You've been running around Area Zero for three hours. Your eyes are strained, your Switch is getting warm, and despite that sparkling "Level 3" buff sitting in the corner of your screen, you haven't seen a single pink, gold, or lime-green variant of anything. It’s frustrating. Honestly, it’s enough to make you want to close the game and go play something else. But here’s the thing about pokemon scarlet shiny sandwich recipes: most people are making them way harder than they need to be.
The community spent months after launch arguing over whether you needed exactly two Salty Herba Mystica or if a Bitter and a Spicy would do the trick. It was a mess. But we’ve finally cracked the code on how the sandwich mechanics actually function under the hood. It isn't just about the herbs; it's about how the game calculates the "points" for each ingredient you drop on that baguette. If you mess up the physics and a single piece of lettuce slides off the bread, you might lose the very buff you spent forty minutes raiding for.
The Math Behind the Sparkle
Every ingredient in Paldea has a hidden value. You’ve got Sparkling Power, Title Power, and Encounter Power. To get that coveted Level 3 in all three categories, you need to hit specific numerical thresholds. For most types, that means reaching 280 points in a specific element.
It sounds like a lot of homework. It isn't.
Basically, the game looks at the dominant flavor and the dominant ingredient type. If you’re hunting a Roaring Moon, you want Dragon or Dark. If you’re looking for a Flutter Mane, you need Ghost or Fairy. The most common mistake? Overcomplicating the fillings. You don't need a mountain of ham to find a shiny Lechonk. In fact, the "Simple Recipe" movement, pioneered by players like SilentDestroyer on Twitter and various Discord researchers, proved that you can get the same results with just one or two ingredient slots.
Why Herba Mystica is the Gatekeeper
You can't do this without Herba Mystica. Period. These salty, sweet, sour, bitter, and spicy plants are the only way to trigger "Sparkling Power." You get them from 5-star and 6-star Tera Raids.
But not all herbs are created equal. Salty is the gold standard because it provides a massive boost to the "Sparkling" stat without pushing the flavors into weird territory. If you have two Salty Herba Mysticas, you can basically throw a single piece of any main ingredient on a bun and call it a day. For example, one piece of Basil and two Salty Herba Mysticas gives you Fire-type Sparkling, Title, and Encounter Level 3. It’s that simple.
The "Any Two Herbs" Strategy
Let’s talk about the recipe that changed the game. For a long time, players thought they were locked into specific pairings. They thought if they didn't have Salty, they were out of luck. That’s wrong.
You can use almost any two Herba Mysticas as long as you balance the ingredients. This is huge for players who have a surplus of Sweet or Sour herbs, which are usually considered the "trash" drops from raids.
💡 You might also like: Thinking game streaming: Why watching people solve puzzles is actually taking over Twitch
To make this work for any type, you generally need:
- 1x of a specific "Type" ingredient (like Onion for Ghost or Tomato for Fairy).
- 2x Salty Herba Mystica.
OR, if you don't have Salty:
- 1x of a specific "Type" ingredient.
- 1x Cucumber.
- 1x Pickle.
- Any 2x Herba Mystica (except certain combinations like 1 Sweet + 1 Sour, which can occasionally nullify the Encounter power).
Actually, let's look at the Ghost-type hunt. If you’re in those spooky ruins looking for a shiny Greavard, just use one Red Onion and two Salty herbs. Boom. Level 3 buffs across the board. If you're out of Salty, use a Red Onion, a Pickle, a Cucumber, and any other two herbs. Just be careful with the physics. If that Red Onion slides off, you've just wasted your rare ingredients.
Common Mistakes That Kill Your Odds
Physics matter. I can't stress this enough.
The sandwich mini-game in Pokemon Scarlet and Violet is notoriously janky. When you’re stacking six pieces of Chorizo for a Fire-type sandwich, the collision boxes are nightmare fuel. If an ingredient falls off the table, it doesn't count toward your total. If you lose enough pieces, your Sparkling Power Level 3 might drop to a Level 2, or worse, change the Type entirely.
Pro Tip: You don't actually need the top bun. When you're finished placing your ingredients, just aim the top bun away from the sandwich and drop it on the table. The game still counts the sandwich as complete, and you avoid the risk of the bun knocking your carefully stacked peppers into the abyss.
The Pickle/Cucumber Myth
You'll see a lot of infographics floating around Reddit claiming you must use Pickles and Cucumbers for every non-salty recipe. While they are great "filler" ingredients because they contribute to Encounter power without skewing the type too much, they aren't always mandatory if you know what you're doing with the "Type" ingredients. However, for a beginner, keeping a stack of Pickles in your bag is the safest way to ensure your pokemon scarlet shiny sandwich recipes don't fail.
Essential Ingredients for Every Type
If you want to be efficient, you need to stock up at Aquiesta Supermarket in Levincia. Don't bother wandering around the small shops in Mesagoza. Levincia has everything in one spot.
📖 Related: Why 4 in a row online 2 player Games Still Hook Us After 50 Years
Here is what you need to keep in your inventory for specific shiny hunts:
- Normal: Rice or Chorizo (though Chorizo is bulky and annoying to stack).
- Fire: Basil or Red Bell Pepper.
- Water: Cucumber or Filet.
- Grass: Lettuce or Jalapeño.
- Electric: Yellow Bell Pepper.
- Ice: Klawf Stick (expensive, but worth it).
- Fighting: Pickles.
- Poison: Green Bell Pepper.
- Ground: Ham.
- Flying: Prosciutto.
- Psychic: Onion.
- Bug: Cherry Tomato.
- Rock: Bacon.
- Ghost: Red Onion.
- Dragon: Avocado.
- Steel: Hamburger.
- Dark: Smoked Fillet.
- Fairy: Tomato.
If you’re hunting Roaring Moon (Scarlet) or Iron Valiant (Violet), you’re looking at a Dragon or Fairy hunt. Avocado or Tomato. That’s your bread and butter. Literally.
The Reset Trick: Don't Waste Your Herbs
This is the most important part of the process. Herba Mystica is rare. The drop rates in 5-star raids are roughly 10%, and even then, it's a random herb. You can easily go ten raids without seeing a single one.
Turn off Autosave. Before you set up your picnic, manually save your game. Make your sandwich. Go to your hunt location. If thirty minutes pass and you don't find your shiny, close the software and restart. You’ll be back at your save point with all your ingredients intact. Never, ever let the game save after a failed sandwich run. It’s a waste of resources that takes hours to grind back.
Finding the Best Hunt Locations
A recipe is only as good as the spot you use it in. You want "Isolated Encounters." This is a technique where you stand in a specific spot where only one species of a certain type can spawn.
For example, if you use a Fighting-type sandwich in the North Province (Area Two) bamboo forest, you’ll be flooded with Passimian or Mankey. But if you use an Electric-type sandwich in certain parts of the cave systems, you might isolate just one evolutionary line.
Check the Pokedex. Look at the "Habitat" tab. If the gold area on the map for a Pokémon is small and doesn't overlap with other creatures of the same type, that's your honey hole. North Province Area Three is famous for Fairy types. The Casseroya Lake is the king of Water and Dragon types.
Nuance in the "Sparkling" Experience
Sometimes, even with a perfect recipe, you won't find the shiny. It’s still RNG. The sandwich brings your odds down from 1 in 4096 to approximately 1 in 683 (if you have the Shiny Charm). Those are great odds, but they aren't a guarantee.
👉 See also: Lust Academy Season 1: Why This Visual Novel Actually Works
I’ve had hunts where I found three shiny Tatsugiri in ten minutes. I’ve had others where I went through four sandwich resets before a single shiny Shroodle appeared. It’s the nature of the beast. Don't get discouraged.
Also, keep an eye on the weather. Rain reduces visibility. Sandstorms in the Asado Desert are a nightmare for spotting subtle shinies like Phanpy or Silicobra. If the weather is bad, wait it out or move to a different province.
How to Handle Shiny Outbreaks
Mass Outbreaks are the final piece of the puzzle. When you see a flashing icon on your map, that’s an outbreak.
- Go to the outbreak.
- Defeat 60 of that Pokémon (use Let’s Go mode to speed this up). A message will say "There are not many [Pokemon] left from the original outbreak."
- Save your game.
- Set up your picnic and use your pokemon scarlet shiny sandwich recipes.
- Instead of running around, just open and close your picnic to "reset" the spawns around you.
This method gives you the absolute highest odds possible in the game. It’s how people end up with boxes full of shiny Pokémon.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Hunt
Ready to go? Here is exactly what you should do right now to prepare.
First, fly to Levincia and head to the Aquiesta Supermarket. Buy 50 Tomatoes, 50 Onions, 50 Pickles, and 50 Cucumbers. This is your "starter kit." It covers Fairy, Ghost, and the basic fillers for the non-Salty herb recipes.
Second, check your bag for Herba Mystica. If you don't have at least two, you need to grind raids. Look for 5 and 6-star raids on the map or join online via the Poke Portal. Focus on Blissey, Amoonguss, or Cetitan raids—they have higher drop rates for herbs than most other species.
Third, pick a target. Don't just wander. Choose one Pokémon you really want. Check its type, find its habitat, and make sure you have the right "Type" ingredient. Save your game manually before you even open the picnic menu.
Finally, remember the "No Top Bun" rule. It’s a lifesaver. Place your ingredients carefully, toss that bun to the side, and get out there. The sparkles are waiting.