The rocking chairs are still there. The peg games are still on the tables. But behind the scenes, things at Cracker Barrel Old Country Store are, frankly, a bit of a mess. Everyone is asking the same question: will Cracker Barrel fire their CEO Julie Felss Masino? It’s the kind of drama you usually see in a Silicon Valley boardroom, not a place known for chicken n' dumplings and hashbrown casserole.
Wall Street is notoriously impatient. When Masino took the reins from Sandra Cochran in late 2023, investors were hoping for a quick spark. Instead, they got a "strategic transformation plan" that sounded more like a survival manual than a victory lap. The stock price has taken a beating. Some days it feels like the floor is dropping out. But is a firing actually imminent, or is this just the growing pains of a brand trying to figure out how to exist in 2026?
Honestly, the situation is complicated.
Why People Think a Change is Coming
You can't ignore the numbers. Since Masino took over, the company has faced a brutal reality: younger people aren't coming in, and the regulars are getting older. Cracker Barrel’s core demographic is aging out. To fix this, Masino announced a massive $700 million investment plan. That is a staggering amount of money for a company with a shrinking market cap.
The market's reaction? It was basically a collective "yikes."
When a CEO tells investors that they need to spend hundreds of millions to fix "relevancy issues" and that dividends might be cut to pay for it, people get twitchy. The stock dropped nearly 20% in a single day following those announcements in May 2024. That is the kind of blood in the water that makes boards of directors start looking at resumes. If the question of will Cracker Barrel fire their CEO comes down to pure stock performance, the outlook isn't great.
But it isn't just about the ticker symbol. It's about the soul of the place.
The Masino Strategy: Brave or Reckless?
Masino isn't some corporate newbie. She came from Taco Bell. She knows how to modernize a brand. Her plan involves three main pillars: refining the brand, optimizing the menu, and evolving the store and digital experience.
It sounds corporate, right? Basically, she wants to make the menu easier for the kitchen to cook, the stores cheaper to run, and the food more appealing to people who don't remember the Eisenhower administration.
- They've tested "lifestyle" bowls.
- They are leaning into the "Beehive" loyalty program.
- They're renovating older stores to feel less... dusty.
Here is the problem. Cracker Barrel is a nostalgia brand. If you change the lighting or the menu too much, you risk alienating the people who actually show up every Sunday. It’s a tightrope walk. If Masino falls, she’s gone. If she stays, she might just save the company.
The board of directors is currently in a "wait and see" mode. They hired her specifically to be a disruptor. Firing a CEO less than three years into a total brand overhaul is usually a sign of total institutional failure. Boards hate admitting they made a mistake that quickly. So, for now, she likely has a leash—but it’s getting shorter with every quarterly earnings call that misses expectations.
The Activist Investor Shadow
We have to talk about Sardar Biglari. If you follow restaurant stocks, you know that name. He’s the guy behind Steak 'n Shake, and he has been a thorn in Cracker Barrel’s side for over a decade. He owns a significant chunk of the company and has tried multiple times to get seats on the board.
Biglari has been vocal about his distaste for the current direction. He thinks the company is wasting money. When an activist investor is breathing down your neck, the question of will Cracker Barrel fire their CEO becomes a political one. If Biglari gains more leverage or if other major institutional holders start siding with him, Masino’s seat will get very hot, very fast.
He wants the company to focus on returning cash to shareholders, not spending $700 million on "remodeling." It's a classic battle: short-term dividends versus long-term survival.
Real Talk: The Customer Experience
Have you been to a Cracker Barrel lately?
Depending on which one you visit, it's either a well-oiled machine or a chaotic scene of long wait times and understaffed dining rooms. This is Masino’s real battle. You can have the best digital app in the world, but if the biscuits are cold and the server is overwhelmed, the brand dies.
Labour costs are skyrocketing. Food costs are volatile. Masino is trying to simplify the menu to help the "back of house" staff. By cutting down on the number of items, they reduce waste and speed up ticket times. It makes sense on paper. But for the regular who has ordered the same trout dinner for 20 years, a menu "optimization" feels like a betrayal.
The Likelihood of a Mid-2026 Exit
If we look at the trajectory, the "danger zone" for Masino is likely late 2026.
Usually, transformation plans take 18 to 24 months to show real, undeniable results in "same-store sales." We are right in the thick of that window. If the holiday season of 2025 didn't show a significant bump in foot traffic and the spring of 2026 stays flat, the board may feel forced to act.
No CEO is safe when the trajectory is a diagonal line pointing down. However, firing her right now would be chaotic. It would signal to the market that the $700 million plan was a mistake. That would send the stock even lower.
What This Means for You (The Actionable Part)
Whether you’re an investor or just someone who loves the gift shop, the stability of the CEO matters. Here is how to read the tea leaves over the next few months:
Watch the Dividend
If the company cuts the dividend again or fails to reinstate it to previous levels, it’s a sign that the "transformation" is sucking up more cash than expected. That’s bad news for Masino.
✨ Don't miss: Is there a bank holiday today? What you actually need to know about bank closures
Look at the Store Remodels
If you see your local Cracker Barrel getting a facelift, pay attention to the vibe. Is it still "Old Country Store," or is it trying too hard to be a Panera? Customer reception to these physical changes will dictate the CEO's future.
Track the "Same-Store Sales"
This is the only metric that truly matters in the restaurant world. If more people aren't walking through the doors compared to last year, the strategy isn't working. Period.
The "Employee Sentiment" Factor
Check sites like Glassdoor or even Reddit threads for employees. If the staff is miserable because of the new "optimized" systems, the service will suffer, and the CEO will eventually take the fall.
The question will Cracker Barrel fire their CEO doesn't have a "yes" or "no" answer today. It has a "not yet." Masino is currently the captain of a ship that is taking on water, but she’s also the one with the only bucket. The board is letting her bail for now. But if the water level keeps rising, they’ll look for a new captain before the whole thing sinks.
Keep an eye on the quarterly reports. In the world of corporate retail, you're only as good as your last three months of sales. If the biscuits don't start selling faster, the rocking chairs might be the only thing left moving at headquarters.
To stay ahead of this, investors should specifically monitor the "Traffic" metric in quarterly filings rather than just "Revenue," as price hikes can often mask a dwindling customer base. If traffic continues to slide more than 3% year-over-year by the end of Q3 2026, a leadership change becomes a statistical probability.