It was 47 yards. That’s it. In the modern NFL, a 47-yard field goal is basically a layup for guys like Justin Tucker or Harrison Butker. But on January 27, 1991, at Tampa Stadium, those 41 paces felt like a mile. Scott Norwood stepped onto the grass, the weight of Western New York on his shoulders, and pushed the ball just a few inches to the right of the upright.
Wide right. The Buffalo Bills lost Super Bowl XXV to the New York Giants 20-19. It wasn't just a missed kick. It was the birth of a psychological scar that has defined a franchise, a city, and a fan base for over three decades. Honestly, if you grew up in Buffalo, "Wide Right" isn't just a sports highlight; it’s a generational trauma passed down like a family heirloom.
The Physics of a Heartbreak
People forget how good Scott Norwood actually was before that kick. He was a Pro Bowler in 1988. He was the guy who helped get them there. But the grass at Tampa Stadium was slick, the pressure was suffocating, and Norwood was a straight-on kicker in an era where soccer-style kickers were taking over the league.
💡 You might also like: NFL Contract Year Players 2026: Why This Class Could Break the Bank
He didn't "choke" in the way people like to say on Twitter. He just missed. The ball stayed straight when it needed to draw.
The Buffalo Bills were the offensive juggernaut of the early 90s. Led by Jim Kelly, Thurman Thomas, and Andre Reed, the "K-Gun" no-huddle offense was supposed to revolutionize football. And it did. But that night, Bill Belichick—then the Giants' defensive coordinator—concocted a masterpiece. He let Thurman Thomas run for 135 yards but refused to let Kelly beat them through the air. He dared the Bills to be patient.
They weren't. They ran out of time.
Why the Wide Right Buffalo Bills Narrative Re-Emerged in 2024
Fast forward 33 years. January 21, 2024. Highmark Stadium is shaking. The Bills are facing the Kansas City Chiefs in the Divisional Round. It’s Josh Allen vs. Patrick Mahomes—the defining rivalry of this era. With 1:47 left on the clock, Tyler Bass steps up for a 44-yard field goal to tie the game.
The kick starts off looking okay. Then it peels. It drifts.
Wide right.
The silence in that stadium was deafening because every single person in a blue and red jersey knew exactly what they were seeing. It was a glitch in the matrix. A cruel, repetitive joke played by the football gods. This wasn't just a missed kick; it was the wide right Buffalo Bills curse manifesting for a new generation.
Bass sat on the bench with his head in his hands. He eventually deactivated his social media because of the vitriol. It sucks. It’s sports at its most brutal. But the comparison to Norwood was instantaneous and unavoidable.
✨ Don't miss: NFL Pick Em Week 13: Why Everyone Is Overthinking These Matchups
The Statistical Reality of the Miss
- 1991 (Norwood): 47 yards, grass surface, Super Bowl.
- 2024 (Bass): 44 yards, turf, Divisional Round.
The 2024 miss felt worse in some ways because the Bills had the better team on paper. They had the home-field advantage. They had Josh Allen playing like a god. And yet, the result was a carbon copy of the trauma that started in 1991.
Belichick’s Blueprint and the One-Point Margin
You can't talk about the original miss without talking about the Giants' game plan. They held the ball for 40 minutes and 33 seconds. That’s insane. The Bills' high-powered offense was stuck on the sidelines watching the clock bleed out.
Jeff Hostetler, a backup quarterback who stepped in for an injured Phil Simms, managed the game perfectly. The Giants' strategy was basically "keep-away." They knew they couldn't outscore the Bills in a shootout, so they turned the game into a slog.
When the Bills finally got the ball back for that final drive, they were frantic. Kelly scrambled. They got into field goal range. But 47 yards on grass back then was a much lower-percentage play than it is today. Norwood’s career long was 49 yards. He was at the absolute limit of his range.
The Psychological Weight of the "Four-Falls"
The wide right Buffalo Bills tag exists because that game kicked off a streak of four consecutive Super Bowl losses. 1991, 1992, 1993, 1994. No other team has ever done that. It’s a feat of incredible excellence and incredible failure all at once.
To get to four straight Super Bowls, you have to be the best team in the AFC for nearly half a decade. You have to have Hall of Fame talent at every level. The Bills did. Bruce Smith was a wrecking ball on defense. Marv Levy was a coaching genius.
But that first miss—the Norwood miss—seemed to set a ceiling on what the franchise was allowed to achieve. By the time they got to the fourth Super Bowl against the Cowboys, the "Bills find a way to lose" narrative was so heavy it felt like they were playing with lead weights in their shoes.
Lessons for Modern Kickers and Fans
If you're a kicker in Buffalo, you aren't just competing against the opposing team. You’re competing against the wind coming off Lake Erie and the ghosts of 1991.
The Buffalo weather is a nightmare for specialists. Swirling winds, lake-effect snow, and freezing temperatures make Highmark Stadium one of the hardest places to kick in the world. This is why the 2024 miss by Tyler Bass was so devastating. He’s a good kicker. He’s been reliable. But in the biggest moment, the environment and the history seemed to converge.
How to Move Past the Curse
- Stop Blaming the Kickers: Scott Norwood didn't lose that game alone. The defense couldn't get off the field. The offense didn't score enough touchdowns. Same for Tyler Bass. If the Bills’ defense stops Mahomes on the previous drive, the kick doesn't even matter.
- Focus on the Process, Not the Result: In 1991, the Bills followed their process, but the Giants disrupted the rhythm. In 2024, the process was sound, but the execution failed under extreme pressure.
- Acknowledge the Pain: Bills Mafia is famous for its loyalty. They jump through tables. They brave sub-zero temperatures. They deserve a win. Part of moving forward is acknowledging that "Wide Right" is part of the identity, but it doesn't have to be the destiny.
The Legacy of Scott Norwood
Here’s the thing people get wrong about Norwood: the city of Buffalo actually embraced him. When the team returned home after the Super Bowl loss, thousands of fans gathered at City Hall. They didn't boo. They chanted "SCOTT, SCOTT, SCOTT."
It was a beautiful moment of humanity in a sport that is often devoid of it. Norwood stayed in Buffalo for one more year before retiring. He’s a quiet guy. He doesn't do many interviews. He’s lived a private life, forever linked to a ball that moved two inches too far to the right.
✨ Don't miss: Why Checking the Score Tigers Game Today Feels Different This Season
The wide right Buffalo Bills story isn't just about losing. It’s about the resilience of a city that keeps showing up, year after year, hoping that one day, the ball finally sails through the center of the uprights.
To truly understand this franchise, you have to look at those misses not as failures, but as the foundation of a fan base that refuses to quit. Whether it’s 1991 or 2024, the story remains the same: the Buffalo Bills are always right there. They are always on the edge of greatness. And eventually, the math says the luck has to turn.
Actionable Insights for Bills Fans and Analysts:
- Audit the Special Teams Strategy: The Bills should continue investing in kickers with high-altitude or wind-resistant leg strength.
- Shift the Narrative: Focus on the "13 Seconds" game or the 2024 Divisional Round as tactical failures rather than supernatural curses.
- Support Mental Health for Athletes: The intense scrutiny on kickers like Tyler Bass highlights the need for robust mental performance coaching in professional sports to handle "legacy-defining" pressure.
The next time a Bills kicker lines up for a game-winner, don't look away. The history is heavy, but the only way to break a curse is to keep kicking until the ghosts get tired of watching.