If you’ve ever watched Witney Carson glide across the Dancing with the Stars ballroom, you know she’s a force. She’s sharp, fast, and basically a human firework. But while she’s in the spotlight with NFL stars or actors, there’s one guy who has been her steady anchor for over a decade. Honestly, the story of the witney dancing with the stars husband, Carson McAllister, is kinda like a real-life Hallmark movie, minus the cheesy script and with a lot more actual work.
They aren’t just some "Hollywood couple" that met at a red carpet event. No, these two go way back to the days of lockers and homework in American Fork, Utah.
Who is Carson McAllister?
Most people just know him as the guy cheering from the front row or the handsome face on Witney’s Instagram. But Carson McAllister isn’t in show business. Not even close.
He’s actually a mechanical engineer.
While Witney was winning Mirrorball trophies and getting Emmy nominations, Carson was hitting the books. He graduated from Utah Valley University in 2022 after six years of "rigorous work," as Witney put it. It’s pretty rare to see a high-profile dancer married to someone in such a grounded, technical field. It seems to work for them, though. He brings the logic; she brings the rhythm.
The High School Sweetheart Story
Carson has admitted—and this is actually sweet—that Witney was his dream girl since the 7th grade. Talk about playing the long game. She didn't really notice he existed until their senior year.
Once they finally started dating in 2011, it wasn't exactly a straight line to the altar. They had to deal with some serious distance early on. Carson went on a two-year mission to Romania for the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. At the exact same time, Witney’s career was exploding on So You Think You Can Dance.
👉 See also: Martha Stewart Young Modeling: What Most People Get Wrong
Think about that for a second.
You’re 18 or 19. Your boyfriend is in Eastern Europe with limited contact, and you’re becoming a household name on national TV. Most teenage romances would have imploded.
When he finally came back, things were... awkward. Their first date back was at a grocery store. Witney has shared that it felt like they knew each other, but everything had changed. It took a family trip to Cancun for them to realize the spark was still there.
The New Year’s Wedding and a Decade of Marriage
They didn’t waste much time after that. They got engaged on a beach in 2015 and tied the knot on New Year’s Day, 2016.
It was a big Salt Lake City wedding. Lots of DWTS royalty were there, like Lindsay Arnold and Emma Slater. Since then, they’ve navigated the weird world of fame while keeping their private life relatively low-key.
Just this month, on January 1, 2026, the couple celebrated their 10th wedding anniversary.
✨ Don't miss: Ethan Slater and Frankie Grande: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Ten years in "fame years" is basically a lifetime.
Raising a Family in the Spotlight
If you follow Witney, you know her "mini-McAllisters." They have two sons:
- Kevin "Leo" McAllister (born 2021)
- Jet McAllister (born 2023)
Leo was named after Carson’s father, who sadly passed away from pancreatic cancer in 2018. It was a brutal time for the family, and Witney has often credited Carson’s strength for getting them through it.
The couple recently moved their entire life from Utah to Florida. It was a huge shift. They wanted a change of pace, but it also meant Witney had to juggle her DWTS career with a cross-country move. In late 2025, during Season 34, there was even some speculation that she might retire to spend more time with the boys, especially after she posted some emotional videos about how hard it is to leave them for rehearsals.
What People Get Wrong
There’s a lot of gossip whenever a pro dancer has a "sexy" routine with a celebrity partner. People love to "ship" Witney with her partners—most recently Robert Irwin in Season 34.
But honestly? Carson seems totally unfazed.
🔗 Read more: Leonardo DiCaprio Met Gala: What Really Happened with His Secret Debut
He’s often seen hanging out with her partners and their families. He’s the guy holding the diaper bag backstage while she’s in sequins. That kind of security is probably why they’ve lasted a decade while other celebrity marriages crumble after two years.
Why Their Relationship Still Matters to Fans
In a world of messy breakups and "situationships," people look at the witney dancing with the stars husband and see something stable. It’s a reminder that you can have the big career and the quiet, normal home life.
Carson doesn't try to be famous. He doesn't seem to want the spotlight for himself. He’s just... there.
If you're looking to build a relationship that lasts as long as theirs, there are a few takeaways. They prioritize communication during long distances. They respect each other's very different career paths. Most importantly, they seem to actually like each other.
Keep an eye on Witney’s social media for updates on their Florida life or if she decides to return for Season 35. For now, they seem to be focusing on their kids and Carson’s engineering career, proving that the best partnerships happen when the music stops.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Check out Witney's "CAPRI" fitness line or her jewelry collaborations if you want to support her business ventures outside of dance.
- If you're following her move to Florida, her YouTube vlogs give a much more "unfiltered" look at her and Carson's daily life than the TV show ever does.
- Watch for any announcements regarding Season 35 of DWTS later this year to see if she'll be balancing the ballroom with mom life once again.