You’ve seen the yard signs. They start popping up months, sometimes even a full year, before the big general election in November. Most people sort of glaze over until the "real" election happens, but honestly? By then, the biggest decisions have usually already been made for you. If you want to understand how power actually shifts in this country, you have to look at what is a primary in politics. It’s the gatekeeper. It’s the filter. It’s where the real drama—and the real policy shift—usually goes down.
Basically, a primary is just an election to decide who gets to be on the ballot for a specific political party. Think of it like the playoffs before the Super Bowl. You can't just show up to the championship game; you have to win your division first.
The "Invisible" Election That Runs the Show
A primary in politics isn't just a single event. It’s a messy, state-by-state patchwork of rules that can make your head spin if you look at it too long. In the United States, we don't have one national primary day. Instead, we have a calendar that stretches from the snowy Iowa caucuses (though Iowa's role has changed recently for Democrats) all the way through the heat of the summer.
Why do we do it this way?
Control. Back in the day—we’re talking late 19th and early 20th centuries—candidates were picked by "party bosses" in literal smoke-filled rooms. If you weren't a political insider, you had zero say in who the Democratic or Republican nominee was. The primary system was a Progressive Era reform meant to give that power back to regular people. It was supposed to be more democratic, but it’s also made our politics way more expensive and, some argue, way more polarized.
Open vs. Closed: The Great Filter
Here is where it gets tricky. Depending on where you live, you might not even be allowed to vote in a primary.
- In a closed primary, you have to be a registered member of that party. If you're an Independent in a state like New York or Florida, you’re often just stuck on the sidelines while the partisans pick the menu.
- An open primary is a bit of a free-for-all. You can walk in and choose which party’s ballot you want to fill out. You can't vote in both, but you get to choose your "lane" for that day.
There are also "semi-closed" primaries and the "top-two" systems used in places like California and Washington. In a top-two primary, every candidate is on one big list, and the top two finishers move on to the general election—even if they’re both from the same party. It’s wild. It leads to November elections where it’s a Democrat vs. a Democrat, which totally changes how candidates have to campaign.
✨ Don't miss: Who Has Trump Pardoned So Far: What Really Happened with the 47th President's List
Why Primaries Create Extremes
You’ve probably noticed that politicians seem way more extreme than the average person you meet at the grocery store. There’s a reason for that, and it’s baked into the primary system.
The math is simple: turnout.
In a general election, maybe 60% of people show up. In a primary? You’re lucky if you get 20%. The people who show up for a primary in politics are usually the most passionate, the most ideologically driven, and the most "online" members of the party. If a candidate wants to win that 20%, they can't be a middle-of-the-road moderate. They have to appeal to the base.
This leads to the "primarying" phenomenon. It’s a verb now. To "primary" someone means a more extreme candidate challenges a sitting incumbent from within their own party. Think of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez unseating Joe Crowley in 2018, or Eric Cantor’s shock loss to Dave Brat in 2014. These weren't losses to the "other side"—they were losses to their own side for not being "pure" enough.
Caucuses: The Weird Cousin of the Primary
We can't talk about a primary in politics without mentioning caucuses. They are weird. Instead of walking into a booth, marking a circle, and leaving, you have to go to a school gym or a church basement and literally stand in a corner for your candidate.
It’s high-commitment. It’s loud. It’s basically a neighborhood meeting that ends in a vote.
🔗 Read more: Why the 2013 Moore Oklahoma Tornado Changed Everything We Knew About Survival
The Iowa Caucus used to be the "Kingmaker," but after the 2020 reporting disaster and shifting demographics, the Democratic National Committee (DNC) stripped Iowa of its first-in-the-nation status, moving South Carolina to the front of the line for 2024. The Republicans, however, stuck with Iowa. This creates a split reality where the two parties are operating on completely different maps.
The Power of "The Frontloader"
States are always fighting to move their primaries earlier in the year. Why? Because by the time June rolls around, the nominee is usually already decided. If you vote in a late-June primary, you're basically just performing a civic ritual for a race that ended in March. This is called "frontloading." States like New Hampshire and South Carolina have outsized influence because they go first. They winnow the field. If a candidate doesn't perform well there, their funding dries up, the media stops covering them, and they drop out before the rest of the country even gets a chance to see their name on a ballot.
Delegates: The Points That Actually Matter
When you vote in a primary, you aren't technically voting for the candidate. You’re voting for delegates.
These are real human beings who go to the big national conventions in the summer to officially cast their votes.
- Democrats use a proportional system. If you get 20% of the vote, you get roughly 20% of the delegates.
- Republicans often use "winner-take-all" rules in certain states. If you win by one vote, you get every single delegate from that state.
- This is why a Republican race can end much faster than a Democratic one.
Then there’s the "Superdelegate" (or "Automatic Delegate") controversy. These are party elites—Congress members, former Presidents—who get a vote just because of who they are. After the 2016 friction between Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders supporters, the Democrats changed the rules so these insiders can't vote on the first ballot unless the nominee is already a "slam dunk." It was a huge shift in how the party handles its internal power dynamics.
Does the Primary System Need a Reboot?
A lot of experts think the current system is broken. They argue it forces candidates to the fringes and leaves the "exhausted middle" of America without a voice.
💡 You might also like: Ethics in the News: What Most People Get Wrong
One big idea gaining steam is Ranked Choice Voting (RCV).
Instead of picking one person, you rank them: 1, 2, 3. If your first choice loses, your vote moves to your second choice. Alaska and Maine are already doing this. It’s designed to reward candidates who have broad appeal rather than just a small, intense base.
Another critique is the "First-in-the-Nation" status. Critics ask: Why should a tiny, relatively non-diverse state like New Hampshire get to decide who is "viable" for the rest of us? It’s a fair question. The demographic makeup of the early states doesn't always reflect the makeup of the country, which can lead to candidates being ignored who might actually be very popular in more urban or diverse areas.
How to Actually Use This Information
If you want to have an impact, you have to stop thinking of November as the only game in town. The primary in politics is where the direction of the party is set. If you wait until the general election to complain that you don't like either candidate, you've already missed your best chance to change the outcome.
Check your registration. Right now. Seriously.
Many states require you to register with a party months in advance if you want to vote in their closed primary. If you’re an Independent, look up your state's rules to see if you're even allowed to participate. In states like California, you can sometimes request a "crossover" ballot, but you have to know to ask for it.
Actionable Steps for the Next Election Cycle
- Find Your "Early" Date: Don't look for the November date. Look for your state’s primary or caucus date. Put it on your calendar with a "two-week warning" alert.
- Check Your "Party Affiliation": If you live in a closed-primary state, you might need to change your registration from "Unaffiliated" to a specific party just to get a ballot. You can always change it back later.
- Research Down-Ballot: Primaries aren't just for Presidents. They’re for Sheriffs, District Attorneys, and State Legislators. These are the people who actually decide how your local laws are enforced.
- Ignore the National Noise: Focus on what candidates are saying about your specific community. National media loves the horse race, but local primaries are about who's going to fix your specific bridge or fund your specific school district.
The primary system is complicated, sometimes frustrating, and definitely weird. But it's the only tool we've got to prevent a return to those smoke-filled rooms of the 1900s. It only works if people who aren't "political junkies" actually show up. If you stay home, you're letting the loudest 10% of the country decide who you get to choose from in November. Don't give away your power that easily.