You know that feeling when you walk into a place and the bartender actually remembers your name? Or at least they remember that you always order the wings with the extra-hot sauce? That’s the vibe at Xtra Innings Sports Bar and Grille.
In a world full of polished, corporate-owned chains where every wall has the same mass-produced neon sign, finding a veteran-owned, family-oriented spot feels like finding a ten-dollar bill in your winter coat. Honestly, it’s refreshing. Located at 1590 Saxonburg Blvd in Tarentum, PA, this isn’t just a place to grab a beer. It’s a community hub where the "hometown crowd" actually hangs out.
People get confused sometimes. If you search for "Extra Innings," you might find baseball training facilities in Massachusetts or dive bars in Denver. But the Xtra Innings Sports Bar and Grille in the West Deer Township area has carved out a very specific niche for itself. They aren't trying to be a fancy gastro-pub with $18 cocktails. They’re a sports bar. Pure and simple.
The Food at Xtra Innings Sports Bar and Grille
Let's talk about the menu. It's comfort food, but done with a bit more heart than your average freezer-to-fryer joint.
They use local fresh meats and produce. You can tell. Their "Xtra Inning Fries" are basically a mountain—and I mean a mountain—of fries covered in cheddar and provolone, topped with bacon and served with ranch. It's the kind of thing you order for the table and then secretly eat half of yourself.
👉 See also: Why the Man Black Hair Blue Eyes Combo is So Rare (and the Genetics Behind It)
Sandwiches and Hoagies
The "Old Grammy" is their signature move. It’s a combination of steak and their famous hot sausage, topped with provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, and a kick of horseradish sauce. It’s a lot of sandwich. If you’re not feeling like a meat-coma, the Turkey Club on toasted sourdough is a solid, lighter choice.
- Super Hot Sausage Sandwich: $14.50 (Topped with grilled onions and peppers).
- Beer-Battered Fish: Hand-breaded cod that actually tastes like fish, not just breading.
- Taco Tuesdays: A local staple from 5:00 PM to 8:00 PM.
They also do this thing called a "Barnyard Chicken Wrap." It's got grilled chicken tossed in a homemade honey maple BBQ sauce, plus bacon, eggs, and sautéed onions. It sounds like a lot of flavors competing, but it weirdly works.
More Than Just the Scoreboard
One thing that sets this place apart is the game room.
Usually, sports bars are "adults only" zones where kids are tolerated but not really welcome. At Xtra Innings Sports Bar and Grille, they have a dedicated space for the kids to hang out. It lets parents actually watch the game without feeling like they’re neglecting their children or annoying the other patrons.
✨ Don't miss: Chuck E. Cheese in Boca Raton: Why This Location Still Wins Over Parents
It’s veteran-owned, which usually translates to a certain level of discipline in the service and a deep pride in the atmosphere. They have 20 rotating craft beers on tap. That’s a lot for a local spot. You’ll find the standard domestic favorites, sure, but the rotation keeps the "beer nerds" happy too.
Why Small Spots Like Xtra Innings Are Hard to Find
We’re seeing a lot of these independent bars disappear. Costs are up. Big chains have bigger marketing budgets. But what the big guys can't replicate is the "Super Bad Wrap"—a steak wrap with french fries, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and tomatoes inside. It’s a Pittsburgh-adjacent culinary tradition that feels personal.
The hours are pretty standard, but they stay open until 11:00 PM on Fridays and Saturdays. Sunday is a bit shorter, closing at 8:00 PM, which makes sense for a place that values family time.
Quick Logistics for Your Visit
If you're heading over, keep in mind they’re tucked away in Tarentum. The address is 1590 Saxonburg Blvd #400.
🔗 Read more: The Betta Fish in Vase with Plant Setup: Why Your Fish Is Probably Miserable
If you call them at (724) 768-7160, you’re likely talking to someone who actually works in the kitchen or behind the bar, not a call center. Happy hour runs Monday through Friday from 4:00 PM to 6:00 PM, where you can knock a dollar off all alcoholic beverages. It’s not a life-changing discount, but it’s a nice gesture in an economy where a pint is pushing eight bucks in the city.
Real Talk on the Atmosphere
Is it the quietest place in the world? No. It’s a sports bar. There are TVs everywhere. People are cheering for the Steelers or the Pens. It’s loud, it’s lively, and it’s local.
If you’re looking for a white-tablecloth experience, keep driving. But if you want a Reuben on marble rye with enough kraut to make your doctor worried, this is your spot. They even do stuffed banana peppers for $10 that have a legitimate bite to them.
The reality is that Xtra Innings Sports Bar and Grille represents a dying breed of "Third Places"—somewhere that isn't work and isn't home, where you can just be.
Whether you’re there for the $12 Loaded Nachos for Two (which can easily feed three) or just to hide from your responsibilities for an hour during the fourth quarter, it delivers exactly what it promises. No frills. Just good food and a cold beer.
Actionable Insights for Your Visit:
- Check the Tap List: Don't just settle for a Lite beer; ask what's new on the 20-tap rotation.
- Bring the Kids: Use the game room so you can actually catch the highlights.
- Target Tuesday: If you're on a budget, the 5-8 PM Taco Tuesday window is the best value.
- Order the Sausage: If you only try one "house" specialty, make it the hot sausage—it's what they're known for.