It started with a few deaths in late July. Nobody panicked at first because, honestly, people died of "fevers" all the time in the 18th century. But by August, the situation regarding yellow fever in Philadelphia 1793 had devolved into a full-blown nightmare. Imagine the scene: Philadelphia wasn't just any city; it was the temporary capital of the United States. George Washington lived there. Thomas Jefferson was there. Then, suddenly, the air felt heavy, the docks smelled of rotting coffee, and people started turning a ghostly shade of yellow before vomiting black blood.
It was terrifying.
The city was the most cosmopolitan hub in North America, yet it was brought to its knees by a mosquito that nobody even knew was the culprit. For months, the government basically evaporated. People who could afford to leave, like Washington, fled to the countryside. Those left behind were caught in a medical civil war between doctors who couldn't agree on how to stop the dying.
The Rotting Coffee and the First Victims
If you were walking down by the Hill’s property on Water Street in early August 1793, you would have smelled it. A cargo of damaged coffee had been dumped on the wharf and was rotting in the sweltering humidity. Dr. Benjamin Rush, perhaps the most famous physician in America at the time, was convinced this "miasma"—the foul stench—was the source of the plague. He wasn't alone in that thinking. Most people back then believed bad air caused disease.
They were wrong, of course.
The real killer arrived on ships from Saint-Domingue (modern-day Haiti). Refugees fleeing the Haitian Revolution brought the yellow fever virus with them, hitching a ride in the bodies of infected people and the water barrels of ships teeming with Aedes aegypti mosquitoes. Philadelphia was a powder keg for an outbreak. It had open sewers, stagnant pools of water, and a record-breaking heatwave.
By the middle of August, the death toll started climbing. Five a day. Ten a day. Soon, the bells of Christ Church wouldn't stop tolling for the dead until the city finally banned the ringing because it was driving the survivors insane with grief.
🔗 Read more: Why Doing Leg Lifts on a Pull Up Bar is Harder Than You Think
The Great Medical Schism: Rush vs. Everyone Else
Medicine in 1793 was, frankly, brutal. There was no germ theory. There were no antibiotics. There was just a lot of guessing.
Dr. Benjamin Rush stayed in the city when other doctors fled, which was brave. But his "cure" was often as deadly as the disease. Rush believed in aggressive depletion. He thought the body had too much tension, so he prescribed massive doses of calomel (a mercury-based laxative) and "ten-and-ten" purges. He also bled his patients. A lot. We’re talking about taking pints of blood from people whose organs were already failing.
On the other side of the fence were the "French" doctors, like Jean Devèze, who worked at the Bush Hill hospital. They looked at Rush like he was a madman. They preferred "milder" treatments: wine, lemonade, fresh air, and rest.
It’s one of the great historical ironies that the "heroic" American doctor was likely killing his patients while the "foreign" doctors were actually giving them a fighting chance. If you got yellow fever in Philadelphia 1793 and ended up under Rush’s care, your odds weren't great.
A City in Total Anarchy
By September, the social fabric just ripped apart.
Friends would cross the street to avoid each other. Parents abandoned children. The College of Physicians told people to stop shaking hands and to walk in the middle of the street to avoid "infected" houses. If you walked through the city, you’d see people clutching handkerchiefs soaked in vinegar to their noses, desperate to filter the air.
💡 You might also like: Why That Reddit Blackhead on Nose That Won’t Pop Might Not Actually Be a Blackhead
The federal government effectively ceased to exist.
Jefferson stayed as long as he could, mostly out of a sense of duty, but even he eventually packed it up. Alexander Hamilton actually caught the fever and survived, though he was treated with the "French" method of cold baths and bark (quinine), which Rush absolutely hated.
The only reason the city didn't completely burn down was the Free African Society.
Absalom Jones and Richard Allen, leaders of the Black community, stepped up when the white leadership fled. There was a prevailing (and deadly) myth at the time that Black people were immune to yellow fever. They weren't. But Jones, Allen, and their volunteers acted as nurses, carted away bodies, and kept the city's basic functions running. They were later attacked in a pamphlet by Mathew Carey, who accused them of overcharging for their services—a claim they brilliantly debunked in their own published defense. It’s one of the most heroic, yet often sidelined, chapters of the whole crisis.
How the Nightmare Finally Ended
People tried everything to stop the "contagion."
- They fired cannons in the streets, thinking the gunpowder would "clear" the air.
- They smoked constant cigars.
- They carried pieces of camphor around their necks.
- They stayed indoors and boarded up their windows.
None of it worked. The mosquitoes kept biting. The only thing that actually saved Philadelphia was the weather. In late October, a cold front moved in. A hard frost finally hit the city.
📖 Related: Egg Supplement Facts: Why Powdered Yolks Are Actually Taking Over
Almost overnight, the dying stopped.
Because the mosquitoes died, the transmission cycle broke. People didn't understand why the frost worked, they just knew the "pestilence" had vanished. By November, the streets were full again. George Washington returned. Life went back to "normal," but the city was forever changed. An estimated 5,000 people were dead—roughly 10% of the population in just a few months.
Why 1793 Still Matters for Us Today
The story of yellow fever in Philadelphia 1793 isn't just a dusty history lesson. It’s a blueprint for how societies handle sudden biological threats. We saw the same patterns during the 1918 flu and the COVID-19 pandemic: the flight of the wealthy, the disagreement over "the science," and the disproportionate burden placed on marginalized communities.
The 1793 outbreak forced the United States to realize that public health was a national security issue. It led to the creation of better quarantine laws and eventually a more permanent focus on sanitation.
If you want to dive deeper into this, you should read Bring Out Your Dead by J.H. Powell. It’s the definitive account, and it reads more like a thriller than a history book. Also, a trip to the Independence National Historical Park in Philly today hits differently when you realize you're walking over ground that was once a literal graveyard for thousands of fever victims.
Real Actions for History Buffs and Health Students
- Visit the African Episcopal Church of St. Thomas: This is where the legacy of Absalom Jones lives on. Understanding the role of the Free African Society is crucial to getting the full picture of the 1793 crisis.
- Check the National Library of Medicine archives: You can actually view digitized copies of the pamphlets written by Benjamin Rush and his rivals. Seeing the original "medical advice" from 1793 is a wild experience.
- Examine the Water Works: While built later, the Fairmount Water Works were a direct response to the city’s need for clean water and better hygiene following the repeated yellow fever outbreaks of the 1790s.
- Support Urban Public Health: The lesson of 1793 is that the health of a city depends on its infrastructure. Supporting modern initiatives for mosquito control and urban sanitation is the direct descendant of the lessons learned during that horrific summer.
The 1793 epidemic was a brutal reminder that even the most powerful cities are vulnerable. It shaped the American medical landscape and proved that in a crisis, the people who stay behind to help are often the ones the history books initially forget to mention.