You've finally gathered your high-tier Doomstack. You’ve spent forty turns carefully nurturing your economy, managing public order, and finally—finally—you have a full 20-stack of Exalted Bloodletters ready to paint the world red. You click to attack a minor settlement in the heart of the Empire. The loading screen fades, and your heart sinks. It’s that one map. The one with the weird choke point on the left and the single hill in the back that you’ve played approximately four hundred times since launch. It’s frustrating. It’s boring. Honestly, it’s one of the biggest reasons people eventually burn out on the game.
Total War: Warhammer 3 is a massive, sprawling masterpiece of fantasy logistics and tactical violence, but it has a repetitive map problem. When players complain about Warhammer 3 same maps over and over, they aren't just being whiny. There’s a mechanical reason why this happens, and it’s tied deeply into how Creative Assembly (CA) handles "procedural" versus "static" map selection across the Immortal Empires campaign.
The Geography of Boredom: Why Map Variety Fails
The problem isn't that there are only ten maps in the game. Far from it. There are hundreds. However, the game’s logic for selecting which map you actually fight on is based on the specific X and Y coordinates of your lord on the campaign map. If you are fighting in a specific region of Reikland, you are almost guaranteed to pull from a very small "pool" of maps designated for that climate and terrain type.
Think about it this way. If you spend most of your time playing as Karl Franz, you’re constantly fighting in temperate forests. If the "Temperate Forest" pool for minor settlements only has five or six layouts, you’re going to see them constantly. It doesn't matter that there are beautiful, unique maps in the Chaos Dwarves’ territory or the jungles of Lustria. If you don't go there, they don't exist for you.
Variety is locked behind travel. But even then, some climates are notoriously "thin" on assets.
The Minor Settlement Dilemma
Early in the life of Warhammer 3, every minor settlement battle was a siege-lite affair with towers and barricades. Fans hated it. It was a slog. CA responded by making most minor settlement battles "land battles" unless the settlement has a specific wall building. While this fixed the pace of the game, it accidentally made the map repetition worse. By reverting to land battles, the game pulls from a pool of generic field maps that often feel indistinguishable from one another.
You’ve seen the "flat field with three clumps of trees" map. You know the one. It’s basically the default setting for half the Old World. When you encounter Warhammer 3 same maps over and over, you're often seeing the result of a map-weighting system that prioritizes "fairness" and AI navigation over visual uniqueness. The AI struggles with complex terrain. It gets confused by too many cliffs or narrow passages. So, the maps that stay in the rotation tend to be the "safer" ones where the AI won't accidentally trap itself in a corner.
The Science of "Map Pools" and Biomes
Creative Assembly uses a biome-based system. Each province is tagged. A province in the Mountains of Mourn is tagged as "Ogre Mountains." This sounds great in theory, but in practice, the assets used to build these maps are often reused to the point of invisibility.
- Temperate: Green grass, deciduous trees, maybe a small farmhouse.
- Desert: Sand. More sand. A rock.
- Frozen: White ground, some pine trees.
Because the tactical objectives in land battles are non-existent—you just kill the other guy—the terrain is the only thing providing flavor. When the terrain is identical, the flavor vanishes. Players on Reddit and the Total War forums have been documenting this for years. A common realization is that even if the "layout" is slightly different, the visual identity is so consistent that your brain registers it as the same map. It's a psychological fatigue as much as a technical one.
Does the AI Cheat the Map Selection?
Not really, but it feels like it. The AI tends to retreat into the same defensive positions. Because the AI is programmed to seek high ground or forest cover, and because these maps are designed with specific "power positions," every battle on the same map plays out in the exact same way. You deploy here. They deploy there. You meet in the middle. Repeat until the heat death of the universe.
How the Community Fixed the Problem
If you are tired of the Warhammer 3 same maps over and over, you need to look at the Steam Workshop. The modding community has basically done the heavy lifting that CA hasn't quite managed yet.
There are "Map Packs" that inject hundreds of custom-made layouts into the campaign's map selection logic. Some of these maps are ports from Warhammer 1 and 2, which had a different design philosophy. Others are completely original.
The most famous is arguably the "GCCM" (Grand Campaign Custom Maps) project, though its compatibility with Warhammer 3 has been a rollercoaster. When it works, it’s a revelation. You’ll fight in a city that actually feels like a city, or a forest that feels ancient and oppressive rather than a few scattered props on a green plane.
The Hard Truth About Official Updates
CA has added maps. With the Shadows of Change and Thrones of Decay updates, new battlefields were introduced. But here’s the kicker: they are often tied to specific "Quest Battles" or the new DLC factions’ starting areas. If you’re still playing an old-school Grimgor Ironhide campaign, you might not see the new stuff for 50 turns.
The developers are in a tough spot. They have to balance "readability" (the player knowing exactly what is happening) with "variety." If a map is too unique, it can be frustrating to play. Remember the bridge battles from older Total War games? They were unique, sure, but they were also a nightmare of broken pathfinding and cheese. CA has leaned toward "boring but functional," which is why we feel the repetition so acutely.
Break the Loop: Actionable Ways to See New Ground
You don't have to wait for a patch that might never come. You can change how you play to force the game to give you variety.
First, stop fighting in the same place. This sounds obvious, but the "same maps" complaint usually comes from players who spend 100 turns slowly expanding through one specific climate. If you're playing as High Elves, get out of Ulthuan. Send an expedition to the Southlands. The game’s map pool changes entirely once you hit the desert or the jungle.
Second, use the "Change Starting Location" mod. It’s a literal game-changer. Starting Balthasar Gelt in the middle of Cathay changes every single tactical encounter you have for the first three hours of your campaign. You’ll see maps you didn't even know existed.
Third, force more Siege Battles. Since minor settlement battles became land battles by default, the variety dropped. If you actually build the garrison buildings in your own settlements, you force the AI to fight you on the settlement maps, which are inherently more complex and varied than the open fields.
Check Your Settings
Sometimes, the "same maps" feeling is exacerbated by low graphical settings. When "Terrain Detail" and "Grass" are turned down, the subtle differences in maps—the little gullies, the rock formations, the puddles—disappear. Everything looks like a flat, brown-green smear. If your rig can handle it, crank the terrain shadows and texture quality. It won't change the layout, but it might stop your brain from glazing over.
The Future of Warhammer 3 Maps
Is there hope? Maybe. CA has been more responsive lately. They know the "land battle" fix was a band-aid. There are rumors and hints in the dev blogs about a more robust map-tagging system that could allow for more "wildcard" maps to appear regardless of the specific biome.
📖 Related: Why The Dead by Daylight Plague is Actually the Hardest Killer to Master
Until then, the reality is that Total War: Warhammer 3 is a victim of its own scale. With so many factions and such a massive world, the "generic" pools have to do a lot of heavy lifting.
To get the most out of your next campaign and avoid the Warhammer 3 same maps over and over slog, take these steps:
- Download a Map Pack: Search the Steam Workshop for "Land Battle Map Pack" or "Campaign Tree" mods. These expand the pool of coordinates that trigger specific maps.
- Aggressive Expansion: Move your armies into different biomes every 20 turns. If you're in the snow, head for the mountains. If you're in the plains, head for the swamp.
- Manual Battles only when Necessary: Use Auto-resolve for the "field with three trees" maps. Save your manual battle energy for the weird, unique, or high-stakes encounters. This prevents "tactical burnout."
- Try the Laboratory: If you just want to see what the game is capable of, go into the custom battle menu and look at the "unique" or "quest" maps. It’ll remind you that the variety is there; it’s just hidden behind the campaign’s rigid logic.
The game isn't broken, but the map rotation is definitely "sticky." By understanding that the game is just looking at your GPS coordinates and picking from a tiny list, you can manipulate your movement to find the hidden gems scattered across the Immortal Empires map. Stop fighting for the same three hills in Reikland and go see what the rest of the world has to offer.