The Dallas Cowboys are currently standing at a weird crossroads. It’s January 2026, and the dust is still settling on a 7–9–1 season that felt like a fever dream. If you’ve been watching the wide receiver Dallas Cowboys room lately, you know it’s no longer just the CeeDee Lamb show. Things got complicated the moment Jerry Jones decided to ship off draft capital for George Pickens.
Honestly, the trade was a shocker. Bringing in a personality as big as Pickens to play alongside a target monster like Lamb was always going to be a boom-or-bust move. Now that we’re looking at the 2026 offseason, that gamble is the only thing anyone in Frisco is talking about.
The CeeDee Lamb Reality Check
CeeDee Lamb is still the undisputed king of this offense, but 2025 was a bit of a grind for him. He finished with 75 receptions for 1,077 yards and only three touchdowns. For a guy who caught 135 balls just two years ago, that feels like a massive step back. But you’ve got to look at the context. The Cowboys' offense under Brian Schottenheimer changed. With Dak Prescott spreading the ball around more—and struggling behind a rebuilding line—Lamb wasn't the "safety valve" he used to be.
He’s still elite. Nobody is doubting that. But the days of him being the only viable threat are over. That’s actually a good thing for his longevity, even if your fantasy team hated it last year.
The George Pickens Factor: WR1 or WR2?
When Dallas traded a 2026 third-rounder and a 2027 fifth-rounder for George Pickens, they weren't just looking for a "number two." They were looking for an Alpha. And Pickens delivered, honestly. He earned a second-team All-Pro nod in 2025 and made some of the most ridiculous sideline catches we've seen in a Cowboys uniform since Dez Bryant.
But here’s the kicker: he’s a free agent.
📖 Related: OKC Thunder vs Kings: Why This Matchup Is Simpler Than People Think
The front office is now staring down the barrel of a massive decision. Do they use the franchise tag on Pickens to keep the duo together? Or do they let him walk because the cap is already squeezed by Dak’s contract and CeeDee’s massive deal? There are whispers that they might even tag running back Javonte Williams instead, which would leave a "George Pickens-sized hole" in the roster. Losing him would set this passing game back years.
The Rise of Ryan Flournoy
While everyone was focused on the stars, Ryan Flournoy quietly became the most important "find" of the 2025 season. Most people ignored him when he was drafted in the sixth round out of Southeast Missouri State in '24.
He basically pushed Jalen Tolbert out of the rotation. Flournoy has that "it" factor—he’s physical, he blocks, and he caught the balls he was supposed to catch. He finished the year as a legitimate WR3. If Pickens leaves, Flournoy might be asked to start. Is he ready? Maybe. But going from a small-school project to a starter for the Dallas Cowboys is a huge leap.
What Happened to the Rest of the Room?
The depth chart looks a lot different than it did eighteen months ago. Brandin Cooks is gone (he’s in Buffalo now). Jalen Tolbert is likely headed for free agency after his numbers fell off a cliff. Then there’s Jonathan Mingo. Dallas traded a fourth-round pick for him in 2024, and so far, it’s looked like a bust. He’s still on the roster, but he’s fighting for his life to stay active on game days.
- KaVontae Turpin: Still the lightning bolt. He got a 3-year, $18 million extension and a second-team All-Pro nod as a returner. He’s the one guy whose role is safe because he does things nobody else can.
- Jalen Brooks: Mostly a special teams ace at this point.
- Traeshon Holden: Just signed a reserve/future contract. He was a fan favorite in camp but hasn't cracked the main rotation yet.
The 2026 Offseason Game Plan
The Cowboys didn't draft a single wide receiver in 2025. Not one. That was a huge mistake that Jerry Jones basically admitted to during the post-draft pressers. They thought they could "get by" with their young guys, and it forced them into the Pickens trade out of desperation.
They can't make that mistake again. Whether they keep Pickens or not, this room needs a speedster who can take the top off a defense. Names like Jauan Jennings or Rashid Shaheed are already floating around the rumor mill as potential free-agent targets.
Actionable Insights for the 2026 Roster
If you’re tracking the wide receiver Dallas Cowboys situation, here is what actually needs to happen to fix this offense before training camp:
- Resolve the Pickens Tag: If Dallas doesn't tag George Pickens by the March deadline, expect them to be aggressive in the first round of the draft for a receiver like Tetairoa McMillan or Luther Burden III.
- Formalize Flournoy's Role: The team needs to decide if Ryan Flournoy is a starter or a high-end backup. His development dictates how much they have to spend in free agency.
- Cut the Dead Weight: It's time to move on from the Mingo experiment. The roster spot is more valuable for a rookie with actual upside.
- Find a True Burner: Even with CeeDee and potentially Pickens, this team lacks a consistent vertical threat. Adding a veteran speedster on a cheap one-year deal (like a Rashid Shaheed) would open up the intermediate routes where Lamb thrives.
The 2025 season was a mess, but the talent in the receiver room isn't the problem. The problem is the hierarchy. Once Dallas decides who is staying and who is going, Dak Prescott might actually have the weapons he needs to get back into the playoff hunt.