Adam Brody and Kristen Bell basically broke the internet—or at least the "romantic comedy is dead" discourse—when they showed up as a rabbi and a podcaster falling in love. It felt like 2003 all over again, but with better therapy and sharper jokes. The chemistry was so undeniable that the moment the credits rolled on that season finale at the airport, everyone had the exact same thought: will there be a season 2 of Nobody Wants This? The short answer? Yes.
Netflix didn't wait long. Usually, the "streaming giants" play it cool, waiting months to look at data while fans suffer in limbo. Not this time. They saw the TikTok edits. They saw the "hot rabbi" discourse. They officially greenlit a second season just a few weeks after the premiere. It’s happening. But there are some massive changes happening behind the scenes that might actually change how the show feels when it returns to our screens.
Why the renewal happened faster than a first date
Streaming success is usually a math problem. Netflix looks at how many people finish a show in the first 28 days. For this show, the numbers were kind of staggering. It didn't just debut well; it stayed at the top of the global charts. People weren't just watching it; they were obsessed with the specific, messy dynamic between Joanne and Noah.
Erin Foster, the creator, based the show on her own life. That authenticity—the cringe-worthy family dinners, the genuine religious tension, the "shiksa" drama—hit a nerve. It wasn’t a sanitized sitcom. It felt like real people making bad decisions for good reasons. When a show hits that specific "cozy but sharp" vibe, a renewal is basically a formality.
The new bosses in the writers room
Here is where things get interesting. Erin Foster is still the heart of the show, but for season 2, Netflix is bringing in some heavy hitters. Jenni Konner and Bruce Eric Kaplan are joining as executive producers and showrunners. If those names sound familiar, it’s because they were the brains behind HBO's Girls.
That tells us a lot about the direction of the next batch of episodes. Girls was famous for being unapologetically messy and diving deep into the uncomfortable parts of relationships. Bringing them on suggests that season 2 isn't going to be a simple, "happily ever after" stroll. It's going to get complicated. Joanne and Noah survived the "will they, won't they" phase. Now they have to survive the "how do we actually make this work without ruining our lives" phase.
🔗 Read more: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
What we know about the plot after that finale
That finale cliffhanger was a lot. Noah chooses Joanne over the "safe" path of his career and family expectations. He walks away from the chance to be the head rabbi of his dreams just to stand by her in a parking lot. It was romantic, sure, but also incredibly stressful.
In season 2, the honeymoon phase is officially over.
We have to deal with the fallout of Noah’s choice. His family isn't just going to say "oh, okay" and move on. Bina (played by the incredible Tovah Feldshuh) is still there, and she’s not exactly Joanne’s biggest fan. The tension between Joanne’s secular, "oversharing" lifestyle and Noah’s deeply traditional community is going to be the main engine for the drama. Honestly, it’s about time a show explored that without making one side the villain.
Will Joanne actually convert?
This is the million-dollar question. In season 1, Joanne realized she couldn't just do it for him. It had to be for her. If the show stays true to its realistic roots, we won't see a magical transformation where she suddenly becomes the perfect rabbi’s wife. We’re likely going to see her struggle with the identity shift.
Can you be a raunchy podcaster and still respect the boundaries of a religious community? Can Noah be a leader if his partner doesn't fit the mold? That’s where the real story is. The "Loser Siblings"—Morgan and Sasha—are also set to return, and their weird, platonic-but-obsessive bond is probably going to get even weirder. Sasha’s marriage is on shaky ground, and Morgan is... well, Morgan. She’s the chaos element the show needs.
💡 You might also like: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
The timeline: When is it coming back?
Production schedules for Netflix are notorious. Even though the renewal was fast, filming takes time. Writing a script that lives up to the hype of the first season is a massive undertaking.
- Writing Phase: Started in late 2024.
- Filming: Expected to kick off in early-to-mid 2025.
- Release Window: Most likely early 2026.
I know, waiting sucks. But rom-coms live and die by the writing. If they rush it, we get a flat second season that ruins the magic. If they take their time with Konner and Kaplan, we get something that stays in the cultural zeitgeist for years.
Why this show matters for the genre
For a long time, the industry thought people only wanted "high-concept" shows—dragons, superheroes, or serial killers. Nobody Wants This proved that people just want to see two charming adults talk to each other. It’s a throwback to the Nora Ephron era but updated for a world where we’re all a little more cynical.
The chemistry between Adam Brody and Kristen Bell is the "secret sauce." You can't manufacture that. It’s either there or it isn’t. Because they’ve been friends in real life for years, there’s a comfort level that allows them to play those intimate scenes without it feeling forced.
Dealing with the "Hot Rabbi" phenomenon
One of the funniest hurdles for season 2 is how the show handles its own viral success. Adam Brody became the internet’s crush overnight (again). The writers have a choice: do they lean into the "fantasy" version of Noah, or do they make him more human and flawed?
📖 Related: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
The best move is flaws. A perfect character is a boring character. We need to see Noah mess up. We need to see him be selfish or stubborn. That’s what makes the payoff worth it.
The "Must-Watch" list while you wait
Since we're looking at a bit of a gap before new episodes drop, you've gotta fill the void. If you loved the vibe of Nobody Wants This, there are a few shows that hit that same sweet spot of "smart people being idiots in love."
- Starstruck (Max): A New Zealand woman living in London has a one-night stand, only to realize the guy is a massive movie star. It’s witty, short, and incredibly charming.
- Lovesick (Netflix): Formerly known by a much worse title, this British show is a brilliant look at a guy who has to contact all his exes. It’s got that same "messy friend group" energy.
- Fleabag (Prime Video): If you liked the religious tension and the "forbidden love" aspect, this is the gold standard. The Hot Priest paved the way for the Hot Rabbi.
- Catastrophe (Prime Video): For those who liked the sharper, more cynical edge of Joanne and Morgan’s humor. It’s about two people who get pregnant after a brief fling and try to make a life together.
Moving forward with season 2
As we wait for more concrete teasers and trailer drops, the best thing to do is keep an eye on the cast's social media. Kristen Bell and Erin Foster often share behind-the-scenes snippets once production actually starts.
The biggest takeaway is that the show is in safe hands. By bringing in the Girls alumni, Netflix is signaling that they want this to be more than just a "comfort show." They want it to have teeth. They want it to be a show that people are still talking about three years from now.
Expect more awkward dinners. Expect more "the funk." Expect Noah to continue wearing those sweaters that seem to make everyone lose their minds. But most importantly, expect a story that doesn't take the easy way out. Love is hard, religion is complicated, and family is usually a nightmare. That’s the core of the show, and that’s why we’re all coming back for more.
Actionable Next Steps:
Keep your Netflix subscription active if you're holding out for the release, but more importantly, follow Erin Foster on Instagram. She’s the primary source for the "real" stories that inspire the episodes. If you’re feeling the "post-show blues," re-watch the first season but pay attention to the background characters—Sasha and Morgan’s subplot is actually much more layered than it seems on the first watch and will likely be the "B-plot" anchor for the upcoming season. Stay tuned for the official production start announcement, which usually triggers the first wave of "first look" photos.