Bread pudding is basically the ultimate kitchen comeback story. You start with a loaf of bread that’s so dry it could double as a brick, and somehow, through the magic of custard and heat, it turns into something elegant. But let’s be real. Most people mess up their challah bread pudding recipe because they treat the bread like an afterthought. They grab a fresh loaf, soak it for five minutes, and wonder why the middle feels like wet cardboard.
If you want that custardy, golden-brown perfection that famous chefs like Ina Garten or Martha Stewart rave about, you have to start with the right foundation. Challah is the undisputed king here. Why? Because it’s an enriched dough. It’s loaded with eggs and oil (or butter), which means it has a sturdy crumb that can absorb a ridiculous amount of liquid without completely disintegrating into mush.
The Science of the Soak
Here is the thing most recipes won't tell you: fresh bread is the enemy. Honestly. If you use a fresh, soft loaf of challah, the moisture already present in the bread blocks the custard from getting into the center. You end up with a puddle of cooked egg at the bottom of the dish and dry bread on top.
You need "stale" bread, but not "rotten" bread. There’s a difference. Professionals call this "staling," which is actually a process of starch retrogradation. To get your challah bread pudding recipe right, slice your loaf into one-inch cubes the night before. Leave them out on a baking sheet. No cover. No nothing. You want those cubes to feel like croutons. If you’re in a rush, you can cheat by popping them in a 300°F oven for about 10 or 15 minutes. Just don't toast them until they're brown; you just want to drive the moisture out.
Once the bread is dry, it acts like a sponge. When you pour that mix of heavy cream, whole milk, and eggs over the top, the dry starches literally pull the liquid into the heart of the cube.
The Ratio That Actually Works
Don't eyeball the custard. I’ve seen too many people just "pour until it looks wet." That’s a recipe for disaster. A standard, reliable ratio for a great custard is about one large egg for every cup of liquid.
For a standard 9x13 baking dish, you’re looking at:
- About 8 to 10 cups of cubed challah.
- 4 large eggs (plus maybe two yolks if you want it extra rich).
- 2 cups of whole milk.
- 1 cup of heavy cream.
- 3/4 cup of granulated sugar.
- A heavy hand of vanilla extract.
Mix the liquid first. Whisk those eggs like they owe you money. You don’t want any "slugs" of egg white hiding in the finished pudding. It's kinda gross when you bite into a sweet dessert and hit a patch of plain cooked egg white.
Why Challah Beats Brioche Every Single Time
People love to argue about this. Some folks swear by brioche. Sure, brioche is buttery. It’s fancy. But challah has a specific structural integrity that brioche lacks. Because challah is traditionally made without dairy (keeping it pareve in Jewish tradition), the fat content comes from oil and plenty of egg yolks. This creates a specific "shred" to the bread.
When you use a challah bread pudding recipe, that "shred" holds up against the heavy custard. Brioche tends to have a much higher butter content, which can sometimes make the pudding feel greasy rather than creamy. Challah stays bouncy. It’s got spirit.
Flavor Profiles and Common Mistakes
Vanilla is a given. But if that’s all you’re using, you’re leaving flavor on the table. A pinch of kosher salt is non-negotiable. Salt cuts through the fat of the cream and makes the sugar taste... well, more like sugar.
Think about texture. A lot of people dump raisins in there because that's what their grandma did. If you like raisins, cool. But try soaking them in bourbon or dark rum for twenty minutes first. It transforms them from little dried pebbles into flavor bombs. Or skip the fruit entirely and go for dark chocolate chunks and a hint of orange zest.
The Oven Temperature Trap
Do not bake this at 400°F. You aren't searing a steak. You are gently coagulating egg proteins. If the oven is too hot, the outside of the pudding will burn before the center sets. 350°F is the sweet spot.
📖 Related: Finding the Best Strawberry Shortcake in New York City: What the Food Blogs Usually Miss
Even better? Use a water bath, or bain-marie. Put your pudding dish inside a larger roasting pan and fill the roasting pan with hot water until it reaches halfway up the sides of the pudding dish. This creates a humid environment and ensures the edges don't get rubbery. It’s the secret to that "restaurant-style" texture that feels more like a custard than a cake.
Troubleshooting Your Challah Bread Pudding
Is it too dry? You probably didn't use enough liquid or you baked it too long. The center should still have a slight jiggle when you pull it out of the oven. It will firm up as it cools.
Is it too wet? You likely didn't let the bread stale enough, or you skimped on the eggs. Eggs are the binder. Without them, you just have soggy bread soup.
Is it bland? Check your salt and vanilla levels. Most home cooks under-season their sweets. Also, consider the sugar. Using half brown sugar and half white sugar adds a molasses depth that plain white sugar just can't touch.
Beyond the Basic Bake
Once you master the base challah bread pudding recipe, you can start getting weird with it. Savory bread pudding (often called a strata) is essentially the same thing but with cheese, sautéed leeks, and sausage instead of sugar and vanilla.
But for the sweet version, the topping is where you win the game. A simple dusting of powdered sugar is fine, but a salted caramel sauce or a crème anglaise poured over the top right before serving? That’s how you get people to ask for seconds.
The Resting Period
This is the hardest part. You take it out of the oven. It smells like heaven. You want to dive in. Don't.
Let it sit for at least 15 to 20 minutes. This allows the steam to settle and the custard to fully "set" around the bread fibers. If you cut it too early, the liquid will just run out of the cubes and pool at the bottom of the plate. Patience is a literal ingredient in this recipe.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Batch
- Buy the bread early: Purchase your challah two days before you plan to bake. Slice it immediately to increase the surface area for drying.
- The "Squish" Test: Before putting the pudding in the oven, press down on the bread cubes with a spoon. If the liquid doesn't easily submerge the bread, add another half-cup of milk.
- Temperature Check: Use an instant-read thermometer. The center of a perfectly cooked bread pudding should register between 160°F and 170°F.
- Storage: If you have leftovers (unlikely), they actually stay good in the fridge for about three days. Reheat in the oven at 300°F to keep the top crispy; the microwave will just make it sad and chewy.
- The Crust Factor: For a crunchy top, sprinkle a tablespoon of demerara or turbinado sugar over the surface in the last 10 minutes of baking. It creates a crackly crust that contrasts beautifully with the soft interior.