If you walk through Manhattan today, you are stepping on his ghost. Literally. Every time you pass a nondescript apartment building in the East Village or a storefront near Astor Place, you're likely looking at a piece of the map once owned by William Backhouse Astor Sr. But here is the weird thing. Everyone knows his father, John Jacob Astor, the guy who started the whole "American Dream" thing with fur trading and opium. And everyone knows his daughter-in-law, "The" Mrs. Astor, who basically decided who was cool enough to be in New York society.
William? He was the middleman. The bridge. The guy who took a massive fortune and, through sheer, obsessive bookkeeping and a refusal to sell a single square inch of dirt, turned it into an empire that made the original look like pocket change.
He was the "Landlord of New York." And honestly, he was kinda terrifyingly good at it.
Who Was William Backhouse Astor Sr Anyway?
Born in 1792, William wasn't exactly the "self-made" type. He didn't have to be. He was sent off to the University of Göttingen in Germany, which was a big deal back then. Imagine being a twenty-something American in the early 1800s, living in Europe, and having your father tell you to "study hard" because you’re going to run a global monopoly one day. No pressure, right?
When he came back, he didn't just lounge around. He became a partner in his father’s export business. He was the quiet one. The worker. His older brother, John Jacob Astor Jr., suffered from mental health issues, which meant the weight of the family legacy fell squarely on William’s shoulders.
In 1848, his father died. William inherited the bulk of the estate.
Suddenly, he was the richest man in the United States.
✨ Don't miss: Jerry Jones 19.2 Billion Net Worth: Why Everyone is Getting the Math Wrong
We aren't talking "rich for the time" rich. We are talking about an estate worth roughly $20 million in 1848. If you adjust that for the scale of the economy today, it's a number that makes Silicon Valley tech bros look modest.
The Strategy: Don’t Sell, Just Build
While other rich guys were betting on risky railroads or gold mines, William Backhouse Astor Sr. had a very simple, very boring, and very lucrative strategy.
He bought land.
Specifically, he focused on the area below Central Park, between 4th and 7th Avenues. Back then, this wasn't the heart of the city—it was the outskirts. He’d buy up lots, wait for the city to grow toward them, and then build. By 1867, he reportedly owned 720 houses.
Think about that for a second. In a city where space is everything, one guy owned over seven hundred buildings.
The Slumlord Accusations
It wasn't all glitz and glamour, though. William wasn't exactly known for being a "charitable" landlord in the modern sense. He was often criticized for the state of his rental properties. People called him a slumlord.
🔗 Read more: Missouri Paycheck Tax Calculator: What Most People Get Wrong
The Astors had a specific way of doing business: they would lease the land to a sub-landlord. That person would then build whatever they wanted—usually cheap, cramped housing—and collect the rent. William got his cut regardless of how many people were squeezed into a room.
Later in life, he did try to renovate some of the older buildings. Maybe it was guilt. Maybe it was just good business to make sure the buildings didn't fall over. Either way, the "Landlord of New York" title was earned through a mix of visionary urban planning and some pretty grim living conditions for the city's poorest.
The Astor Library and the $550,000 Gift
If you want to see his most tangible legacy, go to the Public Theater in the East Village. That building used to be the Astor Library.
His father had left $400,000 in his will to start a public library, but it was William Backhouse Astor Sr. who actually made it happen. He didn't just write a check and walk away. He oversaw the construction. He donated another $150,000 during his lifetime and left even more in his will.
Total investment? About $550,000.
In the 1850s, that was a staggering amount of money for a library. It was the first truly great public library in New York, even if it was a bit "serious." You couldn't just walk in and take a book home—it was for reference only. You had to be a "serious person" to use it. Eventually, this collection became one of the foundational pillars of the New York Public Library system we know today.
💡 You might also like: Why Amazon Stock is Down Today: What Most People Get Wrong
A Family of Feuds and Fortune
William’s life wasn't just ledgers and brick-laying. He married Margaret Alida Rebecca Armstrong, who was from a "real" New York aristocratic family. This was the moment the Astors stopped being "new money" upstarts and became the establishment.
They had seven kids. Two of them, John Jacob III and William Jr., would eventually split the fortune and start one of the most famous family feuds in American history.
Basically, the two brothers (and their wives) spent the next few decades trying to out-mansion each other. One would build a house; the other would build a bigger one next door. This rivalry eventually led to the construction of the original Waldorf-Astoria Hotel.
William Sr. probably would have hated that. He was a man of "unoccupied land" and "houses." Putting a giant hotel on top of perfectly good real estate just to spite a family member? Not his style.
Why Does This Matter Today?
When William Backhouse Astor Sr. died in 1875, his estate was worth nearly $50 million.
He had more than doubled his father's fortune. He didn't do it by being a genius inventor or a charismatic leader. He did it by understanding one fundamental truth: New York City was going to get bigger, and people were always going to need a place to sleep.
Actionable Insights from the "Landlord of New York"
- Long-term Holding Beats Short-term Flipping: William almost never sold land. He held it for decades. If you’re looking at investments, the "Astor Method" is basically: buy quality, wait for the world to catch up, and never panic-sell.
- Diversification Within a Niche: While he was 90% real estate, he also had heavy interests in coal, railroads, and insurance. He knew his core business, but he made sure he was protected if the housing market dipped.
- Legacy is Built, Not Inherited: He inherited millions, but he is remembered for the Library and the 700+ houses he built. If you want to be remembered, you have to add something to what you were given.
To really understand New York's DNA, you have to look at the people who literally built the streets. William Backhouse Astor Sr. wasn't the loudest Astor, but he was arguably the most important one for the city's physical growth.
If you're interested in how this wealth trickled down (or didn't), your next step should be researching the "Four Hundred" list. It’s the direct social result of the money William spent his life accumulating, and it explains why New York society looks the way it does even today.