You’re settling in for a movie night, ready to finally catch up on Yellowjackets or maybe rewatch Dexter, and there it is. That annoying little padlock. It’s sitting right on the corner of the thumbnail. You click it, and instead of a play button, you get a prompt asking you to upgrade your plan. It feels like a bait-and-switch, doesn't it? Honestly, the Showtime titles lock icon Paramount Plus shows users is one of the most common points of frustration since Paramount Global decided to smash its two biggest streaming brands together into one app.
The short version? You’re seeing that lock because your current subscription tier doesn't include the Showtime library. But the "why" and the "how to fix it" are a bit more tangled thanks to how Paramount restructured their pricing back in mid-2023.
The Great Streaming Merger Mess
Streaming used to be simple. You paid for one thing, you got that thing. Then Paramount decided to integrate Showtime directly into the Paramount+ interface. They didn't just add the content; they rebranded the entire top-tier service to "Paramount+ with SHOWTIME." If you are on the "Paramount+ Essential" plan, which is the cheaper, ad-supported version, you are basically looking through a glass window at a party you aren't invited to.
That lock icon is a digital gatekeeper. It’s there to remind you that while the app contains those prestige dramas and first-run movies, your specific login credentials don't unlock them. It’s a classic upselling tactic.
Back when Showtime was a standalone app, you wouldn't even see the shows if you didn't pay for them. Now, they are mixed into your home screen, taunting you. It’s a bit like a supermarket putting the expensive steaks right next to the ground beef. You see what you’re missing.
Why Your Old Subscription Might Be the Culprit
Here is where it gets weird for long-time users. Maybe you’ve been a subscriber for years. You might even be on a "Legacy" plan. If you were paying for the old commercial-free plan before the Showtime merger became official, you might have been grandfathered into a tier that still doesn't include Showtime.
Paramount shifted the goalposts. They retired the $9.99 "Premium" plan and replaced it with the $11.99 "Paramount+ with SHOWTIME" plan. If your billing hasn't updated or if you are subscribed through a third-party bundle—think Walmart+, T-Mobile, or an older Amazon Prime Video Channel—the system might see you as an "Essential" or "Base" member.
Hence, the lock.
Spotting the Lock Before You Click
It’s not just on the main series page. You’ll see the Showtime titles lock icon Paramount Plus uses across various categories:
- The "Shows" Tab: Even if the show itself is a Paramount+ original, certain seasons might be gated if they were co-productions.
- Live TV: If you try to access the live Showtime channel feeds within the Paramount app, those will almost certainly have the lock icon if you aren't on the top tier.
- The Search Bar: Often, when you search for a movie like Pearl or Everything Everywhere All At Once, it’ll pop up in the results, but that tiny lock will be staring back at you.
It's actually a pretty effective bit of UI design, even if it's annoying. It prevents you from sitting through a 30-second ad only to be told at the very last second that you can't watch the actual movie.
How to Get Rid of the Lock Permanently
If you’re tired of seeing it, there is really only one path forward: you have to pay the "Showtime tax."
You need to go into your account settings. If you’re billed directly through ParamountPlus.com, it’s a simple toggle to move from Essential to the Showtime tier. However, if you are billed through Apple, Google Play, or Roku, you usually have to manage that through their respective subscription hubs.
The Walmart+ and Partner Complication
A huge chunk of people see the lock because of the Walmart+ partnership. Walmart+ gives you Paramount+ Essential for free. That’s great for Survivor or Star Trek, but it specifically excludes Showtime. Upgrading from a partner-provided plan is notoriously glitchy. Sometimes you have to cancel the free version entirely and start a fresh paid subscription to get that lock icon to vanish. It’s a headache, honestly.
Is It a Bug or a Feature?
Sometimes, the lock appears even when you know you pay for it. This is a genuine technical glitch.
If you are 100% certain you are on the Paramount+ with SHOWTIME plan and you still see locks, try the "Restore Purchases" button in the settings if you're on an iPhone or Apple TV. If that fails, the old "log out and log back in" trick usually forces the app to re-verify your subscription status with the server.
Streaming apps are basically just fancy web browsers. Sometimes the "cache"—the temporary memory—gets stuck thinking you’re still a "Basic" subscriber.
✨ Don't miss: Why The Recruit Cast Season 1 Actually Worked Better Than We Expected
Specific Titles That Trigger the Lock
Keep an eye out for these heavy hitters. If you see these, and you see a lock, you’re looking at Showtime-exclusive content:
- Billions
- The Chi
- Yellowjackets
- Mayor of Kingstown (Wait—actually, this is a Paramount+ Original, but sometimes licensing in different regions makes it wonky!)
- Fellow Travelers
- The Curse
What You Should Do Next
Don't just stare at the lock. If you really want that content, check your billing date. The best way to handle the Showtime titles lock icon Paramount Plus issue is to wait until a day or two before your current month expires.
- Check your billing source. Look at your bank statement. Does it say "Paramount Plus," "Apple," or "Roku"?
- Verify your tier. Log in via a web browser (not the TV app, which is limited). Look for "Plan Type."
- Look for promo codes. Paramount is famous for "come back" deals. If you cancel your current plan, they will often offer you the Showtime tier for half price for a few months.
- Clear the cache. If you pay for Showtime but see the lock on a Roku or Fire Stick, go to Settings > Applications > Paramount+ > Clear Cache.
The lock icon isn't a permanent broken feature; it's just a digital "No Entry" sign. Once you upgrade, the icons usually disappear instantly, and those thumbnails will finally show a "Watch Now" button instead.