Reality TV is a weird beast. We tune in for the "experiment" but we stay for the train wrecks. Let's be real: nobody is watching Love Is Blind just to see stable people have healthy conversations about their 401(k)s. We want the drama. We want the "I can't believe they just said that" moments. And over the years, some people have truly delivered.
Finding the worst Love is Blind contestants isn't just about who was mean. It's about the people who completely missed the point of the show, the gaslighters, and the ones who seemed to be there strictly for a blue checkmark on Instagram. From the early days of Season 1 to the absolute chaos of the 2025 and 2026 seasons, the hall of shame is getting crowded.
The Pioneers of the Villain Edit
You can't talk about villains without mentioning Shake Chatterjee from Season 2. Honestly, he’s the gold standard for how to make an entire audience hate you. He spent his time in the pods asking women if they were light enough for him to carry on his shoulders. Classy, right? Then he spent the rest of the season telling everyone—including his fiancé Deepti’s family—that he wasn't physically attracted to her. Watching Deepti choose herself at the altar was a top-tier moment, mostly because Shake tried to turn his own wedding rejection into a "party" vibes celebration. It was cringey. It was shallow. It was Shake.
Then there’s Jessica Batten from Season 1. People used to think she was the worst because of the whole "baby voice" and giving her dog wine. Looking back in 2026, she’s actually had a massive redemption arc. But at the time? The way she pined for Barnett while stringing Mark along made her public enemy number one. She’s proof that you can outlive a bad edit, but man, those pod episodes were rough.
Why Do We Love to Hate Them?
It's a visceral thing. You're sitting on your couch, maybe eating some popcorn, and you see someone like Bartise Bowden (Season 3) tell his fiancé Nancy that another girl on the show is a "smoke show." It’s the lack of self-awareness that gets us. Bartise had this way of being incredibly confident while saying the most hurtful things possible. He wasn't just a villain; he was a masterclass in how to tank a relationship in record time.
Recent Chaos: The 2025 and 2026 Seasons
If you thought the early seasons were messy, the recent batches have been wild. In Season 9 (Denver), we met Edmund. He started off looking like the "nice guy," but that mask slipped fast. His "nice guy" rants when things didn't go his way were actually pretty scary to watch. He’d start an argument and then flip it to make Kalybriah look like the aggressor. It’s that kind of manipulation that makes fans rank him among the worst.
✨ Don't miss: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
And we have to talk about Joe from that same season. This guy called his own fiancé "that" in a confessional. He openly talked about how he doesn't usually date "bigger" girls and made Madison cry more times than we can count.
- Jeramey Lutinski (Season 6): Stayed out until 5 a.m. with another contestant (Sarah Anne) while engaged to Laura. Then he had the audacity to say he didn't do anything wrong because he "apologized."
- Irina Solomonova (Season 4): Laughed at women crying in the pods. She basically treated the whole thing like a mean-girl competition from high school.
- Sam Klein (LIB UK): "Beggars can't be choosers." Enough said. He was so obsessed with his own reflection he forgot there was another person involved.
The "I'm Just Here for Clout" Crew
Lately, it feels like half the cast is just trying to launch a fitness app or a podcast. Leo from Season 7 is a prime example. The guy couldn't go five minutes without mentioning his Rolex or the fact that he's an art dealer. It felt performative. When he lashed out at Hannah, it became clear he wasn't there for "the experiment." He was there for the screen time.
The Hall of Shame: A Prose Breakdown
The list of questionable behavior is long. You've got Shaina Hurley from Season 2, who accepted a proposal from Kyle just to stay in the mix, even though she was clearly still hung up on Shayne. She tried to use "religious differences" as an excuse, but nobody was buying it. It was obvious she just wasn't into him.
Then there's Zanab Jaffrey and the infamous "Cuties" scene. That was a turning point for the show's fandom. Zanab accused Cole of body shaming her over some oranges, but when the footage actually aired, it looked... well, it looked like a normal conversation. It sparked a massive debate about gaslighting and how much we can trust what we see on screen. Cole wasn't perfect—he was immature and said some dumb stuff—but the way Zanab systematically dismantled him at the altar felt like a bridge too far for many viewers.
Jackelina Bonds (Season 4) also deserves a mention. The way she treated Marshall was brutal. She basically told him to "man up" and then skipped a wedding dress fitting to hang out with another guy from the pods, Josh. It was messy, it was public, and it was widely considered some of the worst behavior the show has ever seen.
🔗 Read more: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
Is it the Producers or the People?
We have to acknowledge the "edit." Reality TV producers are experts at taking 100 hours of footage and turning someone into a monster. Jessica Batten has talked openly about how she wanted to leave Season 1 but was pressured to stay. However, an edit can't make you say "I'm not attracted to you" to your fiancé’s face or mock someone's insecurities.
The worst Love is Blind contestants usually share a few traits:
- Total lack of empathy.
- Using the "experiment" as a platform for fame.
- Refusal to take accountability at the reunions.
That last one is key. If a contestant shows up to the reunion and says, "Yeah, I watched it back and I was a jerk, I'm sorry," the fans usually forgive them. But when someone like Shake or Bartise doubles down? That’s when they cement their legacy as a villain.
What We Can Learn From the Mess
It’s easy to judge from the couch. But these shows are a pressure cooker. You’re sleep-deprived, there’s free-flowing alcohol, and you’re being filmed 24/7. Still, most people manage not to be "the worst."
If you're watching these seasons back, look for the red flags that the contestants missed. The "love bombing" in the pods usually leads to a crash in the real world. The people who talk most about being "good guys" (looking at you, Sam and Edmund) are usually the ones to watch out for.
💡 You might also like: Is Lincoln Lawyer Coming Back? Mickey Haller's Next Move Explained
What’s Next for the Franchise?
As we move through 2026, the casting seems to be getting even more "intentional"—which is code for "we're looking for people who will cause a scene." The UK and Swedish versions of the show have brought some much-needed genuine romance back to the brand, but the US version remains the king of the "villain" era.
If you're looking for a deep dive into who actually stayed together versus who just wanted the followers, checking out the "After the Altar" specials is your best bet. Some of these villains, like Irina, have gone quiet. Others, like Jessica, are now thriving with families and actual careers outside of the Netflix bubble.
To stay updated on the latest casting disasters, keep an eye on the official Netflix social accounts and the ever-active Reddit threads. The community is usually faster at digging up a contestant's "secret" boyfriend or shady past than the producers are.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Watch the Season 9 reunion to see if Joe or Edmund actually take any accountability (unlikely, but we can hope).
- Follow the Season 10 casting calls to see if the show is finally moving toward a more "genuine" vibe or leaning harder into the drama.
- Compare the "villain edits" of the US version with the international spin-offs to see how cultural differences affect what we consider "the worst" behavior.