If you’ve been scouring the internet lately trying to figure out will there be a season 2 of Poker Face, you aren't alone. It’s been a wild ride for fans of Charlie Cale and her human lie-detector routine. Honestly, for a while there, things looked a bit dicey with the Hollywood strikes and everyone’s busy schedules, but we finally have some concrete answers.
Yes. It happened.
In fact, Poker Face Season 2 officially premiered on May 8, 2025.
If you missed the memo, Peacock dropped the first three episodes all at once, and it was glorious. Rian Johnson and Natasha Lyonne didn't just bring the show back; they cranked the volume up. Instead of the 10 episodes we got in the first season, they gave us 12. Two extra helpings of Charlie squinting at people and muttering "bullshit" under her breath.
What Really Happened with the Poker Face Season 2 Release
The wait was kind of brutal. Season 1 wrapped up way back in March 2023. Because of the massive industry strikes and Rian Johnson being knee-deep in his third Knives Out movie (Wake Up Dead Man), the production timeline got pushed way further than anyone expected.
But when it finally landed in May 2025, it hit hard.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
The structure stayed mostly the same—that classic Columbo style where we see the murder first and then watch Charlie figure it out—but the stakes changed. If you remember the Season 1 finale, Charlie was basically a marked woman. Beatrix Hasp (voiced by the legendary Rhea Perlman) was hunting her down. Season 2 starts with that pressure cooker turned all the way up.
The Guest Stars are Absolute Bananas
Part of the magic of this show is seeing who pops up in the "victim" or "killer" slots. Season 2 basically raided the contact lists of every major casting director in Hollywood. We’re talking about:
- Cynthia Erivo (who basically played six different sisters in a single episode).
- John Mulaney as an FBI agent who isn't exactly what he seems.
- Giancarlo Esposito and Katie Holmes playing a funeral home power couple.
- Awkwafina, John Cho, and Melanie Lynskey also making appearances.
There was even a weirdly hilarious episode involving Kumail Nanjiani as a Florida cop with a pet alligator. It’s that specific brand of "weird America" that only this show really captures.
Where Does Charlie Cale Go From Here?
So, you’ve watched the episodes, or you're planning to, and you're wondering about the vibe shift. About three episodes into the second season, the show pulls a major fast one. Without spoiling too much, the whole "running from the mob" thing gets flipped on its head.
Charlie becomes a free agent in a way she wasn't before.
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Natasha Lyonne actually talked about this in a few interviews, mentioning how they wanted to move away from the "fugitive" trope and just let Charlie be a wanderer who stumbles into trouble because she's fundamentally a good person who can't stand a lie. It makes the show feel less like a continuous chase and more like an anthology of strange lives.
The Big Twist: Is There a Season 3?
Here is where things get a little complicated. In November 2025, Peacock actually announced they weren't moving forward with a third season.
I know. It sucks.
But don't toss your Barracuda keys just yet. Rian Johnson hasn't given up on the world of Poker Face. There have been massive reports from places like Deadline and The Hollywood Reporter that Johnson is shopping the show to other networks.
The kicker? There’s a rumor that if the show moves, it might look very different. Natasha Lyonne has mentioned she needs a break to direct her own films, and there’s talk of Peter Dinklage potentially taking over the lead role in a sort of soft reboot. It sounds crazy, but in Rian Johnson's world, crazy usually works.
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
Why the Show Still Matters
In a world of gritty reboots and "prestige" dramas that take themselves way too seriously, Poker Face is just fun. It’s smart, it’s beautifully shot—using that 70s film grain look—and it respects the audience's intelligence.
Whether it stays on Peacock or finds a new home at Netflix or Apple TV+, the "mystery-of-the-week" format is officially back in style because of this show.
What You Should Do Now
If you haven't finished the second season yet, get on it. It’s 12 episodes of pure television comfort food.
- Check Peacock: All 12 episodes of Season 2 are currently streaming.
- Watch Episode 3 Closely: It’s the one with John Mulaney, and it completely changes the trajectory of the series.
- Keep an eye on T-Street: That’s Rian Johnson’s production company. Any news about the show moving to a new network will likely break there first.
- Rewatch the "Theater" Episode from Season 1: If you need a reminder of why this show is top-tier, that’s the one to revisit while waiting for news on the "Dinklage" era.
The journey of Charlie Cale might be on a pit stop right now, but with the way Season 2 ended, there’s clearly more "bullshit" left to sniff out.