Why Your Cactus and Succulent Soil is Probably Killing Your Plants

You walk into a big-box store, grab a bag with a picture of a Saguaro on it, and head home thinking you've done right by your new Echeveria. Most people do this. Then, three months later, the bottom leaves turn into a yellow, translucent mush. You're confused. You barely watered it! Well, the truth is, the "cactus mix" you bought is likely holding onto water like a desperate sponge, and that’s the fastest way to turn a prize-winning succulent into a compost heap.

Standard potting soil is designed to retain moisture for thirsty plants like ferns or pothos. Cacti are different. They've evolved in places where it rains once in a blue moon and the water vanishes almost instantly through gravelly, porous ground. If you put those same roots in a peat-heavy commercial mix, you’re basically suffocating them in a wet blanket.

Honestly, finding the right cactus and succulent soil isn't about buying the most expensive bag; it's about understanding physics.

The Big Lie About Store-Bought Mixes

Most commercial "succulent" soils are still mostly peat moss. Peat is cheap. It looks dark and rich, which makes us humans feel like we’re giving our plants a "healthy" meal. But peat has a nasty habit: once it dries out completely, it becomes hydrophobic. It repels water. You pour water in, it runs down the sides of the pot, and the root ball stays bone dry. Conversely, once you finally get it wet, it stays wet for way too long.

In the wild, succulents like Lithops or Ariocarpus grow in mineral-heavy substrates. We're talking rocks, sand, and grit. There's almost zero organic matter.

When you use a peat-heavy cactus and succulent soil, you’re inviting Pythium and Phytophthora—root rot fungi—to dinner. It’s a slow death. You won't even see it happening until the plant collapses. Dr. Jeff Pavlat of the Austin Cactus and Succulent Society has often pointed out that drainage isn't just about the hole in the bottom of the pot; it's about the "interstitial space" between the particles in the soil. If those spaces are filled with soggy peat, there’s no oxygen. No oxygen means dead roots.

💡 You might also like: January 14, 2026: Why This Wednesday Actually Matters More Than You Think

Building the Perfect Mix: Grit is King

Forget "dirt." Think "drainage."

A solid DIY cactus and succulent soil usually follows a simple ratio, but you've got to tweak it based on your local humidity. If you live in humid Florida, you need way more grit than someone in bone-dry Arizona. A good starting point is one part organic matter to two parts inorganic "grit."

What counts as grit?

• Pumice: This is the gold standard. It’s volcanic rock filled with tiny holes. It holds a tiny bit of water but allows tons of air to reach the roots. It doesn't break down over time.
• Perlite: The white stuff that looks like Styrofoam. It’s cheap and easy to find. The downside? It floats to the top when you water and eventually turns a gross yellow color. It also crushes easily.
• Turface or Calcined Clay: These are high-fired clay bits often used on baseball fields. They’re great for adding weight and drainage.
• Chicken Grit: Usually crushed granite. It’s heavy and provides zero nutrients, but it’s fantastic for keeping the soil structure open.

For the organic side, coconut coir is often better than peat moss. It’s more sustainable and it re-wets much easier. Mix that with some sifted compost or even just a high-quality potting soil, and you're golden. Just make sure you sift out the big chunks of bark. Bark holds moisture and can harbor pests like fungus gnats.

The Secret Ingredient: Why Particle Size Actually Matters

Size matters. Seriously. If you mix fine sand with large gravel, the sand just fills the gaps between the gravel. This creates a concrete-like substance that prevents water from moving. This is why you should avoid "play sand" at all costs. It's too fine.

📖 Related: Black Red Wing Shoes: Why the Heritage Flex Still Wins in 2026

You want particles that are roughly 1/8 to 1/4 inch in size. This ensures that even when the soil is "saturated," there are still air pockets. Think of it like a jar of marbles versus a jar of sand. Water flies through the marbles. It lingers in the sand. Your cactus and succulent soil should behave more like the marbles.

Testing Your Soil at Home

Not sure if your mix is any good? Try the "Squeeze Test." Dampen your soil slightly and squeeze a handful in your fist.

1. If it stays in a tight, muddy ball: Throw it out or add more grit.
2. If it holds its shape for a second but crumbles when poked: It’s okay for hardier succulents.
3. If it won't even form a ball and just falls apart: Perfect.

That third option is what you want for picky species like Lophophora or Mammillaria. They want to be wet for a day, and then dry for a week.

Debunking the Drainage Layer Myth

We’ve all seen it on Pinterest: put a layer of rocks at the bottom of a glass jar or a pot without a hole. Stop doing this. Science calls this a "perched water table." Water doesn't easily move from a fine-textured material (soil) into a coarse-textured material (rocks) until the soil is completely saturated. By putting rocks at the bottom, you’re actually moving the water table closer to the roots, not away from them.

You need a drainage hole. Period. If you love a pot that doesn't have a hole, get a diamond drill bit and make one. Or use the "cachepot" method: keep the plant in a plastic nursery pot with holes, and set that inside the pretty decorative one.

👉 See also: Finding the Right Word That Starts With AJ for Games and Everyday Writing

Special Needs: Not All Succulents Want the Same Bed

While we group them together, a jungle cactus (like a Christmas Cactus or Schlumbergera) has vastly different needs than a desert cactus.

• Jungle Succulents: These are epiphytes. They grow on trees. They actually like a bit more organic matter and can handle some orchid bark or more coconut coir in their cactus and succulent soil.
• Mesembs (Living Stones): These are the drama queens. They need almost 90% inorganic grit. If they see a piece of peat moss, they might just decide to die out of spite.
• Winter Growers: Plants like Othonna or Ceraria grow when it’s cool. Their soil needs to be extra sharp-draining because evaporation is slower in the winter months.

Practical Steps for Success

If you're ready to fix your collection, don't just repot everything at once in the dead of winter. Wait for the growing season when the plants can recover from root disturbance.

1. Sift your ingredients. Use a kitchen colander or a specialized soil sieve to get rid of the "fines" (dust-sized particles). This prevents the bottom of the pot from becoming a silty graveyard.
2. Wash your pumice. Sometimes it comes covered in fine grey dust that can clog up the drainage. Give it a quick rinse.
3. Don't water immediately after repotting. This is the biggest mistake people make. When you repot, you inevitably break tiny hair-roots. If you pour water on those open wounds, they rot. Wait 3 to 7 days before the first drink to let the roots "callous" over.
4. Consider the pot material. Terracotta is porous and helps water evaporate through the sides. Plastic and ceramic hold moisture longer. If you use plastic, you need even more grit in your cactus and succulent soil to compensate.

Maintaining a healthy collection is less about a "green thumb" and more about engineering. If you get the substrate right, the watering becomes much more forgiving. You’ll find yourself worrying less about "how much" water to give and more about which beautiful new specimen you're going to buy next.

Stop treating your cacti like tropical houseplants. Give them the gritty, rocky, "terrible" soil they actually crave, and they’ll reward you with growth and flowers instead of rot and regret.