It was the blue skin. Honestly, that first teaser trailer for the 2019 live-action Aladdin remake felt like a fever dream that the internet couldn't wake up from. When the world finally saw Will Smith as the Aladdin Genie, the reaction wasn't just skeptical—it was borderline hostile. People were posting memes comparing him to a blue Shrek or a terrifying Smurf. You remember that, right? The collective "yikes" heard 'round the world.
But then the movie actually came out.
Something weird happened. The movie made over $1 billion at the global box office. People who went into the theater expecting a train wreck walked out humming "Prince Ali" and admitting, perhaps a bit sheepishly, that Smith was actually the best part of the whole thing. It turns out that following in the footsteps of a legend like Robin Williams isn't about copying him; it’s about surviving the comparison.
The Impossible Ghost of Robin Williams
You can't talk about the Aladdin Genie and Will Smith without talking about the 1992 original. Robin Williams didn't just voice a character; he redefined what animation could be. He was a tornado of improv, celebrity impressions, and manic energy that Disney basically had to animate around because they couldn't keep up with him.
For nearly thirty years, the Genie was Robin Williams.
Guy Ritchie, the director of the 2019 remake, knew this. Smith knew this too. In fact, Smith initially turned the role down. He told Entertainment Weekly that he was "terrified" of the project because there wasn't much room to improve on perfection. If he tried to do Williams' version, he’d fail. If he did something too different, he’d alienate the fans. It was a classic "damned if you do, damned if you don't" situation.
💡 You might also like: Why This Is How We Roll FGL Is Still The Song That Defines Modern Country
Smith eventually found his "in" by looking at his own history. He realized he could lean into his 1990s Fresh Prince of Bel-Air persona. He decided to make the Genie a hip-hop flavored, swagger-heavy mentor rather than a shape-shifting vaudevillian. It was a calculated risk. By grounding the character in a "Big Willie Style" aesthetic, he stopped trying to be a ghost and started being a person—well, a cosmic entity with an attitude.
That Blue CGI Debacle
Let’s be real for a second: the visual effects in those early promos were rough. The "uncanny valley" effect happens when something looks almost human but not quite, and a muscular, glowing blue Will Smith hit every single alarm bell in our brains.
The issue wasn't the acting; it was the rendering.
In the final film, the CGI was polished significantly, but the real secret weapon was the "Human Genie" form. For a huge chunk of the movie, Smith isn't blue at all. He’s just Will Smith in elaborate silks, playing a high-energy wingman to Mena Massoud’s Aladdin. This gave the audience a chance to connect with his facial expressions without the distraction of digital pixels.
Interestingly, the production used a mix of motion capture and live-action performance. For the musical numbers like "Friend Like Me," Smith performed on a massive soundstage, and the blue "Genie-form" was layered over his movements later. This allowed his natural charisma to bleed through the digital mask. When you watch the 2019 version today, the blue skin feels less like a distraction and more like a costume.
📖 Related: The Real Story Behind I Can Do Bad All by Myself: From Stage to Screen
Reimagining the Soundtrack
The music was another hurdle. You can't have Aladdin without Alan Menken’s iconic score. But how do you make those songs work for a guy who is primarily a rapper and a pop star, not a Broadway belter?
- Friend Like Me: In the 1992 version, this is a Broadway showstopper. In the 2019 version, it’s a big-band hip-hop fusion. It has beatboxing. It has a tempo that fits Smith’s flow. It felt authentic to who he is as an artist.
- Prince Ali: This one was more traditional, but Smith added a layer of comedic "hype man" energy that felt fresh.
- The Credits: Remember the end-credits version of "Friend Like Me" featuring DJ Khaled? It was divisive, sure, but it cemented the idea that this was a version of Aladdin for a new generation.
The 2019 soundtrack didn't try to replace the 1992 one. It acted as a companion piece. By the time the movie hits its stride, you aren't comparing Smith to Williams anymore; you're just enjoying the spectacle.
The Box Office Reality Check
Critics were lukewarm. The movie sits at a "Rotten" or "Mediocre" score on several review sites. But the audience? The audience loved it.
The film's billion-dollar success proved that the "Disney Remake" formula has a massive global appetite, even if the internet screams about trailers. It also proved that Will Smith remains one of the few true movie stars left who can carry a massive franchise on his back through sheer force of personality.
We see this often in modern cinema. There is a massive disconnect between "online discourse" and "the general public." While Twitter (now X) was busy making fun of the Genie’s top-knot, families were buying tickets in droves. They didn't want a carbon copy of the 1992 film; they wanted a colorful, fun, musical blockbuster. That’s exactly what they got.
👉 See also: Love Island UK Who Is Still Together: The Reality of Romance After the Villa
What Most People Get Wrong About the Performance
The most common misconception is that Smith was "just playing himself."
While he definitely brought his trademark charm, there’s a lot of subtle character work happening, especially in his relationship with Taneem (played by Nasim Pedrad). The 2019 film gave the Genie a romantic subplot, something the original never had. This humanized him. He wasn't just a plot device to grant wishes; he was a guy who wanted a life of his own.
Smith’s Genie is actually quite vulnerable. You see it in the scenes where he talks about the limitations of his power. He’s trapped. He’s lonely. That’s a layer that Smith brought to the table that felt very different from the frantic, guarded energy of the 1992 version.
Key Takeaways from the Smith Era Genie
If you're looking back at this cinematic moment, there are a few things that stand out as genuine lessons in how to handle a "sacred" role.
- Don't Imitate, Innovate: Smith didn't do impressions. He did his own thing.
- Embrace the Backlash: The production team didn't panic when the first trailer bombed. They kept working on the VFX and leaned into the marketing.
- Chemistry Matters: The bond between Smith and Mena Massoud felt real. Without that chemistry, the Genie is just a loud special effect.
The Aladdin Genie Will Smith era will probably be remembered as the moment we realized that live-action remakes can actually stand on their own two feet, even if they have a rocky start. It’s a testament to the fact that a performance can overcome bad lighting and questionable CGI if the heart is in the right place.
Practical Steps for Re-evaluating the Film
If you haven't seen the movie since the 2019 theater run, or if you skipped it because of the memes, here is how to actually enjoy it:
- Watch the 1992 version first: Get the nostalgia out of your system.
- Focus on the "Human" Scenes: Pay attention to Smith’s comedic timing when he’s not blue. It’s classic Will Smith.
- Listen to the Lyrics: Notice the small tweaks in the songs that modernize the story without breaking the magic.
- Check out the Behind-the-Scenes: Seeing the motion-capture suits Smith had to wear makes his performance even more impressive.
The Genie is out of the lamp, and honestly? He’s doing just fine.