Lioness." These are modern hybrids bred to be "spineless." If you’ve ever harvested old-school yellow squash, you know the plants are covered in tiny, irritating hairs that make your arms itch for hours. Spineless varieties have smooth stems. They produce beautiful, blemish-free fruit because the squash isn't getting scratched by its own leaves in the wind.
They are the "supermodels" of the squash world. They look perfect. They taste... fine. They aren't as complex as the heirlooms, but they are incredibly reliable.
How to actually use these varieties
Stop boiling them. Please.
Yellow squash is roughly 95% water. Adding it to a pot of water is a culinary redundant.
- High-heat roasting: Cut Pattypans into quarters, toss with oil, and blast them at 425 degrees until the edges are black. The sugars caramelize and it becomes a completely different vegetable.
- Raw Ribbons: Use a vegetable peeler on a straightneck to create thin ribbons. Toss with lemon juice, salt, and pecorino cheese. The acidity of the lemon "cooks" the squash slightly, making it tender but keeping the crunch.
- The "Slow Melt": If you have some older, larger yellow squash, grate them. Sauté them in a pan with a lot of olive oil and a little garlic over medium-low heat for 30 minutes. They will eventually break down into a jam-like consistency. It’s incredible on toast.
Practical next steps for squash enthusiasts
If you want to move beyond the boring grocery store options, your first move is to find a local farmer's market during the peak of summer (usually July or August). Ask the growers specifically for "Zephyr" or "Crookneck" varieties. Most small-scale farmers grow these because they know the flavor is superior, even if the yields aren't as high as the industrial hybrids.
If you’re a gardener, don't just buy a packet of "Yellow Squash" seeds. Look for specific names like "Gentry," "Sunburst," or "Black Beauty" (for zucchini). Ordering from heirloom specialists like Baker Creek or Seed Savers Exchange will give you access to varieties that haven't been seen in commercial stores for fifty years.
Finally, remember that size is everything. In every single one of those beautiful pictures of yellow squash varieties you see online, the best-tasting ones are the small ones. A yellow squash the size of a baseball bat is a decorative object, not an ingredient. Pick them when they are six inches long or smaller. Your taste buds—and your guests—will thank you.
Keep your squash in a perforated plastic bag in the crisper drawer, but don't expect it to last more than four or five days. It’s a "live fast, die young" vegetable. Use it quickly, cook it hot, and don't be afraid of the bumps. Those bumps are where the flavor is hiding.