Everyone thinks they know how to spot a winner. They look at the speed figures, they check the pedigree, and they wait for that one horse to win a major prep race by five lengths. But honestly? That’s usually where the trouble starts. The Road to the Kentucky Derby isn't actually about finding the fastest horse in February or March. It’s a survival gauntlet designed to weed out the brilliant but fragile athletes in favor of the ones who can actually handle a mile and a quarter in front of 150,000 screaming fans.
Most people treat the leaderboard like a simple ranking. It’s not. It’s a point-based qualifying system that Churchill Downs implemented back in 2013 to replace the old graded stakes earnings rule. Before that, you could get into the Derby by winning a bunch of sprint races as a two-year-old. Now, you have to prove you can compete at classic distances. If you don't have the points, you don't get the rose-colored saddle cloth. Simple as that.
The Points Trap and the Early Season Hype
If you're tracking the Road to the Kentucky Derby in the early winter, you’re looking at races like the Gun Runner at Fair Grounds or the Jerome at Aqueduct. These races offer 10 points to the winner. In the grand scheme of things, 10 points is almost nothing. You usually need around 40 to safely "get into the gate."
This creates a weird dynamic. Trainers like Bob Baffert (when he’s eligible), Todd Pletcher, and Brad Cox aren't trying to have their horses peaking in January. If a horse wins the Holy Bull at Gulfstream Park by double-digit lengths, the betting public goes nuts. They hammer the horse’s price in the Kentucky Derby Future Wager. But seasoned horsemen know that an early peak often leads to a late-April burnout. You've seen it happen dozens of times. A horse looks like a superstar in February, then finishes 12th on the first Saturday in May because they "hit the wall" physically.
The real movement happens during the 100-point races. The Florida Derby, the Arkansas Derby, the Blue Grass Stakes, and the Santa Anita Derby. These are the "Win and You're In" equivalent for the Bluegrass State.
💡 You might also like: El Salvador partido de hoy: Why La Selecta is at a Critical Turning Point
Why the Prep Circuit is Changing
We used to see horses take a very traditional path. Three or four starts as a three-year-old before the Derby was the gold standard. Not anymore. Now, trainers are increasingly conservative. They want "fresh" horses. Look at Mage in 2023. He didn't even race as a two-year-old. That was unheard of a decade ago. He followed a very condensed Road to the Kentucky Derby path, finishing second in the Florida Derby before winning the big one.
This shift means you have to look at "internal fractions" rather than just final times. A horse might finish third in a prep race but be closing faster than anyone else in the field. That horse is actually more dangerous in the Derby than the winner who got a "lone lead" and walked on the front end. In a 20-horse Derby field, nobody gets an easy lead. It's a cavalry charge. If a horse hasn't faced "dirt in their face"—which basically means getting kicked with mud while stuck behind other horses—they usually fold when the real pressure hits at Churchill Downs.
The International Wildcards
You can't talk about the modern Road to the Kentucky Derby without mentioning the Japan Road and the European Road. For a long time, these were mostly ignored by American bettors. That was a massive mistake. Japanese racing has exploded on the global stage.
- The Japan Road: This is a separate points leaderboard. Horses compete in races like the Cattleya Stakes and the Hyacinth.
- The European Road: This focuses more on synthetic and turf surfaces, which doesn't always translate to the dirt at Churchill.
- The UAE Derby: This is the "wildcard" race in Dubai. It offers a massive 100 points to the winner.
The problem with the UAE Derby winners is the travel. Shipping from Dubai to Kentucky is a brutal haul. For years, the "UAE Derby bounce" was a real thing—horses would win big in the desert and then finish dead last in Kentucky. But then came Forever Young in 2024, who proved that the gap is closing. You have to respect the international shippers now. They aren't just here for the party anymore.
📖 Related: Meaning of Grand Slam: Why We Use It for Tennis, Baseball, and Breakfast
Understanding the "Figure" vs. The "Trip"
If you're looking at Beyer Speed Figures, you're only seeing half the story of the Road to the Kentucky Derby. A horse can run a 105 Beyer on a "speed-favoring" track where the dirt is packed hard and fast. That same horse might struggle on a "deep" track like Churchill Downs.
Churchill's surface is unique. It's sandy, it's grueling, and it rewards stamina over pure, raw sprinting speed. When you're watching the prep races, pay attention to the tracks. Oaklawn Park (Arkansas Derby) is often gritty and plays fair. Gulfstream (Florida Derby) is usually very fast and favors horses who are close to the lead. If a horse wins at Gulfstream, you have to ask yourself: Did they win because they are a superstar, or did they win because the track layout made it impossible for anyone to catch them?
I’ve spent years watching these "trips." A "bad trip" is the best thing a handicapper can find. If a horse gets blocked, checked, or forced to run six-wide (meaning they ran way more distance than the winner), their finishing position doesn't reflect their talent. That’s where the value is. The Road to the Kentucky Derby is littered with horses who "lost" their prep races but "won" the physical battle.
Pedigree: The Silent Killer
Distance is the ultimate equalizer. Every horse can run six furlongs. Most can run a mile. Very few can run 1.25 miles. This is where pedigree nerds like me get excited.
👉 See also: NFL Week 5 2025 Point Spreads: What Most People Get Wrong
You’ll see horses on the Road to the Kentucky Derby that are sired by "sprint" stallions—think Into Mischief or Munnings. These stallions are incredible, but their offspring often have a "stamina ceiling." When the race hits that 1 1/8 mile mark (9 furlongs) in the final preps, watch for the horses who are shortening their strides. They are literally running out of oxygen. On the flip side, if you see a horse sired by Tapit, Curlin, or Quality Road, they are built for the long haul. They might look "slow" early on, but they'll keep that same grinding pace forever. In the Derby, "grinders" win more often than "burners."
The Psychology of the Trainer
Don't ignore the humans. Some trainers are "Derby specialists." Todd Pletcher will often enter four or five horses. He likes to have a massive "army" on the leaderboard. Bill Mott is more patient; if his horse isn't 100% right, he’ll pull them off the trail entirely.
Then there’s the "Derby Fever" factor. Owners want to be there. Sometimes they push a trainer to run a horse that clearly isn't ready or doesn't belong. This is why you see 80-1 longshots like Rich Strike winning. He didn't even have enough points to get in until another horse scratched at the last minute. The Road to the Kentucky Derby is as much about luck and timing as it is about talent.
Actionable Strategy for Following the Trail
Don't just watch the highlights. If you want to actually understand how the Derby will play out, you need a process.
- Watch the Gallop-Out: After the finish line of a prep race, don't stop watching. See which horse passes the winner 200 yards after the wire. That’s the horse with the most "gallop-out" energy, suggesting they want more distance.
- Ignore the "Bling": Don't get distracted by fancy colors or famous owners. Focus on the "fractions." A race that goes fast early and slow late is usually a weak race. A race that finishes fast (the "final fraction") is a sign of true quality.
- Track the Workouts: Once a horse has their points, the morning workouts at Churchill Downs in the week leading up to the race are everything. Some horses hate the Churchill surface. If they are "propping" (refusing to go) or sweating profusely, they are a "toss" regardless of how many prep races they won.
- The "Third-Start Off the Layoff" Rule: Look for horses who are making their third start of the year on Derby Day. The first start is for fitness, the second is for points, and the third is for the win. It’s a classic conditioning pattern that still works.
The Road to the Kentucky Derby is a puzzle with twenty moving pieces. Most people try to solve it by looking at the box score. But the real answers are in the mud, the pedigree, and the way a horse carries itself when the jockey stops asking for speed. Stop betting on the winners of the prep races and start betting on the horses who were just getting started when the prep races ended.
Go back and watch the replays of the Risen Star or the Wood Memorial. Don't look at the horse in first place. Look at the horse in fourth who was stuck in traffic and finishing like a freight train. That’s your Derby winner. That’s how you actually beat the closing odds.