It wasn't the massive battleships with their 15-inch guns that terrified the British Admiralty in 1917. It was a fleet of oily, cramped, and noisy steel tubes hiding under the Atlantic waves. World War 1 German submarines, or U-boats, basically rewrote the rules of naval engagement. They weren't just "boats." They were the first true implementation of asymmetric warfare on a global scale.
Imagine being a merchant sailor in 1916. You’re hauling grain or shells across the "Western Approaches" to England. The sea is gray and choppy. Suddenly, a white streak of bubbles appears. Seconds later, your ship is breaking in half. No warning. No chance to fight back. This was the reality of the Unterseeboot.
Germany started the war with only 28 operational U-boats. It’s a tiny number when you think about the Royal Navy’s massive surface fleet. But by 1917, these things were sinking hundreds of thousands of tons of shipping every single month. At one point, the UK was down to just six weeks of food supplies. It was that close. Honestly, the U-boat was the most effective tech-disruptor of the 20th century.
The Engineering Behind World War 1 German Submarines
Most people think of these as "submarines," but they were actually submersible torpedo boats. They spent about 90% of their time on the surface. They had to. The diesel engines needed air to breathe and to charge the massive lead-acid batteries. When they submerged, they switched to electric motors.
The early U-1 class was primitive, but by the time the U-139 class (the "U-cruisers") hit the water, they were massive. These later models were over 300 feet long. They carried 15-centimeter deck guns and could stay at sea for months. They even had two hulls. An inner "pressure hull" kept the crew from being crushed, while an outer hull held the fuel tanks.
Living inside was a nightmare.
You’ve got 35 to 40 men crammed into a space the size of a small school bus. It smelled like a mix of diesel fumes, unwashed bodies, rotting food, and battery acid. There were no showers. There was one toilet, and it often couldn't be used when submerged because the external pressure was too high. If the crew tried to flush it at depth, the sea would literally blow back into the boat. This actually happened on some boats, leading to "biological" disasters inside the hull.
The Torpedo Problem
The G6 torpedo was the primary weapon of World War 1 German submarines. It was a marvel of engineering for 1914, but it was incredibly finicky. It used a wet-heater engine—basically a miniature steam engine—to spin propellers.
📖 Related: Why the Metal Storm Gun Never Actually Changed Warfare
But here’s the thing: they left a visible wake of bubbles.
If a lookout saw that wake early enough, a ship could turn and dodge. That’s why many U-boat commanders preferred to surface and use their deck guns. It was cheaper, more reliable, and frankly, more terrifying for the merchant crews. Why waste a 10,000-mark torpedo on a small wooden schooner when a few 88mm shells would do the trick?
Cruel Reality: Prize Rules vs. Unrestricted Warfare
At the start of the war, German captains actually followed "Prize Rules." This meant they would surface, stop a merchant ship, let the crew get into lifeboats, and then sink the ship. It was almost gentlemanly. Sorta.
But then the British started using "Q-ships." These were merchant vessels with hidden cannons. When a U-boat surfaced to give warning, the Q-ship would drop its fake sides and blast the submarine to bits. It was a dirty trick, and it worked.
Because of this, Germany pivoted to unrestricted submarine warfare.
This was the turning point. In February 1917, the Kaiser’s navy declared that any ship—neutral or not—found in the war zone would be sunk without warning. This is what eventually dragged the United States into the war. The sinking of the Lusitania in 1915 had already poisoned public opinion, even though it happened before the "unrestricted" policy was fully official.
Why the U-boat Campaign Failed
It wasn't because the technology was bad. It was because of the convoy system.
The British were stubborn. They didn't want to group ships together because they thought it would make one big target. But Admiral Sims of the U.S. Navy and several British officers pushed for convoys. They realized that the ocean is massive. A lone ship is easy to find if you're patrolling a lane, but a hundred ships huddled together is actually harder to find.
Once the Allies started using destroyers with "hydrophones" (early sonar) and depth charges to protect these convoys, the World War 1 German submarines started dying in droves.
The math changed. In 1917, a U-boat might sink 10 ships for every boat lost. By late 1918, they were lucky to get one or two before being hunted down by a destroyer's depth charges. The psychological toll on German crews was immense. Out of roughly 17,000 men who served in the U-boat force, over 5,000 never came home. That's a 30% mortality rate. Worse than the trenches.
Famous Aces and Infamous Boats
You can't talk about these boats without mentioning Lothar von Arnauld de la Perière. He was the "Ace of Aces." Most people think of the Red Baron in the air, but von Arnauld was the maritime equivalent. He sank 194 ships.
🔗 Read more: Why a huge wave of zombies is approaching font Is Taking Over Digital Design
Interestingly, he didn't use many torpedoes. He was a master with the deck gun. He would surface, fire a warning shot, and then methodically dismantle the ship. He was known for being relatively "humane" in a war that was rapidly losing its humanity.
On the flip side, you had boats like the U-20, which sank the Lusitania. That single act arguably changed the course of world history more than any infantry charge at the Somme.
The Technological Legacy
When the war ended in 1918, the Allies were shocked by what they found in German pens. The Germans were working on the Type U-142, a massive "submarine cruiser" that could cross the Atlantic and back without refueling.
The British and Americans took these captured boats, took them apart, and basically copied the blueprints. The modern US Navy's submarine fleet in the 1930s owed a massive debt to the tech found in World War 1 German submarines. Things like the "saddle tank" design and the specific diesel-electric configurations became industry standards.
The Myth of the "Invulnerable" U-boat
A big misconception is that U-boats were silent hunters. They weren't.
They were loud. If they were on the surface, you could hear the thrum of the diesels for miles. If they were submerged, their electric motors hummed. They were also blind. Once they went under, the commander only had the periscope. If the seas were rough, he couldn't see a thing.
If a destroyer started "patterning" an area with depth charges, the crew inside a U-boat just had to sit there and wait. They called it "the iron coffin." Every time a charge went off, the lightbulbs would shatter, the rivets would pop, and water would start spraying from a dozen different leaks. You couldn't fight back. You just prayed the hull held.
Actionable Insights for History Buffs and Researchers
If you're looking to really understand the impact of World War 1 German submarines, don't just read dry statistics. You have to look at the primary sources.
- Visit the U-534: While it's a WWII boat (located in Birkenhead, UK), it gives you the best physical sense of the cramped conditions that evolved directly from the WWI designs.
- Study the "Handels-U-Boot": Look up the Deutschland. It was a merchant submarine designed to bypass the British blockade to trade with the US. It’s a fascinating example of how Germany tried to use sub-tech for commerce, not just killing.
- Check the Logbooks: The National Archives (UK) and the German Federal Archives (Bundesarchiv) have digitized many U-boat war diaries (Kriegstagebücher). Reading a captain's handwritten notes about a sinking is a haunting experience.
- Analyze the Tonnage: If you're a data person, look at the "Tonnage War" charts from April 1917. That month was the peak of the U-boat threat, and the numbers are staggering—nearly 880,000 tons sunk in 30 days.
The U-boat wasn't just a weapon; it was a shift in the human psyche. It ended the era where the ocean was a safe "highway" and turned it into a permanent front line. The tech has changed—we have nuclear power and ballistic missiles now—but the basic concept of the "silent hunter" started right here in the muddy waters of the North Sea in 1914.
To truly grasp the naval history of the 20th century, you have to start with these steel cylinders. They were the first machines to prove that a small, invisible force could bring a global empire to its knees. They didn't win the war, but they changed how every war since has been fought.
🔗 Read more: Congruent Meaning: Why Getting the Definition Right Matters in Geometry and Beyond
If you're researching this for a project or just out of interest, your next move should be to map the sinking locations off the coast of Ireland. The sheer density of wrecks there tells a story that words can't quite capture. Check out the "Integrated Mapping for the Sustainable Development of Ireland's Marine Resource" (INFOMAR) project; they have incredible sonar imagery of these WWI wrecks resting on the seabed today.
---