You’re standing at a picnic table in the middle of North Province, desperately trying to balance a single cherry tomato on top of a mountain of chorizo. One slip of the Joy-Con and your Master-class creation becomes a pile of "Tasty Original" garbage. It's frustrating. We've all been there, swearing at the screen because the physics engine decided a piece of lettuce has the friction of an ice cube.
But here is the thing: most players are doing too much.
The sandwich guide Pokemon Scarlet community has spent years perfecting recipes, but the game doesn't actually care if your sandwich looks like a Five Guys burger or a tragic kitchen accident. It cares about the math. If you want those Shiny Sparking Power Level 3 boosts, you don't need sixty ingredients. You need a specific threshold of points.
Honestly, the picnic mechanic is the most chaotic addition to the franchise since the introduction of friendship-based evolutions that nobody asked for. It’s a hidden spreadsheet disguised as a cooking mini-game.
💡 You might also like: The Adventures of Cookie and Cream PS2: Why This Weird Co-op Game Still Breaks Brains
The Absolute Basics of Sandwich Logic
Stop overthinking the bread. Seriously. You can literally throw the top bun off into the grass—in fact, you should. It saves space and prevents the physics engine from collapsing your stack.
Sandwiches in Paldea are governed by three main variables: Type, Power, and Level. Every ingredient you drop onto that bread adds a specific value to a hidden tally. Once you hit the magic number for a specific type (like Fire or Ghost), the game grants you the corresponding "Meal Power."
Most people use a sandwich guide Pokemon Scarlet to hunt Shinies. That means you’re looking for three specific powers: Sparking Power, Title Power, and Encounter Power. To get these at Level 3, you usually need Herba Mystica. There's no way around it. You have to grind those 5 and 6-star raids. It’s a chore, but the payoff is a pink Celebi—wait, no, Celebi isn't in this one—a pink Lechonk. Much better.
Why Herba Mystica Changes Everything
If you’re just starting out, don't waste your rare herbs on a whim. Salty Herba Mystica is the "gold standard" because it's the most flexible for forcing Encounter Power. However, since the Version 1.1.0 update, we found out that you can mix and match almost any two herbs to get the same results, provided you use the right base ingredients.
For instance, two Salty Herba Mysticas used to be the only "meta" way to get Sparking Power 3. Now, you can use one Spicy and one Sweet if you balance it with the right type-specific food. It’s about the sum, not the specific item.
The "One Ingredient" Method You Should Be Using
Forget the pre-made recipes the game gives you. They’re mostly useless for high-level hunting. The real pros use the "Creative Mode."
Let's say you're hunting a Iron Valiant. You need Fairy or Fighting type boosts. Instead of piling on five different meats, you can use one single serving of Tomato for Fairy or Pickles for Fighting, then add two Herba Mysticas. That’s it. One slice of food and two herbs.
The game calculates the "dominant type" based on the ingredient with the highest value.
- Normal: Rice
- Fire: Red Bell Pepper
- Water: Cucumber
- Electric: Yellow Bell Pepper
- Grass: Lettuce
- Ice: Klawf Stick
- Fighting: Pickle
- Poison: Green Bell Pepper
- Ground: Ham
- Flying: Prosciutto
- Psychic: Onion
- Bug: Cherry Tomato
- Rock: Jalapeño
- Ghost: Red Onion
- Dragon: Avocado
- Steel: Hamburger
- Dark: Smoked Fillet
- Fairy: Tomato
It's almost too simple. You just pick the type you want, use one portion of that ingredient, and add two Salty Herba Mysticas. Boom. Level 3 boosts across the board. If you don't have Salty, you might need to add two or three portions of the type-ingredient to overcome the "offset" from the other herb types.
Dealing With the "Physics" Nightmare
The physics in the sandwich mini-game are, frankly, a disaster. I have seen Chorizo slices fly across the screen with the velocity of a bullet because they touched a piece of cheese at the wrong angle.
Here is the trick: stack from the center out. Don't try to make it look pretty. The game doesn't give a "Beauty" bonus like the old Contests. If you have to stack six pieces of Prosciutto, lay them in a flat, overlapping circle. And again, throw away the top bun. When the game asks you to place the top bread, just drop it into the void next to the plate. You still get the full 30-minute buff, and you won't risk knocking your ingredients off the plate at the last second.
The Town Method vs. The Picnic Method
A lot of players overlook the shops in Mesagoza, Cascarrafa, and Levincia. While a sandwich guide Pokemon Scarlet focuses on the picnic, sometimes it's faster to just buy a meal.
If you aren't hunting Shinies and just want to hatch eggs faster, don't bother making a sandwich. Fly to Mesagoza, go to the Gastronomy Enclave, and buy the Five-Alarm Ceviche. It gives you Egg Power Level 2. It’s cheap, instant, and you don't have to play the stacking mini-game.
However, shops will never give you Level 3 powers. Those are strictly gated behind the picnic table and the Herba Mystica grind. If you’re trying to find a Shiny Roaring Moon, you're going to have to get your hands dirty with some Avocado and Salty Herbs.
Common Mistakes That Kill Your Buffs
- Using too many different types: If you mix Tomato (Fairy) and Onion (Psychic) in equal amounts, the game might get confused and give you a boost for a type you weren't even targeting. Stick to one "type" ingredient.
- Missing the plate: If an ingredient falls off the bread, it's gone. If too many fall off, your "Power Level" drops from 3 to 2, or even 1. This is why we toss the top bun.
- The "Sweet" Herb trap: Sweet and Sour Herba Mysticas are generally considered the "worst" because they don't contribute as much to the Encounter Power threshold. If you're using these, you almost always have to add more of your base ingredient (like three servings of Onion instead of one) to make up the difference.
- Multiplayer Desync: Making sandwiches with friends is technically more efficient because you can share ingredients, but the lag is real. Often, what looks like a perfect sandwich on your screen is a mess on theirs. If you're going for a serious hunt, do it solo unless you've practiced with your group.
Secret Ingredients and Where to Get Them
You can't just find everything at the Every Wich Way shop. Some of the best ingredients, like Wasabi, Horseradish, and Curry Powder, are exclusive to the Aquiesta Supermarket in Levincia.
Why does this matter? Because certain seasonings provide massive boosts to the "Point" totals required for Level 3 powers without adding a lot of physical bulk to the sandwich. If you're trying to make a complex recipe without Herba Mystica (which is possible for Level 2, but very hard for Level 3), you'll need these high-value seasonings.
Practical Next Steps for Your Shiny Hunt
To get the most out of your next session, follow this workflow:
- Disable Autosave: This is the most important step. Before you make a sandwich, turn off autosave and save manually. If the sandwich fails or you don't find your Shiny within the 30-minute window, just close the game and restart. You’ll get your rare Herba Mysticas back.
- Clear the Area: Make sure you're standing exactly where the Pokemon you want to hunt spawns. For example, if you want Shiny Iron Valiant, go to the hidden cave in Area Zero first, then set up the picnic.
- Check Your Status: Press the Right D-Pad button to check your active Meal Powers. If you see Sparking Power: [Type] Level 3, you're good to go.
- The "Town Reset": If you are hunting in an area near a town gate, you can skip the picnic reset. Just walk into the town and walk back out. This despawns everything and forces new spawns immediately, maximizing your 30-minute timer.
The system is weird, but once you stop trying to follow the in-game recipes and start treating it like a math problem, it becomes the most powerful tool in your Paldean journey. Stop building towers. Start building math. Toss the bread. Get the Shiny. It's really that simple.