Novigrad is a dump. Honestly, between the smell of rotting fish and the constant threat of Eternal Fire zealots burning someone alive, it’s a miracle Geralt doesn't just turn Roach around and head back to Kaer Morhen. But tucked away in the shadows of the Bits, you run into a quest that defines why CD Projekt Red’s writing is so legendary. It’s the "An Elusive Thief" contract. People always ask about the Witcher 3 doppler story comedy or drama balance, and the truth is, it’s both. And neither.
It starts like any other job. A merchant is complaining about a "thief" stealing his wares. You track some prints. You find some spilled flour. Standard Witcher stuff. Then you realize you're chasing a Doppler.
The Identity Crisis in the Bits
Dopplers are weird. In the lore, they aren't malevolent monsters. They’re mimics. They take the shape of others not just to kill them, but to survive. They literally become the person, right down to their memories and soul. This is where the drama hits hard. When Geralt finally corners the Doppler—who has been posing as a temple guard—you aren't looking at a snarling beast. You’re looking at a terrified individual trying to find a place in a city that wants to purify him in a bonfire.
The drama is baked into the setting. Novigrad in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is undergoing a literal ethnic cleansing. Non-humans and mages are being rounded up. For a Doppler, who has no "true" face of his own, the act of hiding is an act of survival. If you choose to kill him, it feels wrong. It feels like you're doing the Hierarch’s dirty work for a few crowns.
But then, there's the comedy.
Why the Doppler Fight is Pure Slapstick
You can't talk about the Witcher 3 doppler story comedy or drama without mentioning the actual boss fight. It is one of the funniest moments in the game because the Doppler, in a fit of panic, transforms into Geralt.
✨ Don't miss: All Might Crystals Echoes of Wisdom: Why This Quest Item Is Driving Zelda Fans Wild
Suddenly, you’re fighting yourself.
It’s absurd. Two white-haired, scarred mutants swinging silver swords at each other in a muddy alley. The Doppler even uses Signs. He'll Quen up right as you're trying to Igni him. It’s a meta-commentary on how ridiculous Geralt looks to regular people. The Doppler isn't a trained swordsman; he's a mimic playing a role. The clashing of two identical "Geralts" is peak gaming comedy, especially when you realize the Doppler is basically just "Button-mashing" Geralt’s moveset to stay alive.
Moral Complexity or Just a Bad Day?
Most players end up letting the Doppler go. Why? Because Geralt’s own code—the real one, not the made-up "Witcher's Code" he uses to get out of awkward conversations—says he doesn't kill sentient monsters that don't pose a threat.
The Doppler, named Tell, just wanted to buy food.
If you let him go, he gives you some loot and a bit of coin. If you kill him, you get the Doppler Mutagen. This is the ultimate "meta" drama for players. That mutagen is one of the rarest items in the game. You literally cannot craft the Doppler Decoction without it. So, the game forces a choice: are you a roleplayer who cares about the narrative weight of a persecuted minority, or are you a completionist who wants every potion in the book?
🔗 Read more: The Combat Hatchet Helldivers 2 Dilemma: Is It Actually Better Than the G-50?
That’s a cruel joke from the developers.
Comparisons to "Skellige's Most Wanted"
To see how the Witcher 3 doppler story comedy or drama evolved, you have to look at the DLC quest "Skellige's Most Wanted." Here, a Doppler teams up with a Godling, a Werewolf, and an Ice Troll to put Geralt on trial for his "crimes" against monster-kind.
This leans way harder into the drama. The Doppler in this quest is bitter. He remembers friends Geralt has killed. It challenges the player’s history. Did you kill the Doppler in Novigrad? If you did, this guy knows. The comedy disappears here, replaced by a tense standoff where your past choices actually determine if you have to slaughter an entire committee of monsters.
What Most Players Miss
People forget that Dopplers aren't just shape-shifters; they are emotional sponges.
When Tell becomes Geralt, he feels Geralt’s exhaustion. He feels the weight of the swords. This isn't just a "monster of the week" encounter. It’s a mirror. CD Projekt Red uses the Doppler to show us Geralt’s own humanity. If the Doppler can be Geralt and show mercy, can Geralt be a "monster" and do the same?
💡 You might also like: What Can You Get From Fishing Minecraft: Why It Is More Than Just Cod
The humor comes from the situation—the "I’m looking at the man in the mirror" tropes—but the drama is the anchor. Without the threat of the Witch Hunters, the quest would just be a funny chase. With them, it's a commentary on urban hate.
The Verdict on the Tonal Shift
If you're looking for a straight answer on whether this is a comedy or a drama, you’re playing the wrong game. The Witcher 3 thrives in the "Grey Area."
- The Comedy: The fight. The confusion of the merchant. The sheer audacity of a monster hiding as a religious guard.
- The Drama: The Doppler Mutagen dilemma. The persecution of non-humans. Tell’s genuine fear.
- The Gameplay: Tracking mechanics that lead to a surprising payoff.
Honestly, the Doppler quests are the best example of why the game holds up years later. They don't treat the player like an idiot. They give you a funny boss fight and then immediately punch you in the gut with a moral choice that has no "right" answer.
How to Handle the Doppler Quest for the Best Experience
If you're currently running through Novigrad, don't rush "An Elusive Thief."
- Listen to the dialogue: Tell actually explains his motivations if you don't just mash the "attack" button.
- Check your Bestiary: The entry updates based on your choice, and it's written by Dandelion. His take on the Witcher 3 doppler story comedy or drama is usually more insightful (and biased) than anything else in the game.
- Think about your build: If you aren't an alchemy-focused player, you don't need that mutagen. Let the guy go. The reward for being "good" is a unique pair of boots and a clear conscience, which is rare in the Continent.
- Look for the aftermath: In later chapters, your reputation for how you treat "monsters" in Novigrad can subtly change how certain NPCs react to you in the streets.
The real "drama" isn't in the cutscene; it's in the realization that in Geralt’s world, the monsters are often the ones trying the hardest to be human.