Online multiplayer is a miracle, sure, but it's also kinda lonely. You spend three hours grinding for loot with a "friend" who is actually just a flickering green icon and a voice that sounds like it’s coming from the bottom of a Pringles can. It’s not the same. It’ll never be the same as the chaotic, elbow-jabbing energy of sitting next to someone on a sagging sofa while you both scream at the TV.
People keep saying local multiplayer is dead. They’re wrong.
Actually, Xbox local co op games are currently having a weird, beautiful renaissance. While big AAA publishers often ditch split-screen to save on graphical processing power, indie devs and a few stubborn studios like Hazelight have doubled down. If you own an Xbox Series X, an old One S, or even just a PC with some controllers, you have access to some of the best shared-screen experiences ever made.
Honestly, the Series X's "Quick Resume" feature makes this better than it used to be. You can hop between a stressful round of Cuphead and a chill session of Stardew Valley without waiting ten minutes for things to load. It makes the "couch" part of couch co-op feel seamless.
The Games That Actually Save Friendships (Or Ruin Them)
Let’s talk about It Takes Two. It’s the obvious choice, but for a reason. Josef Fares, the director, famously offered $1,000 to anyone who got bored of it. He didn't have to pay out. The game is a mechanical chameleon. One minute you're playing a third-person shooter with sap guns, the next you're in a top-down dungeon crawler or a rhythm game. It’s built from the ground up specifically for two players. You literally cannot play it alone. That’s a bold move in an industry obsessed with "player counts" and "engagement metrics."
Then you have the Overcooked! All You Can Eat edition. This game is basically a stress test for your central nervous system. You aren't just cooking soup; you're managing a kitchen that is currently floating down a river or splitting in half during an earthquake. It’s less about gaming skill and more about communication. Or, more accurately, it’s about shouting "WHERE IS THE ONION?" at your partner while they accidentally throw a plate into a trash can. It’s brilliant.
The Indie Gems You Probably Skipped
If you want something a bit more "vibe-heavy," look at Unravel Two. It’s a physics-based platformer where you and a partner are made of yarn and literally tethered together. If one of you falls, the other has to anchor themselves. It’s a metaphor for relationships that is actually fun to play.
On the complete opposite end of the spectrum is Vampire Survivors. Most people think of this as a solo time-sink. But the local co-op update changed the game. Adding a second, third, or fourth player makes the screen a psychedelic mess of pixels and damage numbers. It’s pure dopamine. You don't even need to be "good" at games to enjoy it. You just move a stick and watch stuff explode.
Why Technical Limitations Almost Killed the Split-Screen
We need to be real about why Xbox local co op games became rarer for a while. It’s a hardware problem. Rendering a modern game twice—once for each player's perspective—is incredibly demanding.
When a game like Halo Infinite launched without its promised local campaign co-op, fans were livid. 343 Industries eventually canceled the feature to focus on "live service" updates. It felt like a betrayal of the franchise that basically built the Xbox brand on the back of split-screen 4v4 matches in Combat Evolved.
Rendering two viewports means the console has to draw twice as many polygons and handle twice the draw calls. Most modern games use "dynamic resolution scaling" to keep frame rates stable. In split-screen, that resolution often bottoms out. This is why you see games like Baldur’s Gate 3 struggling to maintain parity on the Series S—the "little console" just doesn't have the RAM to handle two players doing wildly different things in a massive open world simultaneously.
✨ Don't miss: Rarest TCG Pocket Cards: What Most People Get Wrong
But there’s a workaround. Shared-screen games (where both players are on the same fixed camera) avoid this. Titles like Diablo IV or Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder’s Revenge keep everyone on one screen, which saves the GPU from a meltdown.
The Survival and Strategy Niche
If you have a hundred hours to kill, Don't Starve Together is the way to go. It’s brutal. You will starve. A giant deer-clops will crush your base. Your friend will accidentally burn down your forest. But the sense of accomplishment when you finally survive a winter together is unmatched by any solo achievement.
For the strategy nerds, Halo Wars 2 offers a surprisingly deep co-op campaign. Controlling an army from a bird's-eye view while your buddy manages the base builds a level of tactical synergy that you just can't get in a standard shooter.
The Hardware Reality: What You Actually Need
Don't buy the cheapest controllers you find on Amazon. Seriously. Third-party controllers often have "dead zones" in the sticks that make precise platformers like Cuphead a nightmare.
- Official Xbox Wireless Controllers: They’re the gold standard for a reason. The haptic feedback is subtle, and the battery life (if you use a rechargeable pack) is solid.
- The Wireless Adapter: If you're playing on a PC via the Xbox app, don't rely on Bluetooth. Bluetooth is prone to interference when you connect more than two controllers. Get the official Windows adapter.
- Game Pass: This is the "cheat code" for local co-op. Probably 60% of the games mentioned here are on Game Pass. It’s the cheapest way to demo whether your partner actually likes Gears 5 or if they’re going to hate you for making them play it.
Addressing the "Lag" Myth in Local Play
One thing people get wrong about Xbox local co op games is the idea of "input lag." Locally, there is zero network latency. However, some 4K TVs have terrible "processing lag." If your character feels heavy or unresponsive, make sure your TV is in Game Mode. This bypasses the TV's internal image processing to give you the fastest possible response time.
In a game like Streets of Rage 4, where frame-perfect parries matter, that 50ms of TV lag is the difference between a high score and a Game Over.
Finding the Right Game for Your Partner
Not everyone wants to shoot aliens. If you’re trying to get a "non-gamer" into the hobby, start with Portal 2. It’s the perfect introductory course. It teaches you how to move in a 3D space without the pressure of being shot at. Plus, the writing is genuinely funny. GLaDOS mocking your "friendship" while you fail a puzzle is a highlight of the medium.
For families, Minecraft Dungeons is basically "Baby's First Diablo." It’s a dungeon crawler with simple mechanics but enough depth to keep adults interested. No complicated crafting, just loot and monsters.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Game Night
To make the most of your Xbox setup, start with these specific moves:
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With Metal Gear Solid Delta Launch Issues
- Audit Your Game Pass Library: Go to the "Store" or "My Games & Apps," select the filter icon, and choose "Local Co-Op" or "Shared/Split Screen." You’ll likely find you already own 5-10 titles capable of local play.
- Check "Backward Compatibility": Some of the best local experiences are from the Xbox 360 era. Left 4 Dead 2 and Castle Crashers are still top-tier. They run better on a Series X than they ever did on original hardware, thanks to Auto HDR and faster loading.
- Adjust Your Screen Settings: In split-screen mode, players often lose peripheral vision. Go into the game's settings and increase the FOV (Field of View) to at least 90. This helps reduce that "claustrophobic" feeling of having only half a screen.
- Try "Copilot" Mode: This is a hidden Xbox system feature. It allows you to link two controllers so they act as one. It’s incredible for helping a child or a less-experienced player through a difficult game. You can handle the movement while they handle the jumping/shooting.
- Invest in a Chatpad or Headset: Even in local play, if you're playing an RPG like Stardew Valley, having a way to quickly type in-game or talk to other friends online simultaneously keeps the "social" aspect alive.
The reality is that Xbox local co op games aren't a dying breed; they've just moved away from the spotlight. While the "big" games chase photorealism, the co-op scene chases memories. Grab a second controller, find a game that looks interesting, and actually talk to the person sitting next to you. It's better than a headset any day of the week.