It was a year that felt like a decade. If you followed the Bronx Bombers this past summer, you know exactly what I’m talking about. The Yankees team stats 2025 tell a story of massive power, a late-season collapse in the division race, and an October that ended way too soon for most fans' liking.
They finished with a 94-68 record. On paper? That's a great season. In reality? It left them tied for first with the Toronto Blue Jays but relegated to second place in the AL East due to tiebreakers. They were a juggernaut that somehow felt vulnerable every time a high-leverage reliever stepped onto the mound.
The Offensive Explosion and the Judge Factor
Let's be real: watching Aaron Judge in 2025 was basically like watching a video game character with the sliders turned all the way up. The man is 33 now, but he’s still making professional pitchers look like they’re throwing BP.
Judge put up a .331 batting average with 53 home runs and 114 RBIs. His OPS was a staggering 1.145. Honestly, he’s reaching a point where "elite" doesn't even cover it. He led the team in almost every meaningful category, and his 10.1 WAR (Wins Above Replacement) suggests that without him, this team might have been fighting for a Wild Card spot rather than the division lead.
Juan Soto’s year was a bit more of a roller coaster, though the final numbers look solid. He hit .263, which is a bit of a dip for him, but he still mashed 43 homers and drove in 105. The guy just knows how to find the seats. Between Judge and Soto, the Yankees accounted for 96 home runs from just two spots in the lineup. That is terrifying for any opposing manager.
The team as a whole slashed .251/.332/.455. They scored 849 runs, which is about 5.24 runs per game. They weren't just hitting homers, either; they actually showed some life on the basepaths with 134 stolen bases, led by Jazz Chisholm Jr., who put up a 4.2 WAR season while playing all over the diamond.
Why the Pitching Staff Felt So Different
This is where the Yankees team stats 2025 get a little messy. Gerrit Cole’s season was effectively over before it really started. He had Tommy John surgery in March, and the rotation had to be held together with duct tape and hope.
Max Fried was brought in to stabilize things, and honestly, he did a decent job, but losing an ace like Cole is a hole no one can truly fill. The team still managed to rank 4th in the league in strikeouts with 1,440. That's a lot of missed bats.
The bullpen was a different story. While they had high-strikeout arms like Camilo Doval and David Bednar in the mix, the consistency just wasn't there during the dog days of July and August. They allowed 685 runs over the course of the season.
The Heartbreak of October
The postseason was a microcosm of the entire year. They fought through the AL Wild Card Series, taking down the Boston Red Sox 2-1 in a series that probably gave half of New York a heart attack. Beating Boston is always sweet, but it took a lot out of them.
Then came the ALDS against Toronto. The Blue Jays just had their number. The Yankees lost the series 3-1, and just like that, the 94-win season was in the books.
People love to blame Aaron Boone or Brian Cashman when things go south, but when you look at the Yankees team stats 2025, the failure in the ALDS came down to the bats going cold at the worst possible time. You can't average five runs a game all summer and then disappear in October.
Surprising Depth and Statistical Oddities
One of the more interesting "under the radar" stats from 2025 was Austin Wells. The catcher hit 21 home runs. For a 25-year-old behind the plate, that’s huge. His .219 average is ugly, sure, but his power is real.
Then you have Paul Goldschmidt, who at 37 years old was still grinding out a .274 average over 146 games. He wasn't the "Goldy" of five years ago, but he provided a veteran presence in a clubhouse that occasionally looked like it was panicking during that July skid where they lost two out of three to the Mets and got swept by Toronto.
📖 Related: Fantasy Football Auction Cheat Sheet: Why Your Budget Strategy Is Probably Failing
Defensive Reliability (Or Lack Thereof)
- Team Fielding Percentage: .984 (Right in the middle of the pack)
- Total Errors: 94
- Double Plays Turned: 105
They weren't "bad" defensively, but they weren't elite. Anthony Volpe continues to be a vacuum at shortstop, but the revolving door at third base and the corner outfield spots led to some "Yankee Stadium Specials"—balls that should have been caught but somehow found the turf.
What Most People Get Wrong About 2025
A lot of fans think the 2025 season was a failure because they didn't win the World Series. Honestly, that’s a tough way to live. If you look at the Yankees team stats 2025, this was one of the most productive offensive teams in franchise history.
They hit 274 home runs as a team. That’s the second-highest mark for the franchise in the last decade. The problem wasn't talent; it was health and a lack of a true "stopper" in the rotation once Cole went down. Relying on Luis Gil and Clarke Schmidt to carry the load in a pennant race is a lot to ask, even if they both had moments of brilliance.
Actionable Insights for the 2026 Season
If you're looking at these stats to figure out what happens next, here is what the front office is likely focusing on:
- Rotation Health: Gerrit Cole’s rehab is the biggest storyline of the 2026 offseason. They cannot go another year without a true Number 1 starter.
- The Strikeout Problem: 1,463 strikeouts as a team is way too high. They need a high-contact bat in the middle of that lineup to move runners when Judge and Soto aren't hitting it over the fence.
- Bullpen Roles: Bednar and Doval are great, but the bridge to the 9th inning was shaky. Expect a few more veteran signings on low-risk, high-reward deals.
- Youth Movement: Jasson Domínguez and Spencer Jones need regular reps. The veteran stop-gaps are fine, but the ceiling of this team is tied to the kids.
The 2025 season showed us that the Yankees have the highest ceiling in baseball, but their floor is lower than we'd like to admit. 94 wins is great, but in the Bronx, it’s just another year without a ring.
Check the 40-man roster movements this week. If the Yankees don't add a contact-oriented infielder soon, we're likely to see the same "all-or-nothing" offensive output in 2026.